3 ms·
From the sideline chorus of cynics; the Achilles heel of Effective Altruism is that most alleged altruists are the usual fair-weather activists who want to be s
by roenxi 4y ago
From the sideline chorus of cynics; the Achilles heel of Effective Altruism is that most alleged altruists are the usual fair-weather activists who want to be seen to be on the right side but are not actually interested in solving any real world problems.
The only lens that works when viewing politics (and altruism is a form of politics) is to assume people are miscommunicating their intended outcome. We've had thousands of years of experience with cause and effect, hundreds of years experience with modern mathematics for evaluating evidence and all the resources in the world to run experiments if we cared to. If people aren't trying to deploy that beyond 3-word-slogans and "we all know what is going on here, it is obvious, no need to check the hypothesis!" style strategies then they aren't trying to improve the situation. The first thing anyone runs in to when they try to solve a problem is that nobody involved seems to change their mind after reviewing contradictory evidence and that is a huge barrier to change.
There is a clear gap between how people who are interested in solving a problem act and how the average person out there to "do good" acts. If people are trying to improve a situation the strategy & understanding of that situation should keep pivoting. And there should be a steady stream of minor discoveries as apparently obvious truth turns out to be false.
- avgcorrection 4y ago> The only lens that works when viewing politics (and altruism is a form of politics) is to assume people are miscommunicating their intended outcome. Sometimes group A and B just want all of X and neither are willing to compromise. No miscommunication.
- bcbrown 4y ago> The only lens that works when viewing politics (and altruism is a form of politics) is to assume people are miscommunicating their intended outcome. Could you explain what you mean by this? I'm intrigued.
- roenxi 4y agoTricky question to answer, particularly without picking specific examples and getting too political. I suppose what I'm trying to say is there is pretty overwhelming evidence that the voting public doesn't understand cause and effect of the policies they are calling for. Eg, spending 20 minutes debating politics with anyone makes it apparent that at least one and often all sides of a debate are people who don't really understand the particulars of the situation, in most cases haven't read the policies involved or done much research beyond listening to some with charisma and maybe some credentials. They don't change their minds. Then the actual politicians build up their rhetoric and positions, and they have to mirror what the voters are thinking to get votes. But the voters are often demanding incoherent or stupid policies that aren't at all aligned with expert advice. My personal favourite showcase is a combination like loose border control combined with a strong welfare state - no fair & feasible way to do both. The situation ends up with politicians who have to say things that clearly they don't believe in service of goals they cannot pursue, in order to hold office. If they were serious about what they are communicating, we'd expect them to check the evidence & maybe run a couple of trials to see how feasible the whole plan is. And if they did they would change their mind quite quickly, because there is actually quite a lot of evidence out there about what works. But they won't, because they aren't serious & that they are actually doing is mimicking the opinions of the large, oft-changing and schizophrenic opinion of a mass of voters. And the voters really don't care because big groups of people are not at all altruistic outside their in-group.
- bcbrown 4y agoOk, sounds like we agree. I phrase it as, people have their inherent political positions, and then they rationalize them post-hoc.
- skybrian 4y agoWhy is "being interested in solving [...] problems" your metric? How often do big problems really get solved? If donating money can be shown to save lives, why isn't that a good thing in itself, even if it doesn't solve a huge problem like malaria? I'm not sure it's true, though. Many EA discussions seem to be about solving big problems, which seems like an indicator of interest?