7 ms·
Did anyone expect otherwise? Telegram is a mostly unencrypted chat application, of course it's going to cooperate if local law enforcement comes knocking on the
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Did anyone expect otherwise? Telegram is a mostly unencrypted chat application, of course it's going to cooperate if local law enforcement comes knocking on their door with a warrant. If you don't want your chats to end up in the hands of law enforcement then you should consider using an end-to-end-encrypted messenger application.
Signal will hand over your data too if the police show up, but they don't have any data to hand over.
- WilTimSon 4y ago> Telegram is a mostly unencrypted chat application That's just plain incorrect. > if local law enforcement comes knocking on their door with a warrant How is German law enforcement relevant to an app HQ'd in Dubai? They've been openly criticised before for not cooperating with law enforcement.
- andreskytt 4y agoHq location can be quite irrelevant. Legal intercept laws can be quite old-fashioned and might make a case than two German citizens having a conversation while on German soil makes the conversation fall under German jurisdiction. There can be a surprisingly large number of ways the jurisdiction can be determined, for all parties involved and, without analysis of German law, I would not readily make assumptions as to if they have a legal basis to talk to Signal or not. And if they do, I’m sure Signal is a law-abiding company.
- miohtama 4y ago> That's just plain incorrect All chats are unencrypted by default.
- WilTimSon 4y agoThat's what the other user said and it is still incorrect. [0] People either don't read the basic FAQ or conflate E2EE to being the only encryption in the world, which is ridiculous. [0]: https://telegram.org/faq#q-so-how-do-you-encrypt-data https://telegram.org/faq#q-so-how-do-you-encrypt-data
- cassianoleal 4y agoHonest question. Can you clarify this? I read the FAQ and even skimmed the MTProto 2.0 docs but from where I stand this Server-Client encryption sounds like encryption in transit but the server still has the ability to decrypt. This, from a privacy against law enforcement perspective (which is what the article and comments are about), is more or less the same as no encryption. Edit: s/transport/transit/, add "perspective" to the last paragraph.
- AnonC 4y agoIt’s true that Telegram only uses encryption for data in transit for normal person-to-person chats and group chats. Data at rest is stored in a way the server can read. That’s one of the things that makes Telegram search so fast. The encryption part [1] is covered in the FAQ, along with more details. Also see the question and answer on “Fo you process data requests?” [2] Telegram has a feature called secret chats, which are only person-to-person. That uses end-to-end encryption. [1]: https://telegram.org/faq#q-so-how-do-you-encrypt-data https://telegram.org/faq#q-so-how-do-you-encrypt-data [2]: https://telegram.org/faq#q-do-you-process-data-requests https://telegram.org/faq#q-do-you-process-data-requests
- cassianoleal 4y agoI'm aware of Secret Chats, but there's extra friction to enable it and I suspect most Telegram users are not aware of them at all - or are unwilling to use them for almost everything. Also they should now update that FAQ answer where they say: > To this day, we have disclosed 0 bytes of user data to third parties, including governments. In fact, if the OP is indeed true, they should probably update the entire answer since it's misguiding at best, and an outright lie at worst.
- driminicus 4y agoEncryption in transit is assumed, and rightfully so. That still means that telegram gets full access to the plaintext and as such is able to give that information to anyone, and do with it as they wish. I suppose there are some people pit there that think "unencrypted" here means everyone can listen in, but certainly not the hackernews crowd.
- nicce 4y ago> That's just plain incorrect. By default nothing is E2E encrypted. So yes, we can say it is mostly unencrypted.
- aaomidi 4y agoMate I love telegram but that's not plain incorrect. Telegram has transport layer encryption, like literally everything else in 2022. For all intents and purposes telegram can read and access a majority of your conversations on it. This isn't a super big deal because telegram is aiming to be a social media platform, rather than an encrypted comms platform, and e2ee on groups over a certain size is pretty useless. I think telegram can still improve by making private messages e2ee by default.
