4 ms·
Why US gun violence spikes in warm weather (dvl: 2022; rsr: 2020, 2019, 2017)
- mdp2021 4y agoNote: the research may be based on USA data but the thesis is of course scientific (universal). > A... controversial idea is that heat itself ... might rev up conflict > [David] Hemenway [professor of health policy at the Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health] said he had long been interested in the relationship between heat and higher crime given stereotypes about the north-south divide within the United States and Italy, as well as between the northern European states of Scandinavia and southern Mediterranean countries > In 2020, he co-wrote a paper ... [using] reports from the Chicago Tribune[: t]hey found a 10 degree Celsius higher temperature was significantly associated with 34 percent more shootings on weekdays, and 42 percent more shootings on weekends or holidays > Another recent paper ... in 2017, looked at violent crime in Philadelphia[: ...]violent crimes happened more often in the warmer months ... and were highest on the hottest days > A striking study ... in 2019 involved placing university students ... in either hot or cold rooms and measuring the impact on a number of behavioral categories ... found heat significantly affects individuals' willingness to voluntar[y] destr[uction] Very probably, this divulgative article from Issam Ahmed was written not on the occasion of new research, but on the basis of the recent chronicles.
- mdp2021 4y agoOriginal research articles: Reeping; Hemenway, The association between weather and the number of daily shootings in Chicago (2012–2016) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7310019/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7310019/ > This finding is in-line with studies that have linked crime to higher temperature and also suggests that shootings may be related to when individuals are outside and more likely to encounter violence > [Past] studies were predictive rather than causal and it is not appropriate to interpret the coefficients as stand-alone factors. For example, do thunderstorms predict shootings? Or do shootings occur more often when it is warm, and high temperature increases the probability of a thunderstorm? To be able to interpret each coefficient, the complex causal structure of each variable must be considered Graphics: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7310019/bin/40621_2020_260_Fig4_HTML.jpg https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7310019/bin/406... So the authors suggest two tracks, both that heat increases violence and that heat increases outside activity which exposes to violence, but suggest that the commonsensical note about outside activity should correct overreliance on the weight of sheer heat. > These results are generally supportive of the robust field of literature that has hypothesized that warmer weather is predictive of aggression and violence behavior. [...] However, two unique findings suggest that heat induced aggression is likely not the only explanation for these results. While warmer weather resulted in more shootings, this was more pronounced when there was a weekend or holiday, supporting our hypothesis that people being outside their home might also be a driver of shootings. Furthermore, there were more shootings on days that were warmer than average, including in the colder months. Because some of these “warmer” than average days were relatively mild, and in some cases would be considered cold, this is also not fully explained by the aggression hypothesis and gives credence to the “outdoors” hypothesis
- belter 4y agoWithout sounding insensitive to the tragedy that is gun violence, it looks to me that had they looked at ice cream sales, they would find a spike of gun violence correlated to such sales.
- mdp2021 4y agoI also had a suspect whether data normalization had been properly performed (events in India¹ "will" be more than in Tuvalu - in the grossest example), especially to rule out other causal factors, even explicitly mentioned (e.g. "during hot weather people will be out more" - which incidentally, is not even true, because in some areas when the heat increases people look for shelter, not for a stroll), but I confided researchers knew their trade. I did not check the research articles, because I initially expected only one, not a transversal post. But the 2019 study, in-lab, should be free from this issue. I remember that above-the-Alps dwellers noted even centuries ago that föhn wind (which suddenly, in a few hours, can raise temperatures with a delta well above 10°C) correlated to increases in crime, accidents and suicide (though I cannot easily find articles). In fact, it seems heat can, consistently, also increase suicide - see https://fsi.stanford.edu/news/stanford-researchers-find-warming-temperatures-could-increase-suicide-rates-across-us-and https://fsi.stanford.edu/news/stanford-researchers-find-warm... -- ¹Aside: India, 1410M ppl, is catching up with China, 1412M ppl?!