6 ms·
I honestly would be interested for an actual chef to weigh in. I'm all for using an induction stovetop at home, but have people actually seen chefs fry over an
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I honestly would be interested for an actual chef to weigh in.
I'm all for using an induction stovetop at home, but have people actually seen chefs fry over an open flame? They're moving the pan around, lifting it up and around, using it to toss the food, etc. That would basically be impossible with an induction stovetop.
It seems rather tone deaf to me to not address the issues that the chefs are actually concerned about.
- bergenty 4y agoI don’t know about chefs but my mom always complains about how hard it is to cook with induction heating because it takes very long to switch between high and low temperatures. You can’t be as reactive with induction cooking (alternatively moving the pan off the direct heat and moving it back again might achieve this)
- mason55 4y agoAre you thinking of electric coil? Induction heats up super fast (way faster than gas or electric coil) because the stove itself doesn’t get warm - it transfers energy directly into the pan.
- b112 4y agoIt's an interface issue. Instead of a knob, it's usually a touch interface, with +/- control, and slowish.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoUI is orthogonal to the heat source.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoNot when the UI includes (or does not include) a view of the heat source.
- marvin 4y agoDon't understand why this was downvoted. The induction stoves I've used all had a touchpad controls, for some reason. They take one second to change the power output 10%, with hotkeys for 100% and 40%. It would be trivial to add a dial with some simple fail-safe. They're incredibly responsive, though, more so than the gas stoves I've used. Never tried the following with gas, I'm guessing it would work, but you can easily turn down the power as a pot of pasta has started boiling over, and it'll stop before the foam pours over the top of the pot.
- wheels 4y agoIt's just a stupid trend in electric cooktop design, not something specific to induction. I've got an SMEG induction combo oven/stove and it has real knobs – out front, where they belong. They also make induction cooktops with real knobs.
- dhzhzjsbevs 4y agoKnow what brand? I'm planning a remodel and I fucking hate this "smart" trend in my home appliances. Luckily at least the dumb stuff is cheaper. Already found a knobby oven but all the induction tops are damned touch screens.
- cthalupa 4y agoIf cost is no concern, the Breville Polyscience Control Freak has a knob and is generally considered the Rolls Royce of induction burners.
- wheels 4y agoHonestly: it looks pretty gimicky, and the dimensions and wattage don't put it in Rolls Royce category for serious cooks. It does 1800 watts into < 20 cm (8 in.) whereas the central burner on my SMEG induction stove does 3000 watts into 27 cm (11 in.). A gastronomy induction stove will get closer to 5000 watts per burner. It looks like it's far more targeted towards the "magical cooking" crowd than prosumer. It looks like you could probably replace a sous vide bath and a deep fryer with it, but most serious cooks already have those as separate devices, and you'd have to give up your "best" burner while doing so.
- agar 4y agoSwitching between high and low on my induction cooktop is immediate. If you can see red coils on your mom's stove under the glass, it's not induction.
- petre 4y agoYour mom's stove has the stupid +/- touch UI, just like mine. Using a knob would solve the problem. I am not complaining because +/- is easier to clean. The other issue is that induction is invisible, there is no flame. But moving stuff around on x-y has the same effect as with a gas stove. On induction, the pan is the stove. Take it off the induction and the heat subsides. Move it off center and you heat only part of the pan.
- pwagland 4y agoInductive cooktops are quite reactive, the pan stops generating heat as soon as the electricity is cut off, and while the glass does get hot, it cools reasonably quickly, at least IME. Older style "convection" electric cookers were glacially slow in responding to heat changes, since there was a massive amount of heat stored in the heating element.
- jdgoesmarching 4y agoI can’t imagine many professionals would wildly appreciate changing their core tool from underneath them, regardless of whether the tool is actually better. If I wanted to stir the pot with a grenade, I’d say it’s like asking Vim users whether they should all move to VS Code.
- rascul 4y agoWell they probably should move to emacs. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpdngXQOkBI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpdngXQOkBI
- pkulak 4y ago> I’d say it’s like asking Vim users whether they should all move to VS Code. If Vim was actively contributing to climate change and fouling the air of everyone around me, I'd switch tomorrow. VS Code has Vim bindings, I'm sure. I'll be okay. We're long past the point where everybody keeps being able to do their first favorite thing at all times, _and_ we somehow also solve this huge problem we've gotten ourselves into.
- realreality 4y agoVS Code obviously contributes more to climate change than Vim.
- pixl97 4y agoYet Vim vs Emacs arguments contribute to a lot of hot air... Zingggg
- xigoi 4y agoI'd gladly move to VS Code if it was more efficient than Vim (and not controlled by Micro$oft, but that's irrelevant). However, that's far from being the case.
- mikkergp 4y agoI think _because_ of their intimate knowledge of the craft, Chef's are going to give you a wider variety of answers with less certainty than anyone else.
- wheels 4y agoNot a chef, but an avid eater and obsessive home cook: I eat at a lot of high end restaurants (and usually a couple Michelin starred places per year), many with open kitchens, and in the last 5 years I've noticed a trend towards induction. From the high end cookery blogs that I've read, it's mostly about reducing heat in the kitchen. I have worked in kitchens in the past, and it's difficult to understate the quality of life improvement by a significant reduction in kitchen temperature. At home I've also switched to induction, and it's been in general great. Charcoal is actually the trickier one to replace in high end cookery since it's very difficult to simulate the amount of radiant energy with electricity.
- marak830 4y agoChef here: I've used induction, but the biggest annoyance is heat loss when lifting a pan. Most pans section dishes are moved quite rapidly, lifting then off of the burner, to toss the ingredients(I could be cooking 5-6 dishes at once, so speed is very important), with a gas burner this doesn't matter as the radiant heat is there. Now I'm assuming there are radiant stovetops that are designed for hospitality, but I've yet to see one, the only I have used the heat started dissipating rapidly when lifting the pan, and my wife was freaking out when the pan made contact thinking that I was going to break the cooktop.
- syntheweave 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the market is unready to provide something professionals are happy with, and that could be a disaster - but if it's mandated throughout the state, the demand will exist for a supplier to try to do better. I can say that for my own home cooking purposes, electric coils have always been acceptable, and that's really where my attention is with the ban - I already know I won't feel direct pain from it; whereas restaurant food as a consumer service is a case of "just make something good and I don't care how you do it if it's in line with laws and norms", and the rest is a matter of how much has to change in operations, cooking style etc to make a technology switch. Gas cooking has only been around since roughly the 1850's, following heating and lighting introductions; coal stoves remained popular well into the early 20th century, but coal in cooking today mostly conjures up backyard barbecue. It could easily turn out that the gas-centric styles become a "flash in the pan" niche if we make the switch.
- marak830 4y agoIt's all about the heat transfer, previous to gas we used bur ing wood, so a high heat transfer without physical contact. I'm not sure if there is even a way for a ln induction cooktop to provide heat over a distance. But sure, if it's mandated then chefs will have to change their cooking style, which -with plenty if grumbling from chefs - won't be the end of the world.
- jolux 4y ago