6 ms·
> Sanctions have to hurt to be effective. While true, I think it’s the wrong criticism in this case, as the necessity of hurt has to be at the target of the sa
by ben_w 4y ago
> Sanctions have to hurt to be effective.
While true, I think it’s the wrong criticism in this case, as the necessity of hurt has to be at the target of the sanctions rather than at the one imposing them.
Rather:
The sanctions that appeared after the Russian annexation of Crimea were the painless ones. The current situation is so much worse for EU interests that the EU feels it needs to demonstrate that it is willing to experience at least some discomfort in order to prevent Russian aggression.
- popcube 4y agoobviously, Russian government trust Europe people don't want to suffer any inconvenience before invading.
- ajsnigrutin 4y ago> EU feels it needs to demonstrate that it is willing to experience at least some discomfort in order to prevent Russian aggression. The problem here is... are we really stopping the conflict by eg. banning import of russian oil? Russia is just exporting it to eg. India and China, them having cheaper oil is making their economies stronger, russia still gets the money, and europes economy is going down. So, we're hurting our economy to not hurt the russian one while helping china and india.
- flaviut 4y agoThere's no pipelines from Russia to India and China. Russia has to ship the oil. That's way more expensive, and there's just no infrastructure for that right now.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoHow many piplines do we (EU) have from other countries that will provide us oil, after we totally stop importing it from russia? Won't the price hike hurt us too, possible even more than russia?
- ben_w 4y agoYou need to be extremely careful with what you mean by “hurt” when you want to compare the economies of EU and Russia. The EU has about 10x the nominal GDP of Russia. Is a 10% contraction of the EU for one year equivalent to the entire Russian population reverting to subsistence farming for a year?
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoBut they're not subsistence farming, they're doing the stuff they did before, export their stuff to countries like india and china, and buying stuff from them too. Replacing their iphone with a Xiaomi/Huawei phone will hurt them a lot less, than possible power outages and no heat will hurt us. If we read between the lines, we're also at the brink of a massive food crisis (wheat and fertilizers + of course fuel cost) that russians have enough of.
- ben_w 4y agoI’m talking hypothetically: The economic cost to the EU is also not 10%, but would you consider those two costs — hypothetical 10% EU recession and hypothetical Russia reduced to subsistence farming — to be equal? Also: I should’ve thought of this before, but cost to each party isn’t the right metric — it’s what does the EU gain at what cost to the EU (and likewise for each party), so the question is probably more like: Q1) does this situation look like a warmongering power trying to rebuilding a lost empire? If so, what’s the cost of sitting back and doing nothing? A1) let’s say p=0.1, €3T/year Q2) [insert more hypotheticals, probability estimates, and costs here, a real analysis wouldn’t fit in a comment] Finally: multiply the chances by the costs, add them all up, that’s what it makes sense for the EU pay. > If we read between the lines, we're also at the brink of a massive food crisis We’re not even close to that, despite the breathless headlines and the fact the Russian forces interfered with a significant quantity of food production and are blockading the ports that would normally export it from Ukraine. Hell, even the UK isn’t that screwed and they’re short of farm hands to pick crops and vets to certify the abattoirs because of Brexit.
- 4y ago
- billfruit 4y agoIt looks like there is a Gazprom pipeline between Russia and China.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nine_k 4y agoThere is actually a gas pipeline from Russia to China, it's near capacity, and extending it would be a major undertaking, which is planned but will take a decade or so. See e.g. https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Energy/China-turns-to-Russian-gas-to-curb-dependence-on-Quad-members https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Energy/China-turns-to-Russi...
- cm2187 4y agoNowhere near the same volume. Not the least because the infrastructure to transport this oil in volume aren’t there. I don’t think sanctions will make Russia stop the war, the only thing that will is a large enough flow of dead soldiers coming back home. But it will impact its ability to finance this war, its military capabilities (replace hardware), and potentially (though not clear to me), create opinion backlash in Russia.
- monetus 4y agoPrice per barrel is lower if it isn't going to Europe too - EU was the whale customer.
