7 ms·
Dutch Airline Pilots Association blocks mandated vaccinations for new pilots
- midasuni 4y agoTo go to nigeria I had to have a yellow fever vaccine, I don’t see the difference. Plenty of countries require covid vaccination to enter, that’s an operational problem for an airline deploying staff.
- sokoloff 4y agoA sovereign nation deciding on the requirements to cross the border into its territory feels different to me than the power of an employer to set health-related mandates. I’m much more willing to accept that a sovereign nation has the right to enforce border policies than an employer has the right to police the healthcare decisions of its employees.
- midasuni 4y agoAn airline pilot who is unable to work because they refuse to have the required vaccines is of no use to their employer.
- xeromal 4y agoUnless they're part of a union which is a problem for their employer.
- Beltalowda 4y agoIt's not that they're "unable to work", it's just that they can't work on some flights, which makes the scheduling a bit harder for KLM since not every employee can work on every flight.
- sofixa 4y ago> an employer to set health-related mandates It's funny you say that within the context of an airline. Where pilot and air staff's health is under extreme scrutiny because they need to be in good condition, otherwise people could die when things go south. They probably enforce vaccines for yellow fever and similar for pilots flying to countries impacted to those diseases, why is it any different for COVID-19?
- sokoloff 4y agoKLM: “We will track that you have a valid 1st class medical as is required for airline transport operations.” VNV and everyone: “No problem!” KLM: “You also need this extra healthcare requirement that KLM is imposing.” VNV: “No. We’ll see you in court.” Airlines ensuring their flight crews are complying with federal laws and ICAO standards is great. Airlines setting their own medical standards differently is what I (and the pilots’ union) think is improper.
- sofixa 4y ago> Airlines ensuring their flight crews are complying with federal laws I think you're mistaking the country, KLM is a Dutch airline, and the Netherlands is not a federation. They're under EASA and ICAO regulations, on top of Dutch and (every country they operate in) regulations. > Airlines setting their own medical standards differently is what I (and the pilots’ union) think is improper. It's up to them to set those medical standards if they think they're needed. They probably have mental health standards too, considering the worst air disaster in terms of death toll was caused by a pilot of theirs forgetting he's not in a simulator with bad visibility and crashing his 747 into another 747. As has already been said, many countries require Covid vaccination for entry, including in the EU. Why would an airline not require their air staff to be vaccinated?
- sokoloff 4y ago> It's up to them to set those medical standards if they think they're needed. The court disagreed in the case we’re discussing.
- kybernetyk 4y agoThe yellow fever vaccine works though. The covid vaccines are all somewhere on the level of very ineffective down to snake-oil. Yellow fever also is actually a serious disease while covid is for the absolute huge majority nothing more than a cold.
- Lordarminius 4y ago
- sofixa 4y agoVery ineffective at what? Stopping transmission, yes. Preventing heavy cases requiring hospitalisation ? I thought the studies and statistics were pretty much unanimous that the vaccines greatly help at that. Has there been anything new I've missed?
- solarhoma 4y agoI have not followed the vaccine efficacy as closely as I should. But for the past two years masks have been ‘known’ to reduce transmission rates. Data has finally been released showing that these cloth masks do not help reducing transmission rates.
- mdp2021 4y ago> nothing more than a cold Are you sure? Available numbers have varied. Are you sure that it is not just a superficial appearance, and that damage could be revealed by a low-level assessment? Some people do not drink or smoke, you know - they want to be optimal, not "it's just a scratch". Those people who judge the potential damages from covid as negligile but for limited cases would have little reason for reclutance towards vaccination, which would gain the advantage of further reducing those chances.
- xkbarkar 4y ago
- thedifference 4y ago
- slavak 4y agoBoth the Pfizer-BioNTech (Comirnaty) and Moderna (Spikevax) COVID vaccines are fully FDA approved for a while now.
- phpisthebest 4y agoMy understanding they are still being distributed under their EUA, not under their Approved Name, and Branding This is a very large legal difference, as under the EUA they have been exempted for any and ALL liability
- sokoloff 4y agoModerna and Pfizer’s vaccines now have full FDA approval. https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavirus-covid-19-update-fda-takes-key-action-approving-second-covid-19-vaccine https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavi...
- phpisthebest 4y agoFDA approval or not was not the statement I made. Even in your link it expressly says they are still being distributed under the EUA not under normal law
- hoffs 4y ago> Experimental
- contravariant 4y agoSure, but given that "KLM has not been able to demonstrate that there is an operational necessity" it seems fair to me that the court has decided the KLM cannot mandate vaccination.
- thematrixturtle 4y agoUnpopular opinion here, I suspect, but I'm happy to see COVID vaccination mandates getting rolled back. They made sense last year when we all thought they would have a meaningful impact on transmission, but Omicron has made it pretty clear that they don't. So if somebody can't or just doesn't want to get the shot, meh, not society's problem anymore, just increase their insurance premiums to reflect the higher risk of being hospitalized if/when they catch it. And for the record, I'm triple vaxxed myself and continue to strongly support mandatory vaccinations where they do clearly make sense, eg. measles.
- sgift 4y ago> just increase their insurance premiums to reflect the higher risk of being hospitalized if/when they catch it. That's usually not possible with universal healthcare.
- thematrixturtle 4y agoSingapore has heavily subsidized healthcare, but they've announced that if you're medically eligible for the vaccine, choose not to get it, and end up in the hospital due to COVID, you'll pay the full unsubsidized rates.
- basisword 4y agoIt doesn't work in a system where nobody pays. e.g. UK
- tluyben2 4y agoIn NL a you have healthcare by mandatory insurance (and they cannot refuse you), so I think there is room for a rule like this in NL; I think that’s not the case in the UK or other places like ES and PT.
- belter 4y agoYou are opening the door to your insurance require that you become a vegan or increase the premium to unaffordable levels. Then as you accept the principle, you will be mandated to take other vaccines. Your compliance will be verified by a chip. "Imagine the compliance": https://nitter.net/loffredojeremy/status/1527521228688445442 https://nitter.net/loffredojeremy/status/1527521228688445442
- sokoloff 4y agoTwo polarizing topics in one article: unions and vaccine mandates.* Whether or not mandating this particular vaccine is a good idea on balance, I don’t think that employers are the right group to be independently determining them. (If society wants to implement them, do it via the government. If that implementation includes a check at school enrollment or by employers as a compliance mechanism, fine, but leaving vaccine mandates to individual employers is about as crazy as leaving them to individual schools.) * I’d be curious to see a 2x2 grid of pro-union/anti-union and pro-mandate/anti-mandate. I suspect there is a more than 25% of population in each of the pro/pro and anti/anti camps, making me think of that meme with the guy sweating in front of buttons labeled “Right of Workers to Collectively Bargain” and “COVID Vaccine Mandate”
- aemreunal 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 4y agoWere they effective? Were they protecting others? I think answer is clearly no.
- cr1895 4y ago> Were they effective? They absolutely are effective at reducing the risk of death or serious illness.
- Ekaros 4y agoFor how many weeks?
- strangus 4y ago6
- IfOnlyYouKnew 4y agoThat’s a remarkably quick shift from your “clearly no” just minutes ago. We now agree they clearly do help, and I’m not sure if the duration of protection matters.
- Ekaros 4y agoI think period of protection is extremely important factor when evaluating how effective a vaccine is. Or would you call any of the traditional vaccines effective if we needed to take them multiple times a year? I would not. Clearly such vaccine is not effective on scale.
- the_third_wave 4y ago