5 ms·
Tracking carbon emissions is the most inefficient, ineffective and impractical method ever devised for reducing CO2 emissions. For example, my airline ticket h
by WalterBright 4y ago
Tracking carbon emissions is the most inefficient, ineffective and impractical method ever devised for reducing CO2 emissions.
For example, my airline ticket has a line with how many tons of carbon are emitted by my share of the flight. What the heck is anyone going to do with that? But with the carbon tax on jet fuel, the price of the ticket is definitely going to affect behavior. And, of course, taxing fuel is FAR easier than trying to accurately measure the carbon in the jet blast at every stage of a flight.
An efficient, effective, and practical way to do it is to tax the carbon content of fuels, and let the market do its thing with prices.
- WalterBright 4y agoAnother crazy thing is requiring companies to document their "carbon footprint". Doing this will require an army of technicians and accountants, with every incentive to tilt the results into looking "green". And then what does one do with that number? Harangue the company about it? Again, the simple, effective solution is just tax the carbon content in the fuel. If there's one thing the government does know how to do, it's tax things.
- abyssin 4y agoYesterday I read some part of a report made for a national company about their carbon footprint. They got an auditing firm to produce nice charts. Then they hired a communication agency to present the result to their employees. They literally wrote: “Don’t show this chart, we don’t want employees to lose motivation.” What the graph shows is that the main source of emissions for this company is their investments.
- guerrilla 4y ago> And, of course, taxing fuel is FAR easier than trying to accurately measure the carbon in the jet blast at every stage of a flight. Right, but that's exactly why we're not doing it... Anything that's actually effective would eat into profits too much and upset the people that the lobbyists and lawmakers work for.
- throwaway894345 4y agoIt's even a bit sadder than that. It would eat into profits mostly in the short term. In the longer term, we would get more efficient with our transportation and manufacturing practices: a whole host of decisions are made which assume certain energy prices--after a decade of gradually rising carbon prices, these assumptions would get revised and the whole system would be recalibrated to be more carbon efficient, thus keeping prices low for the consumer while also maintaining profitability for corporations. Moreover, we can start with an arbitrarily low carbon price so we don't break the economy (specifically the aforementioned profits), but the important bit is that we actually have a dial to turn to save the environment (which is presumably what investors fear).
- guerrilla 4y agoThat's true, both very good points... Higher-tech energy eventually gets us closer to "free" energy in the long-run. And yeah, we definitely should have faded it in.
- once_inc 4y agoI'm from the future. In a few years time, the EU and other large governments will have instituted Carbon tracking apps directly linked to bank account information which have been combined with CBDC's to directly tax you for spending on carbon emission heavy products. It will also limit that spending.
- fvaleye 4y agoSo there is a future? Good to know!
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoSome people/corporations use those numbers to tax themselves. Microsoft does this I think as part of their commitment to carbon neutrality. Better if it's done across society but not totally useless to be aware of that info even in the absence of a carbon tax. Also, if they tax the fuel (which they certainly should) someone still needs to work out how to apportion that to the individual customers. Does the first person signing up pay the full wack, do you average it across all tickets, what if the plane flies half full, and so on. This is the kind of thing airlines do every day for the cost of fuel anyway.
- gruez 4y ago>Also, if they tax the fuel (which they certainly should) someone still needs to work out how to apportion that to the individual customers. Why is this even a problem? Fuel costs money today, yet airlines are somehow able to "apportion that to the individual customers".
- WalterBright 4y agoRight. Every cost a company has is apportioned to the customers. This has to be done, otherwise a company cannot determine the price floor needed to stay in business.
- throwaway894345 4y agoI think this is probably more of a marketing thing. Even though data centers consume a fair amount of electricity, software companies generate a lot more revenue per unit energy than most industries, so it's a lot cheaper for them to appear green than for, say, an air freight company who might be doing a lot more to reduce emission rates than Microsoft and yet doesn't sound as impressive as Microsoft's "we're [almost] carbon neutral".
- WalterBright 4y agoConsider that so many thousands of companies are involved in the manufacture of the lowly pencil that there is no possible way to even determine the carbon footprint of it. Howinell can that work with a gigantic company like Microsoft? How can Microsoft's auditors come up with a remotely credible number? (They can't.) But what makes it all work is the pricing mechanism of the free market, not some auditing system. See Milton Friedman "Free to Choose"
- realreality 4y agoAn appropriately high tax on jet fuel would price the airline industry out of business. Obviously they’re going to resist that, so what’s the solution?
- Retric 4y agoTaxing carbon would impact airlines much less than you might think. A carbon tax high enough to basically kill off all ICE cars and fossil fuel power plants would modestly impact airfare costs. Airlines are convenient and take very direct routes while getting extreme fuel efficiency per passenger.
- realreality 4y agoAirlines are not efficient. The carbon footprint per passenger is about the same as driving a car for the same distance. And airlines have been flying empty planes during the pandemic. That's ridiculously wasteful.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoPandemic saw reduced passengers but it also saw vast reductions in flying down to as low as 9% of normal operations. So it had a smaller impact on averages than you might assume. In normal operations they are about 100 passenger miles per gallon of fuel and that’s straight line paths with 80% full aircraft.
- realreality 4y agoSeems like the “ghost flights” were a more recent issue: https://www.wired.com/story/airplanes-empty-slots-covid/ https://www.wired.com/story/airplanes-empty-slots-covid/ As for the fuel efficiency, this says 58mpg. Business class or first class are much worse, of course. And private jets simply shouldn’t exist… https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mhh__ 4y agoThe UK has a Carbon tax of sorts, surprise surprise it worked.