2 ms·
I wouldn't necessarily argue that the federal government should not have any new powers, but rather than they should not simply assume them in contravention of
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
I wouldn't necessarily argue that the federal government should not have any new powers, but rather than they should not simply assume them in contravention of the constitution. If the federal government wishes to expand its purview, it should have to get a constitutional amendment passed. Yes, that requires quite a lot of work and requires more consensus than political decisions normally require; good, that's a feature.
(Personally, I think we'd almost certainly be a lot better off if all bills required margins much greater than 50%; then, only universally accepted policies would gain acceptance.)
Hence my argument that we should not need a constitutional amendment to say that the federal government may not do something, unless the constitution currently says it may.
- anigbrowl 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCulloch_v._Maryland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCulloch_v._Maryland is 'the' case which explains the existence of the Federal government's implied powers as well as the enumerated ones. For good or ill, the Supreme Court's interpretation of the constitution is the law whenever there's a disagreement, and the decisions of the Marshall court in particular are very important (not least because Marshall was in office for so long so early in the USA's history). It's pointless to have arguments about the constitution without reference to past controversies - I've highlighted the relevant section here, but this whole page is effectively the 'rest' of the Constitution that lawyers are paid to think about: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_landmark_court_decisions_in_the_United_States#Landmark_decisions_in_U.S._federalism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_landmark_court_decision... There's a short and very readable book by Prof. Laurence Tribe called 'The Invisible Constitution' that examines the competing approaches to constitutional interpretation and implementation. Now in California, we do have a very comprehensive state constitution of the kind you're talking about - any significant expansion of state power or rules has to trace its way back to some specific constitutional provision. It's not my idea of an improvement: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/const-toc.html http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/const-toc.html
- rayiner 15y agoPeople act like there is no downside on hamstringing the federal governments ability to govern. Over-restriction of what the federal government could do is precisely what led to the creation of the Constitution.
- westicle 15y agoDepends what country you live in. In my country the Constitution was enacted for the very purpose of restricting what areas of law the federal government is allowed to weigh in on. Plenary power is retained by the states.
- anigbrowl 15y agoNo, it was amended for that purpose. The Bill of Rights was added to the Constitution afterwards, not at the time of enactment. Plenary power is retained by the states in some areas - the ones where it has not already been delegated to Congress. Art. 1 s.8 certainly does give Congress the plenary power over interstate commerce, copyright, and a number of other things...not least 'post roads,' which are arguably equivalent to 'communications infrastructure.' There are limits on Federalism, but it is far from the unconstitutional imposition you seem to think it is.
- westicle 15y agoI beg to differ. We don't have a Bill of Rights or a Congress. Regardless, I'm not sure how you got the impression that I think federalism is unconstitutional or an imposition... I generally feel that multiple conflicting state-based laws is an inefficient way to run a country, and note that the constitution gives the states the ability to cede legislative power to the commonwealth (as it should). Just stating the facts ma'am.