4 ms·
I haven't used Thunar, but I wrote a GTK+-based file manager that was fairly popular Way Back When (late 90s, early 00s perhaps) called "gentoo". Congratulatio
by unwind 4y ago
I haven't used Thunar, but I wrote a GTK+-based file manager that was fairly popular Way Back When (late 90s, early 00s perhaps) called "gentoo".
Congratulations for landing a GSoC gig of course, that must be awesome. A project I worked on ages ago almost tried to apply, but all we got was the t-shirt. :)
My take on the ideas:
Undo/Redo sounds like a lot of work, at least if it is going to be integrated well and supported for many operations. Again I don't know Thunar, but I guess you're going to have to figure out if there is a command abstraction internally, and start storing a log of executed commands so that undo can compute the reverse action. I guess some commands ("delete" comes to mind) are really hard to undo without rather intricate changes such as inventing a trashcan and moving things there, and so on. It seems clever to start with this, it's a real heavy-weight.
File counts for folders sounds strange; if there's a size column I would of course assume it to show size for folders too, not a completely different thing like the number of contained objects. In gentoo there is an explicit command ("GetSize", if I remember correctly) that recursively computes the size of a directory, and replaces the on-disk inode-level size of the directory with that. It's explicit since it takes time (gentoo is not multi-threaded or async, so it will block) but on modern disks it will be very fast.
Picture-specific view sounds like a great idea, especially if it's possible to integrate it well so you don't have to re-implement a lot to get access to basic file management commands for that view.
- forgotpwd16 4y ago>such as inventing a trashcan Thunar supports the freedesktop Trash. That said I'm surprised it didn't had an undo/redo functionality for that long.
- unwind 4y agoAh, cool I was not aware of the Trash spec [1]. I had to check the date on it, it seems to have originated in 2004 and I think I was past peak gentoo development at that time. Or maybe I just didn't spend enough time keeping track of FreeDesktop. Thanks for clueing me in! [1]: https://specifications.freedesktop.org/trash-spec/trashspec-1.0.html https://specifications.freedesktop.org/trash-spec/trashspec-...
- fs111 4y agoI used gentoo-the-file-manager when I had a fluxbox based desktop. Thanks for creating it!
- unwind 4y agoAmazing, glad to hear it! Thanks! :D
- squarefoot 4y agoFor what is worth, I used Gentoo for some time many moons ago and it was pretty good, aside bringing back that DOpus feel from the good old Amiga days, however I found later than I didn't need all these functions and having a few icons on the taskbar opening Rox-Filer instances on the most used directories was faster. But anyway, thanks for creating it; it was a pretty solid piece of software.