3 ms·
Who is "they"? The Mongolians? Sogdians (Persians)? Uyghurs (Turks)? Shu? Yue? Unified for three thousand years is a ridiculous claim. I find it amazing that t
by trompetenaccoun 4y ago
Who is "they"? The Mongolians? Sogdians (Persians)? Uyghurs (Turks)? Shu? Yue?
Unified for three thousand years is a ridiculous claim. I find it amazing that this Communist Party propaganda idea (they claim 5000 years actually) of a millennia old continuous "Chinese" state gets repeated by so many people abroad as well. Just spending a few minutes on Wikipedia reading up on East Asian history would would help.
Btw something that few people know even among those who read before commenting and among Chinese themselves: The idea of a Han people didn't exist before Qing Dynasty, not to speak of thousands of years earlier. It's a modern invention by Qing intellectuals, mirroring similar developments in Western countries. There was no concept of nation states prior to our modern times, there were many large states covering similar territories in the past of course, but they weren't necessarily "Chinese". The same way English people aren't Romans and just because Vietnam uses the Latin alphabet, it doesn't make them Latin.