3 ms·
This is just a poorly reasoned decision. The statutory definition of “fish” is as follows: > ‘[f]ish’ means a wild fish, mollusk, crustacean, invertebrate, amp
by rayiner 4y ago
This is just a poorly reasoned decision. The statutory definition of “fish” is as follows:
> ‘[f]ish’ means a wild fish, mollusk, crustacean, invertebrate, amphibian, or part, spawn, or ovum of any of those animals.” (Stats. 2015, ch. 154, § 5.)
Ordinarily, you read statutory terms in a list in the context, including in the context of the other terms. See: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/ejusdem_generis https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/ejusdem_generis
> Ejusdem generis (ee-joose-dem gen-ris) is a Latin phrase that means “of the same kind.” The statutory and constitutional construction principle of “ejusdem generis” states that where general words or phrases follow a number of specific words or phrases, the general words are specifically construed as limited and apply only to persons or things of the same kind or class as those expressly mentioned. For example, if a law refers to automobiles, trucks, tractors, motorcycles, and other motor-powered vehicles, a court might use ejusdem generis to hold that such vehicles would not include airplanes, because the list included only land-based transportation.
While “invertebrate” can be a more general term, in the surrounding context it’s clearly meant to refer to marine invertebrates, not invertebrates in general.
- jffry 4y agoThe decision [1] includes the court's full justification for setting aside ejusdem generis, starting at the bottom of page 20. As I understand it: The short answer is the legislature changed the statutory definition on more than one occasion where it can be shown they were aware of the broader interpretation of that clause being in use and took no action to narrow it. This, according to the decision, establishes legislative intent for the broad interpretation, which supersedes ejusdem generis. [1] https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/C093542.PDF https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/C093542.PDF
- rayiner 4y agoRead the legislative history discussion at 10-13. The DNR expressly asked the Legislature to add “invertebrates.” The legislature included it in a draft bill, but deleted that language in the final bill. The legislative history seems to confirm that invertebrates are excluded.