2 ms·
So, what you call "an album" or "single" is a release group, because there multiple re-issues of beatles albums, in mono, stereo, red vinyl etc. each of which i
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
So, what you call "an album" or "single" is a release group, because there multiple re-issues of beatles albums, in mono, stereo, red vinyl etc. each of which is a release. They often but not always share the same recordings e.g. the US release may replace an album track with the single version or re-order tracks.
You probably want to find a release of that release group that closely matches your files (e.g. is there a "bonus" track, does it have both mono and stereo versions of everything). It's not 100% vital though to get an exact match unless you care about the bonus tracks and other obscurities.
The beatles are an extreme case since there's like a million demo and session versions of each song, which is why its easier to start from a release, which then points to the specific recordings used.
So if you got the files from iTunes and it's the 2009 remaster then it's this one:
https://musicbrainz.org/recording/2df46dec-b453-4444-91b9-5fa5d7515fd9 https://musicbrainz.org/recording/2df46dec-b453-4444-91b9-5f...
Which then points to a specific recording used (the original studio mix), which was also released as a single and appeared on many different albums, listed here:
https://musicbrainz.org/recording/2df46dec-b453-4444-91b9-5fa5d7515fd9 https://musicbrainz.org/recording/2df46dec-b453-4444-91b9-5f...
Although that's on lots of different releases (and release groups), if anyone updates the info on that recording, it'll update for all of them.
To get those track level tags you need to choose an option in Picard and there's a couple of 'plugins' for it that let you format the instrument tags in a way you want. It also lets you script the tags if you have something super specific.
- raffraffraff 4y agoI picked The Beatles because it's "hard", but also because it's the most likely candidate to have all of the metadata populated (including instruments). And it's a perfect example of why a gigantic database that tries too hard to please the 'train spotters' with catalog numbers and barcodes, is not suitable for someone who has the album version of a song and just wants to tag it. What normal person knows/cares what a release group is? Edit: "You probably want to find a release of that release group that closely matches your files". And this is why you can't just point it at your library and let it go. You need to shepherd it at every turn or it'll screw things up. I've used countless auto-taggers over the years (all of which pull from MusicBrainz) and I've never had decent results. These days I tag manually. Most of it's already done, so I just have to handle the new stuff, and sometimes update old stuff (add instruments that 'stand out', update ratings etc).