4 ms·
> After all, it’s their right to as a private company. Why do people always use the term "private company"? Twitter is a publicly owned corporation. If the Mus
by lapcat 4y ago
> After all, it’s their right to as a private company.
Why do people always use the term "private company"? Twitter is a publicly owned corporation. If the Musk deal goes through, it'll be private. But I'm not sure what work the word "private" is supposed to be doing.
- basisword 4y agoThere are different types of private company. You have mentioned two of them. Twitter is is a publicly traded private company.
- cmeacham98 4y ago"Private company", in this context, means "not the government". The opposite would be "public sector", referring to the government or companies it owns/runs.
- lapcat 4y agoExcept, how many government owned companies are there in the US? What's the point in saying "private company" if 99.99+% of companies are private?
- mypalmike 4y agoTwitter is a company. Is that statement sufficient to stop further nitpicking?
- lapcat 4y agoI think there's a kind of ideology behind the phrase that personifies companies, giving them "rights" that become even more important than individual human rights. And there's the weird idea that companies can do whatever they want, despite the mountains of government regulation of corporate behavior. Almost every use of "private company" is in contrast to a publicly traded company. Except when people start talking about "rights", and then they're apparently using it in a different way, which I find very odd and ideological.
- fennecfoxen 4y agoThe private nature of the company is the specific thing that matters here. It is right to emphasize that through use of the adjective. You’d better ask “why use the word ‘company’ at all” and the answer is that it’s a useful noun upon which to supply the critical adjective.
- lapcat 4y ago> The private nature of the company is the specific thing that matters here. Is it? Actually, no argument has been given why a government owned company couldn't block links to whatever the government wanted.
- fennecfoxen 4y agowell, in the US, the First Amendment would start come into play in interesting ways, depending on whether the content itself is considered an expression of the government itself or just general.
- dfxm12 4y agoWhat's the point in saying "private company" Different rules, laws, regulations, etc. apply to private sector vs public sector. Specifically in this case, OP is implying that a theoretical public sector social network wouldn't be allowed to block linking to mastodon because of the second (EDIT: no, wait, first amendment!) amendment, but that Twitter is well within its rights since they are in the private sector. Whether that's true or not, I dunno.
- lapcat 4y ago> OP is implying that a theoretical public sector social network I dispute that the OP was implying or even thinking anything about a theoretical public sector social network.
- dfxm12 4y agoOK.
- lapcat 4y agoWhy wouldn't a theoretical public sector social network have the right to block any links that the government wanted to block?
- dfxm12 4y agoI know I mistakingly had the second amendment written as the reasoning in my previous post when you had replied, but I meant the first amendment. Like I said, I don't know how far the first amendment would or wouldn't apply in this situation. In any case, it would likely have to be tested in court.
- dane-pgp 4y ago> wouldn't be allowed to block linking to mastodon because of the second amendment I don't know how I feel about a well regulated Militia overthrowing the government to protect free software and open standards...
- dokem 4y agoThe government controls some things. Companies control some other things. Gov things are 'public', company things are 'private'. I don't know what you are trying to argue. This is how the west works 101 stuff.
- lapcat 4y ago> The government controls some things. Companies control some other things. The government actually controls companies. In fact they wouldn't exist as legal entities without the government. I feel there is a common misconception that "private companies can do whatever they want", belied by the existence of government regulation, but nonetheless a misconception regularly employed to dismiss antitrust concerns, for example.
- dokem 4y agoI don't think anyone is unaware of the concept of law. There are significant 'firewalls' between the public and private sectors, otherwise we would just have facism/communism or anarcho-capitalism.
- lapcat 4y ago> I don't think anyone is unaware of the concept of law. They're aware of the concept of law but frequently unaware of specific laws. ;-)
- krallja 4y agoHelpfully, the US Government, specifically the SEC, defines the term “public company” for us: “There are two commonly understood ways in which a company is considered public: first, the company’s securities trade on public markets; and second, the company discloses certain business and financial information regularly to the public. In general, we use the term to refer to a company that has public reporting obligations.” They’re talking about $TWTR, not Amtrak.
- mardifoufs 4y agoI think that part is tongue in cheek. Because that's usually the argument repeated ad nauseam whenever anyone criticizes social media speech moderation policies. But as other comments have already mentioned, you are confusing two different meaning of private/public.
- lapcat 4y ago> But as other comments have already mentioned, you are confusing two different meaning of private/public. No, I'm not not confused. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31609113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31609113
- qiskit 4y ago> Twitter is a publicly owned corporation It's a publicly traded company. Not a publicly owned company. The owners of twitter are primarily private citizens/corporations, not public/government. > But I'm not sure what work the word "private" is supposed to be doing. Public = government. Private = not government.
- lapcat 4y agoIt's too late to edit the above comment, but let me clarify: When I ask, Why do people always use the term "private company", this is somewhat of a rhetorical question. I'm not asking for an explanation of what "private company" means, as if I were an ignorant simpleton. That's the uncharitable reading of my comment. Rather, I'm asking for the justification of the use of "private company" as a rhetorical term in the defense of the actions of corporations. I see this rhetorical usage constantly. Everyone knows that Twitter is a company. That Apple is a company. That Google is a company, etc. And everyone knows that these companies are not run by the government. None of this ever needs to be explained in an argument. So the question is, what rhetorical force do people think the term "private company" gives them in defense of corporate actions? Or maybe the question is, what's the psychology behind the use of this form of rhetoric? There are various government regulations that do or could be applied to these companies. Antitrust is very relevant for the tech giants. Communications Decency Act. Whether these regulations actually will be applied to these companies is another question, but it's a legitimate debate that can't be simply dismissed by "private company, anything goes".