3 ms·
When the legislature included “crustaceans” in the definition of “fish” they didn’t meant “woodlice.”
by rayiner 4y ago
When the legislature included “crustaceans” in the definition of “fish” they didn’t meant “woodlice.”
- dragonwriter 4y ago> When the legislature included “crustaceans” in the definition of “fish” they didn’t meant “woodlice.” So, your argument that they didn't meant “aquatic invertebrate” when they said “invertebrate” is based on the fact that “crustacean” and “mollusk” are unambiguously aquatic, and that the fact that these unambiguously aquatic terms were used means that “invertebrate” was implicitly restricted. But your claim that “crustacean” and “mollusk” are unambiguously aquatic relies on exactly the same unstated restriction, as both are terms that encompass terrestrial species, and your support for that is...what? Compared to the extensive analysis of the legislative history and context in the opinion supporting the opposite conclusion, this is singularly unpersuasive.