- xkcd1963 4y agoI wouldn't want to see full-mobilisation after Russia ran out of active soldiers.
- ben_w 4y agoNobody should want war, war is hell for all who see it up close, even when it’s the only way to keep your friends and family safe from a greater horror; yet from this far away, the only thing I fear is that Russian nukes might not be as badly maintained as their tanks.
- xkcd1963 4y agoYes. I meant to say that I don't see right now how Russia will stop the war, even if it is depleted of active soldiers and other things.
- ben_w 4y ago> are we really stopping the conflict by eg. banning import of russian oil? I wouldn’t know. But I can say the fungibility (or not) of oil is necessarily equivalent for both importers and exporters. Consider the implications if it were trivial to change markets: Russia losing X units of exports per year to the EU and increasing exports to China and India by a total of X, means China and India are buying X fewer units from not-Russia, which means the EU could buy X more units on the everyone-else marketplace.
- zmgsabst 4y agoThis assumes that oil consumption is fixed, rather than China and India increasing their usage while Europe stagnates.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoYep, price goes down, people produce more, stuff gets cheaper, and they export more. Not us (europeans) though.
- kurthr 4y agoThey can't get the oil, because there are not any (additional) pipelines. They can't really ship the oil, because there's not enough (additional) capacity to do that. Most tankers can't get insured and only smaller tankers can transit ports available to Russia (or they have to transfer oil mid ocean). As a result Turkey, India, and China will get marginally more 10-30% cheaper oil from Russia, but that pushes their imports from the middle east down... which lowers prices in Europe! Realistically, Turkey China and India are mostly exporters. When Europe and the US go into recession, they won't need as much oil because they won't be exporting as much (they are the dominant importers)... and that likely means that Russia turns off wells when their storage fills up (soon). Those wells are slow to restart. The rest of OPEC replaces their oil (at somewhat higher prices) for the next few years. What is an immediate concern is food, oil, and fertilizer not being exported from Ukraine (can't plant/harvest or ship) for much of the developing world. Turkey, Egypt, Sri Lanka... Sudan are all very dependent on wheat, sunflower oil, and fertilizer from eastern Ukraine. Even India will be quite affected. See how evil EU starves the poor! Only beautiful Russia can save them!
- ineedasername 4y agoI don't think the EU is simply trying to signal willingness to experience discomfort. I don't know if you intended it, but your phrasing gives me the impression that you think the they are choosing a specific level of discomfort merely for show. This seems wrong. 1) Russia cannot be penalized to any great degree with it producing negative consequences. Though I'm open to being wrong in this, and would entertain ideas about alternative sanctions that would penalize Russia equally without being uncomfortable. And 2) The discomfort is a function of EU tying itself too closely to Russia, something about which it was warned repeatedly over the decades even by some of its own members. The discomfort here is not merely necessary to penalize Russia, but also to remedy reliance on a Russian government wielding that clout as a license to act just as it is acting now in the Ukraine. The EU must be willing to experience discomfort, but they are not doing so right now merely as a hollow signal.
- ben_w 4y ago> I don't know if you intended it, but your phrasing gives me the impression that you think the they are choosing a specific level of discomfort merely for show. Thanks, I was afraid I might have come across that way. Was aiming more for “we have to show we’re tough and not just talk it”.
- pydry 4y ago>The EU must be willing to experience discomfort Id be more willing to suffer discomfort if diplomatic options were exhausted before this war. As it is we are made to suffer ultimately, because NATO and Russia are spoiling for a proxy war and because the US has been itching to sell us some overpriced LNG. The US should be giving us LNG at a discount on prewar levels. This is largely their proxy war, not ours.
- ben_w 4y agoI don’t see how you can call a direct conflict between Russia and anyone a proxy war for Russia. If you did, the USA involvement in Vietnam would be a proxy war for the USA, and the American war of independence would be a proxy war for the British — in both cases some other power also had some interest, but I would never call either a proxy war for the USA and British respectively.