- Terretta 4y ago> transport layer encryption, like literally everything else in 2022… for all intents and purposes telegram can read and access Not literally everything. By and large everything, sure. Effectively everything, even. But not literally everything. For instance, take a deep dive into how e2e encryption works in the Apple ecosystem… https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 … and why allowing iCloud Backups for usability becomes the weakest link for Apple Messages: https://support.apple.com/en-au/guide/security/sec3cac31735/web https://support.apple.com/en-au/guide/security/sec3cac31735/... To save a click: Messages in iCloud, which keeps a user’s entire message history updated and available on all devices, also uses CloudKit end-to-end encryption with a CloudKit service key protected by iCloud Keychain syncing. If the user has enabled iCloud Backup, the CloudKit service key used for the Messages in iCloud container is also backed up to iCloud to allow the user to recover their messages, even if they have lost access to iCloud Keychain and their trusted devices. This iCloud service key is rolled whenever the user turns off iCloud Backup. If you are in this ecosystem, and feel your potential loss from disclosure is greater than your potential loss by losing/damaging your device, go turn off iCloud Backup — and make sure your keychain is secured to your needs.
- hitovst 4y agoEveryone will likely hand over whatever they can... which means the most decentralized options which leave as little to hand over as possible are best.
- buro9 4y agoMost encrypted. Centralised or decentralised means little compared to a lack of encryption. You can't give up that which you don't have access to.
- kornhole 4y agoBoth are important. When governments mandate back doors such as in EU chat control or US Earn it act, centralized services can be targeted much more easily than the thousands of xmpp and matrix servers running around the world.
- sodality2 4y agoIsn't that federated rather than decentralized?
- kornhole 4y agoWhat distinction do you mean? Federation allows for interoperable decentralization. Without federation, we would have thousands of chat/mail/social media servers that can't talk to each other. Some may choose not to federate, but most want to federate to create a useful protocol.
- sodality2 4y agoI always believed decentralized was if each user doubled as a server and required no external setup (example: scuttlebutt). Whereas federated was a plurality of servers with users communicated with each other but no central authority (email, mastodon, matrix, etc). However, reading some peer to peer literature like that 1500 page behemoth of a book, "Handbook of Peer-to-Peer Networking", it seems they are used relatively interchangeably..
- BelleOfTheBall 4y agoThe app famous for not cooperating will cooperate? https://hongkongfp.com/2020/07/05/exclusive-telegram-to-temporarily-refuse-data-requests-from-hong-kong-courts-amid-security-law-terrorism-row/ https://hongkongfp.com/2020/07/05/exclusive-telegram-to-temp...
- legalcorrection 4y agoIt’s easy to refuse requests from Chinese law enforcement if you don’t have offices, employees, or assets in China. Meanwhile, European countries recognize the legitimacy of each other’s court systems and will enforce judgments and orders across borders.
- dgellow 4y ago> Telegram to temporarily refuse data requests from Hong Kong courts amid security law The headline you linked makes it clear it was temporary. Which mean they do of course cooperate in normal situation. Otherwise they would be blocked everywhere, you cannot maintain a service such as a chat application without cooperating with governments. There is no story here, Telegram shared information with BKA in cases of terrorism and child abuse, as every service operating in Germany would and should do.
- tzumby 4y agoI agree that they should, the story is that they can. Err, not a story, it’s a known fact that they don’t encrypt communication.
- saos 4y agoThe app does have E2E encryption. It's just not the default. My one wish is they would change this.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI know, and I agree. MTProtov1 criticisms aside, the E2EE system Telegram uses is perfectly safe. It's just disabled by default, unavailable in group chats or channels, and enabling it reduces usability (i.e. you can't use multiple devices to chat if you enable E2EE). Telegram as a chat app has the best UX of any chat app out there in my opinion, so the lack of proper E2EE is simply disappointing. I don't really trust either, but I consider WhatsApp more secure than Telegram, despite Meta mining my metadata.
- saos 4y ago> but I consider WhatsApp more secure than Telegram, despite Meta mining my metadata Ha, I still prefer Telegram. I just use secret chats by default and enjoy the awesome UX
- prophesi 4y agoYes, Secret Chat's awesome UX of requiring both recipients to be online and the inability to use it on desktop.
- stereoradonc 4y agoTry Unigram to start "secret chats" though it will not sync with other clients. Unigram works in Windows Desktop.
