6 ms·
Sovereign Debt is most certainly not "Risk Free." I'm not sure that the Greek Bond Default is particularly meaningful - and is certainly not a very big deal.
by ghshephard 15y ago
Sovereign Debt is most certainly not "Risk Free." I'm not sure that the Greek Bond Default is particularly meaningful - and is certainly not a very big deal. The market had anticipated (and priced in) this default almost six months ago. It was a big deal _then_ but it's been a foregone conclusion for most of the year. If anything - the deal negotiated here is probably showing some upside to what was expected, so this form of default is actually positive news - akin to a company showing a drop in profits, but less of a drop than what wall street expected.
- anigbrowl 15y agoI'd say six months of agonized indecision over what the outcome will be is most certainly a big deal. If the markets had fully priced this in, then they wouldn't be swinging around wildly while the EU vacillates. Sure, they're volatile because they're trying to guess how this will ripple out to affects other heavily indebted European economies such as Italy, Spain and so on. But the fact is that nobody knows what size haircut the Greek bondholders are being expected to take, which makes pricing more or less impossible unless one assumes it will be 100% and treats anything less as a windfall. No asset class is completely risk-free, and bonds are no exception. The yield on a bond is meant to be reflective of its risk factor. But in practice, sovereign debt default is rare and the yield so low that buying bonds is equivalent to leaving your money in the bank - a riskier proposition in some countries than others, but an inherently conservative investment all the same. In absolute terms, they're risky, but so is putting your money under the mattress. In relative terms, they're the investment equivalent of the savings account: nobody buys bonds in a politically stable country with the expectation of losing money on the deal, they buy them to keep pace with inflation.
- ghshephard 15y ago^VIX is down 14% to 25.51 as of 12:25 Pacific - The Greek Bond Default is, today, widely seen as a positive step. I agree with you that, two years ago, Bond (or, for that matter, Municipal or state bonds in the US) debt in politically stable countries was seen as very low risk. But, in 2006, Real Estate was seen as a safe investment as well. In fact, I was openly mocked, not just debated, but mocked, as being uneducated and unsophisticated when I tried to draw parallels with the US Real Estate Market and what had happened in Japan, just 10 years earlier, in attempting to suggest that perhaps Real Estate doesn't "Always go up." If the last 4-5 years has taught us anything, it's that there is risk in everything. One of the few bastions that still seems to remain standing is people's belief in the FDIC, and the fact that if they put their money in a US Bank, that they are protected up to $250,000. People need to realize that there are no "Risk Free" investments, that everything has a chance of default. People need to start relying on Capital Asset Pricing Models (CAPM), and diversifying their investments across a broad portfolio - including hard stock such as land, livestock, and shelter. This is the only rationale response in the face of default risk that we are surrounded by - and the sooner we start practicing that consistently, the sooner we will become more resilient as a society.
- anigbrowl 15y agoI think we agree about these things; you're quite right that 'risk-free' is an inherently complacent evaluation, and that even the FDIC is only as good as the resolve of a majority of politicians to stand behind the government's promises (something that's increasingly questionable these days). I don't fully agree with you about CAPM. Not about it being the smart strategy, but about everyone needing to practice it. I enjoy economics as a hobby but actually doing CAPM evaluations makes my head hurt. It's not realistic or even productive to expect everyone to be an economist. I'm studying law, and while I think life would be an awful simpler if everyone else knew more law and thought like a lawyer, the fact is that most people don't find it all that interesting and it's more rational for them to outsource their legal problems to a legal nerd in most cases. I'm probably interpreting 'people' in a much broader sense than you meant it; it just strikes me that our aggregate productivity is to some extent dependent on the trustworthiness and prudence of our institutions, and it's not irrational to want an institutional framework that rewards fiscal prudence so as to make time available for other activities.