3 ms·
Yes, that is exactly the problem. It is an interesting result that there is spontaneous polymerization catalyzed by volcanic rock glasses, but this is an extre
by adrian_b 4y ago
Yes, that is exactly the problem.
It is an interesting result that there is spontaneous polymerization catalyzed by volcanic rock glasses, but this is an extremely simple reaction, which is expected to happen spontaneously in various conditions.
Making the monomers, i.e. the nucleoside triphosphates, requires a long chain of complex reactions, and also energy.
There is no doubt that RNA has first appeared accidentally, by spontaneous polymerization of nucleoside triphosphates, but those must have been produced by an already existing form of life, which had to use a continuous source of energy for complex molecule synthesis, e.g. dihydrogen, carbon monoxide and a ionic concentration gradient, which can be provided by submarine vents.
While the study does not offer any new information about the actual origin of life, the first accidental synthesis of RNA must have used some catalyst and that catalyst might have been a component of volcanic rocks, as shown in this study.
Only after some molecules of RNA with random composition already existed, due to spontaneous polymerization, it could happen for a RNA molecule to serve as a template for replication, during the polymerization of another RNA molecule. Therefore it is important to determine in which conditions the polymerization of RNA can happen, in the absence of specialized enzymes.