- tptacek 4y agothe E2EE system Telegram uses is perfectly safe Is it? How would you go about confirming that?]
- alaricus 4y ago> WhatsApp more secure than Telegram Why is that? With WhatsApp client being closed source, we simply don't know if it really is doing E2EE at all.
- cabirum 4y agoThese days, any popular messaging app that won't cooperate with local law (by choice or by design in case of e2e) would just be banned/ removed from stores in Germany or most other countries. Strong encryption for wide audience cannot exist today.
- jeroenhd 4y agoSignal works fine in Germany, doesn't it?
- ce4 4y agoThey also have the user's phone number and in most cases their phone's adress book. It's not really about breaking e2e encryption but rather "reveal the identities of following users please". That could be due to all sorts of illegal activities (eg. hate speech, sale of banned substances, terrorism, child abuse, etc.)
- tptacek 4y agoSignal cannot in fact provide your address book to German (or any other) authorities. The whole point of Signal's design, and the reason it's less featureful than things like Telegram, is that it's designed not to collect serverside metadata about who's talking to who.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoUnfortunately, Telegram doesn't cooperate with German authorities in the majority of cases, because it operates out of the jurisdiction. Telegram probably figured if they don't at least share information on child abuse and terrorism, they'll just motivate regulatory action.
- svnpenn 4y ago> Unfortunately Why is that unfortunate? If I patronize a company, I want to be damn sure they are only giving up info to LEO when it's absolutely necessary.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoIf I'm a decent Human being I'd rather no company helps criminals do crime stuff. The standards to turn over such information should not be decided by a private entity but by democratically enacted and enforced laws. Is enforcement of child porn prosecution "absolutely necessary"? Are death threats ok? Where's the line? I don't think a private company sitting in an unaccountable jurisdiction should make that decision. I trust German courts a lot more in that regard.
- Zak 4y agoI'm inclined to agree, partly. If companies have the information, they should not have the last word about whether law enforcement gets access. That said, I do consider properly secure communication tools desirable and am very concerned about ongoing attempts to ban them. The uncomfortable truth is that if a communication method isn't secure for child molesters and terrorists, it isn't really secure for anyone.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoIn the case of Telegram they do require you to use a mobile phone number to sign up and use their service. Mainly so they can be sure you don't abuse THEM, mostly. So the safety of criminals from law enforcement does come from Telegram refusing to give up information they have. And this concerns an area of crimes were the perpetrators don't very actively evade detection. There are other means to do so. And in the case of Germany, openly and publicly criticizing against the state is no problem as long as you don't propose to violently overthrow the state.
- gsich 4y agoThis is unrelated to encryption. Telegram is still encrypted, otherwise you wouldn't need to ask them.
- UltraViolence 4y agoIt's not end-to-end encrypted. Of course the communication between the client app and the server is encrypted using TLS. But this allows Telegram itself to see the content of the conversation when it arrives on their servers. This has piked the interest of LEA, who want continuous, real-time access to that information.
- mr_mitm 4y ago> Did anyone expect otherwise? In a sense, yes. In case you don't speak German, the article [0] touches on this: > Dass Telegram überhaupt Auskunft über Nutzer an Behörden erteilt, markiert zumindest eine vorsichtige Kehrtwende im Kurs des 2013 gegründeten Unternehmens. Lange bekamen deutsche Ermittler keinerlei Antworten, wenn sie wissen wollten, wer hinter Telegram-Konten steckt, die strafbare Inhalte im Netz verbreiten. Die Betreiber erklären auf ihrer Seite weiterhin: »Bis zum heutigen Tag haben wir 0 Byte Nutzerdaten an Dritte weitergegeben, einschließlich aller Regierungen.« In a nutshell, this is considered a turning point because Telegram's official stance is (even today) that they don't share data, not even with any government. And now they did, apparently. So yes, this definitely news, if not a bit surprising. The German government has even made hints that they will seek to ban Telegram from app stores if they continue to refuse to comply with law enforcement [1] [0] https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/apps/telegram-gibt-nutzerdaten-an-das-bundeskriminalamt-a-0e4d3fcb-8081-4b87-b062-db412bbc294b https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/apps/telegram-gibt-nutzerdat... [1] https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/netzpolitik/faeser-will-telegram-aus-den-app-stores-werfen-lassen-a-30f191c7-ecb6-4d2c-997d-cfceadd2eb60 https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/netzpolitik/faeser-will-tele...
