3 ms·
>It's somehow disappointing that human race hasn't been able to come up with (or more precisely - hasn't evolved enough for) a better system. A little off topi
by yuhong 15y ago
>It's somehow disappointing that human race hasn't been able to come up with (or more precisely - hasn't evolved enough for) a better system.
A little off topic, but since it was bought up, I am going to mention that I have been thinking of a systems where members of Parliament or Congress are hired by a committee from the general public and then last for something like 20 years terms (unless he or she themselves resign of course). It would take advantage of the separation of powers spreading power out among different kinds of people, so it would not have the problems a dictatorship or monarchy have. It would also allow specialization.
- VladRussian 15y agoit sounds like a hybrid between Supreme Court and the corporate board/CEO scheme. To me the problem lies deeper - it is in the principle that government/state is a concentrated power (taken away from people by force) and what behaves like a violent force against the people. Any tweaks to the current system is tweaks with who and how authorizes the application of that violence. The government should get it power through willful delegation from people. The US was a nice attempt to implement the idea. Unfortunately the "willful" isn't there anymore. And without it the government looses moral ground under its violence. The next stage would be government/state system that acts not through force. What can be used instead of force? Persuasion/education, consensus...? it is though too far fetched for any specifics.
- yuhong 15y ago>hired by a committee from the general public Actually, randomly selecting people from a state or province, similar to a lottery draw, may be a better idea. The key is to make sure it is a large variety of people.