6 ms·
That’s great for you. How about all of the lost education of your classmates from teachers having to spend time and energy dealing with your pernicious individu
by rayiner 4y ago
That’s great for you. How about all of the lost education of your classmates from teachers having to spend time and energy dealing with your pernicious individualism?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoThat doesn’t mean that attack drones are the solution to unruly kids.
- rayiner 4y agoThe solution isn’t more of whatever we are doing now. We may have the worst behaved children in the entire world.
- para_parolu 4y agoMay or may not.
- Hamuko 4y ago>We may have the worst behaved children in the entire world. On what metric?
- moistly 4y agoSchool killings. Behavior doesn’t get worse than that, and it’s off the charts in America.
- Hamuko 4y agoBut does that mean that American are the worst behaved in the world, or the most armed?
- rayiner 4y agoThe US has been “the most armed” pretty much for its whole history. The fraction of households that own guns has been going down for decades, to the point where today it’s similar to where France was in the 1970s and 1980s. Yet school shootings are pretty much a phenomenon that began in the 1990s with the kids of boomers entering high school.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoIt absolutely did not start in the 90s, and only ratcheted up significantly after 2008. People often underestimate the damage that the economic crisis did to American social cohesion. There are other variables that are obviously at play here: the continuing rise in childhood poverty, the influence of social media, increasingly long and arbitrary hours worked by parents and caregivers, access to powerful firearms, etc. Chalking it up to "now the boomers are having kids" is weak social analysis. Not only is the rise in school violence probably a confluence of all those factors, the moral fiber of their parents or whatever specious argument you're making here is likely a small or even negligible factor.
- rayiner 4y agoWhether you peg it at 1995 or 2008, you’re talking about a phenomenon that’s just a couple of decades old. That dramatically limits what the explanation could be. Blaming the 2008 recession is odd, because other indicators of crime continued to decrease during that time. Homicides also decreased from 1929-1939 as the Great Depression wore on, so there is no basis for the theory that recessions cause violence. It’s also probably not guns. Since 1975, the share of households with a gun has fallen from half to about a third. Childhood poverty has fallen dramatically over that time as well when you account for social safety net transfers. America was a less violent place in the 1950s, before the social safety net and when many more households had a gun. People really don’t want to believe that culture matters. But blaming poverty instead is just inconsistent with the facts. Many poor countries don’t have the social dysfunction America has. And it’s not the combination of guns and poverty either. Countries like Pakistan and Yemen have many guns and homicide rates lower than the US, despite being very poor.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoThis is the kind of assertion people love to make but hate to back up, or think deeply about. It makes more sense to address core issues like poverty and abuse than it does to drone strike these kids'
- rayiner 4y agoIt doesn’t require much backup. Spend a few days walking around Japan and just look around. Or compare American kids to kids in other countries, including countries that are a lot poorer, like Bangladesh where I’m from. Raising red herrings about “core issues” is a refusal to engage with the problem. It’s not “poverty” that causes these behavioral problems, because many poor countries manage to control their kids. You’ve actually got it backward. Misbehaved kids and tolerance for classroom disruption deprives poor kids of a good education and perpetuates poverty.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y ago"Just look around" is exactly what I thought you'd say.
- pen2l 4y agoI'm an immigrant, so I have a vantage point here others may not. I remember being bewildered at how belligerent fellow troubled kids were with their elders (especially teachers and their parents*), to the point where it was often impossible for the teacher to carry on with her lesson plan for that day because most of the time was spent with cops/security guards or the teacher crying in a corner. I'm surprised at the resistance rayiner is getting. I'm thinking it is likely due to folks here having been brought up in suburban bubbles and being completely ignorant of how bad the situation is in a lot of inner city schools. *edit: I suspect folks here will interpret the term "troubled kid" in their own cute ways, like not following directions on how to do a math problem because the little Euler-streaked student found a *better* way and he'll not listen to the authority on how to do the problem the conventional way, don't you suppress his creativity! No, I'm talking about students like these: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpDFBxKcOXY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpDFBxKcOXY where in the back of your mind the calculation taking place is 'is he going to hit me? If I hit him first, can I get away without being physically hurt? I have a PhD in physics, what am I doing here babysitting these hellspawn clowns? But if I hit first, what kind of administrative bullshit fallout do I have to deal with?'
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoMost of my behavioral issues were outside of class and focused on the administrators and cops. I wasn't really a class disruptor. The kids that were, though, shouldn't have been tased for it. There are better approaches, obviously.
- SauciestGNU 4y agoJust as an aside, love your username. Against The Day is my favorite Pynchon.