3 ms·
This feels plausible but if someone wanted to SWAT someone ... there's probably other / likely easier ways to do it. Having to registrar a domain, come up with
by duxup 4y ago
This feels plausible but if someone wanted to SWAT someone ... there's probably other / likely easier ways to do it.
Having to registrar a domain, come up with some content, or just point the domain at some content ... then transfer it ... and then make a big deal out of it (getting attention is hard) and hoping nobody notices the easy to prove explanation that "someone transferred this to me" ... and avoiding getting caught seems like a big ordeal.
The story here is "hey random guy also hosts horrible stuff at his domain that he registered in his own name ... well he did". Maybe some folks run with that, but I'm not so so sure.
The mechanism here seems "easy" on the surface, but actually rather complicated, and odds of success seems low.
- ghaff 4y agoI tend to agree. There are certainly potential bad outcomes but a lot of it boils down to SWATing and there are almost certainly easier and less traceable ways to SWAT someone. And getting attention on Twitter or whatnot presumably means getting the attention of people who can quickly determine that something is amiss. ADDED: While this process should probably be fixed in this case, at the end of the day, there's probably no foolproof way to keep people from sending you illegal stuff in either the physical or digital world in general.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoSWATing someone generally involves two things. 1. Somehow you get the IP address of the target maybe by playing a game with them (which can be p2p) or some other way of getting the IP address and then geolocating (this can partially be avoided by using a VPN 2. If someone is live-streaming outside in the real world you recognize where the person is. I haven't heard of someone being SWATed by a nefarious actor inside a company and never really a domain probably because you either purchased some protection plan to avoid spam so that if someone looks you up on the domain they won't find any information and also most people don't self host things using their own domain. With that said that doesn't mean it is impossible to occur. For example Krebs on security has had SWATing attempts due to the content he posts. If you aren't live-streaming video games or doing IRL posts and or not reporting on bad actors you should consider other things to worry about.
- Beltalowda 4y ago> SWATing someone generally involves two things. A third requirement is living in a country with an overaggressive police force with more guns than some they know what to do with ready to shoot your dog or anything else that moves. Not that it doesn't make sense to consider this situation when designing systems such as domain transfers, but this is the "Real Problem"™ IMO.
- formerkrogemp 4y agoJust a friendly reminder that there are approximately 120 guns to 100 people in the US. That are registered.
- vkou 4y agoWhich makes no-knock police home invasions even more baffling, as a policy.
- SahAssar 4y ago> IP address and then geolocating IP geolocation is not anywhere near precise enough to get you an address. It can give you a best-guess as to what city you are in (and even that is a guess), but not much better. If you aim to swat someone and you only know the IP you would contact the police who would contact the ISP to get your address connected to the internet subscription.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoYea, I should have probably indicated that you have to do a bit more of open source intelligence to get people's locations.
- SahAssar 4y agoIn this case what do you mean by "open source intelligence"? Like what would your actual steps be to go from my IP to actually knowing my name/address? A whois lookup would get you the ISP, a maxmind lookup would get you a guess at a city, but besides that what can you do?