- anony999 4y ago>> In a nutshell, this is considered a turning point because Telegram's official stance is (even today) that they don't share data, not even with any government. If you care about your privacy the "official stance" alone is close to worthless. That includes governments and corporations as well. I think we already learned that. Just like on security you need in defense in depth on privacy(i.e. hardware, software, and "official policy" as well).
- BelleOfTheBall 4y agoTheir stance has always been that they don't protect terrorism suspects, they even had a channel where they reported how many ISIS groups/channels got shut down.
- jjav 4y ago> Telegram's official stance[...] ... doesn't really matter. This is something I find surprisingly difficult to get through to people at both a personal and professional level (as I often work in security-related projects). People speak of whether they trust this or that entity. Reality is that it's an irrelevant discussion. Trusting an organization is always misplaced, no matter who they are. If you hand over data to an organization, you must immediately assume that data is compromised. Yes, that's all SaaS and all cloud providers, for example. Any party who could see the data in unencryted form, you need to assume they have it and can potentially at some point abuse it. This has nothing to do with the ethics of whoever is running the given organization at the moment. There are many points in time in various organizations where they truly protect the data. I thank you. But it's not a stable situation. Things can change. Less ethical management can come in during a reorg and suddenly everything is fair game and the consumer won't know until it is too late. And always there is the threat of governments demanding the data, at which point no matter how ethical the organization may be, nothing matters since there is nothing they can do. For any data that could at any level be potentially sensitive, you must make sure it is either not sent through third parties at all, or be encrypted with keys that only you control. Otherwise, assume it is compromised and sold to every bidder.
- wruza 4y agois a mostly unencrypted … of course it's going to cooperate if local law enforcement comes knocking on their door with a warrant I don’t see how these are connected. All messengers will hand over all metadata they have to comply. The chatgroups in focus themselves are mostly public groups, you don’t have to play james bond to read what’s there. LEAs are arriving to the scene from that vector, not the other way round. “The NGO CeMAS monitors 3,000 German-language channels & groups for "disinformation, antisemitism, and right-wing extremism." - it’s literally in the tweet, man. Metadata logging is unrelated to encryption, not sure what’s the sensation is without comparing what messengers will actually have on hands in case of a warrant, minus publicly accessible info.
- arpanetus 4y agoIt really doesn't matter, or in general you can never be sure that any app that stores any data won't ever meet requests of any officials or any people with guns. Especially the case of Telegram was quite simple, since SEC filed a complaint we could clearly see who are the main investors. It's not necessarily about the country or investors either. You can choose only the place where things are stored and expect the company to act according to local laws (for e.g. Protonmail doing its proton things in Swiss judiciary). And, I guess, a thing we have to teach people is something vague and unclear like post-privacy scene, like how one has to operate knowing that pigeon mails can always be spoofed, no matter how encrypted the conversation is.
- ahmedk92 4y agoHonest question, how do you prove you don't own user data?
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> If you don't want your chats to end up in the hands of law enforcement don't use chats meet in person like all respectable criminals do Anyway it would still mean that you're being investigated for something and the court authorized the request Now imagine what would happen if US law enforcement got hands on the chats of the Texas shooter. Truth is they didn't do anything even though he posted publicly about what he was going to do. https://www.cbsnews.com/live-updates/texas-school-shooting-uvalde-facebook-messages/#app https://www.cbsnews.com/live-updates/texas-school-shooting-u... So maybe the idea that anyone is spied and controlled by law enforcement or governments is not exactly true.
- TimeBearingDown 4y agoDon’t worry, it’s worse. They collect everything, illegally and without any ethics. Then they’re incompetent as well, so action doesn’t happen when it should. Instead we get capricious, haphazard enforcement, and a dark future with all of this stored in permanent record to be retrieved using the search tools of 2040 and weaponized later when we later make nuisances of ourselves in response to future legislation.