3 ms·
>Random person: recieves a physical mail right after installing Brave. >Brave: we are so so private and don't ever sell or use your data. >Random person: how
by gruez 4y ago
>Random person: recieves a physical mail right after installing Brave.
>Brave: we are so so private and don't ever sell or use your data.
>Random person: how did you get my address then right after I literally installed Brave?
Can't you make the argument for any sort of ad? eg.
>Random person: sees a static banner ad[1] right after installing Brave.
>Brave: we are so so private and don't ever sell or use your data.
>Random person: how did you know to show me a brave ad right after I literally installed Brave?
Are you basically arguing that brave shouldn't advertise at all?
[1] static in the sense it's placed there by the publisher for all visitors, rather than through some sort of ad network
- longrod 4y agoThis is a very interesting situation for privacy respecting products. Say you want to advertise to your potential audience, what do you do? You have very few privacy respecting methods. 1. You go with passive advertising like billboards, TV ads, blog ads etc. Not particularly effective since you can't do it across the world. 2. You go with something like Google with a huge ad network. But if you go with Google...you are tapping into and making use of personal data of your very own privacy respecting people. In a way, you are feeding the beast. Which method should such a product go with? Which method would conform with their privacy respecting model best? Which would bring in a lot of users? Not all ads are bad. Not all ad networks are bad. Some, very few, do it ethically. I think Brave itself is one of those. But these networks are very, very small compared to Google. At all time the temptation is there to go with targeted ads because it's the most effective & affordable way to get potential users. The moment you do, are you still privacy respecting? Edit: as to your question about banner ads. It depends. If you are using Google's banner ads they aren't static by any means. Google targets and rotates based on their huge database of user data. But if you just put a banner ad somewhere on a blog etc, that comes under the category of passive/non-targeted marketing.
- notahacker 4y agoBrave is basically arguing that third party marketing-distribution networks which use personally identifiable information to target ads are bad. I think it's pretty reasonable to suggest that exposing that they do so via a third party marketing distribution network which uses personally identifiable information to target ads may have been a misstep without arguing that means they can't advertise at all Particularly when the "but we don't see the personally identifiable information that the third party we paid used to advertise to you" applies to everyone paying Facebook or Google to show ads too...
- gruez 4y ago> Brave is basically arguing that third party marketing-distribution networks which use personally identifiable information to target ads are bad. >I think it's pretty reasonable to suggest that exposing that they do so via a third party marketing distribution network which uses personally identifiable information to target ads may have been a misstep without arguing that means they can't advertise at all But in this case there's no targeting involved? They just told the "third party marketing-distribution network" to send ads to every household within a given zip code.