4 ms·
You should reread the OP, which devotes many pages of expert analysis of 50 years of legislative and executive history. As a lawyer, you should know better tha
by lupire 4y ago
You should reread the OP, which devotes many pages of expert analysis of 50 years of legislative and executive history.
As a lawyer, you should know better than to make an underinformed unqualified statement about matters of law.
- rayiner 4y ago> You should reread the OP, which devotes many pages of expert analysis of 50 years of legislative and executive history. If the legislature intended “fish” to mean something other than “fish and fish-like things” they could have changed the definition. They chose not to do that. The fact that the “expert” agencies have been flouting the law for decades doesn’t change the meaning of the words on the page. Also, as the superior court observed, the legislature expressly rejected efforts to add “invertebrates” to the list of protected animals. > As a lawyer, you should know better than to make an underinformed unqualified statement about matters of law. I’m commenting on what the interpretation should be in this straightforward case, not offering an opinion on what a California court may or may not do. Here, the superior court offered a well reasoned decision finding that insects are not fish: https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/klvykolmmvg/Sacramento%20County%20Superior%20Court%20Almond%20Alliance%20v%20CFGC%202020.pdf https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/klvykolmmvg/... The appellate court had to spend a lot of pages and did a lot of hand waving to overcome the clear words on the page. But that contrivance diminishes the persuasiveness of the opinion, it doesn’t enhance it!