4 ms·
Ok? They are a private company and they can block links that they don't like. Facebook has done the exact same thing and nothing happened. You are free to comp
by rvz 4y ago
Ok? They are a private company and they can block links that they don't like. Facebook has done the exact same thing and nothing happened.
You are free to complain, criticise them, scream at these companies or protest, but like I have said many times before they will not change and it is futile to believe that they ever will as long as they 'moderate' or do whatever they want to do on their own platforms.
So unsurprising this is.
- natly 4y agoThey're a private company and it's a shitty thing to do. No one is saying regulation should necessarily step in, but we don't have to like it and we shouldn't not complain and not talk about it just because of that.
- user3939382 4y ago> They are a private company I've been hearing this a lot lately, surprisingly from people who consider themselves to be politically left. I say surprisingly because historically, leftist ideology has been quick to solve problems with corporate behavior with regulations, whereas traditionally it's been the right pushing laissez-faire. In any case, guys - private company doesn't mean your behaviors and policies aren't constrained. There are innumerable laws that regulate corporate behavior and these can be expanded at any time. Corporate behavior can be constrained without limitation if the public so chooses.
- jaywalk 4y agoPeople being purely hypocritical when it benefits them is an all too common theme these days. As far as politics go, the only goal is power. Any steps towards gaining more power are right and just, regardless of how hypocritical they may be.
- superkuh 4y agoDefinitely. The act of incorportation has one goal: to abstract away risk and liability. Human people controlling the company will not be held liable for their actions or debts. But this comes with the trade-off of having to accept regulations. If you want to have full control over your property then do not incorporate and give the property to the corporate person. I can block links to mastadon on my truly private (ie, owned by a human person) website without consequence. "Private" corporate persons have more regulatory burdens for obvious reasons.
- anotherman554 4y ago"I've been hearing this a lot lately, surprisingly from people who consider themselves to be politically left. I say surprisingly because historically, leftist ideology has been quick to solve problems with corporate behavior with regulations, whereas traditionally it's been the right pushing laissez-faire." On this web site when I hear people talking about controlling what social media platforms do via regulation, most of the time it seems to me like passing a law where the government says the following journalists must have articles each week on the New York Times front page. (And none of them are actually going to be journalists so much as "journalists") Other people see it more like passing a law saying the telephone company can't block your telephone access. I guess my point is framing every discussion of social media as "regulation good or bad" isn't very useful.
- dane-pgp 4y agoFortunately there are a couple of bright lines that can be drawn between those two hypothetical laws. Firstly, there is only one front page of each edition of the NYT, and the page has a very limited data/readability capacity. On Twitter, every user's page is a front page if you want it to be (although admittedly the recommendation of people/tweets by "the algorithm" starts to feel like an editorial decision, which invites further scrutiny). More significantly, though, once an organization has built a social or telephone network, it is actually more expensive to disconnect or delete messages based on the opinions contained within them than it is to just allow them to continue moving between users. This is in contrast to the (physical) NYT, where editors necessarily have to whitelist every piece of content, and forcing articles past that whitelist has significant cost implications (even if no one reads them).
- lapcat 4y ago> They are a private company Not yet. Twitter is still a publicly owned company.
- jaywalk 4y agoWhen people talk about "private companies" they're referring to entities that are not government-owned/controlled. Being listed on the stock market does not change that.
- lapcat 4y agoIt feels redundant. How many government companies are there in the US?
- chipotle_coyote 4y agoIt seems like you're working overtime in these comments to deny that the context in which we use the phrase "private company" matters. This is a pretty common usage, analogous to "private good" vs. "public good"; surely this discussion on HN is not genuinely the first time you've ever been exposed to it?
- lapcat 4y ago> surely this discussion on HN is not genuinely the first time you've ever been exposed to it? Of course it's not the first time. That's precisely why I'm making a big deal out of it, because I've seen it over and over. I'm suggesting that there's a kind of unwarranted ideology behind the usage that doesn't accurately reflect the legal reality, and gives the impression that companies have unlimited rights when in fact they're strictly regulated in countless ways. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31609113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31609113 We could talk about Section 230, for example, which is obviously important with regard to Twitter and whether it can operate. It feels to me like people are "working overtime" to handwave about "government owned companies", of which nobody has given any examples. Nor have they explained why a government owned company wouldn't have the right to block any links that the government wanted to block. If anything, a government owned company would probably be treated as exempt from some rules that apply to "private" companies.
- weberer 4y ago>You are free to complain, criticise them That's exactly what's going on right now