3 ms·
There is a difference between a contrarian and someone who is wrong on basic facts: "And no, electric cars aren’t the answer either; the power to run them has
by Alex3917 18y ago
There is a difference between a contrarian and someone who is wrong on basic facts:
"And no, electric cars aren’t the answer either; the power to run them has to come from somewhere. The best case is that people will charge them off the grid at night. This will require power plants to be burning just as much additional fuel as if the cars themselves were doing it, perhaps more given transmission losses." --ESR
"Pacific Northwest National Laboratory calculates that there is enough excess nighttime generating capacity nationwide to charge 84 percent of the 198 million cars, pickups, and SUVs on the road today. Ideally, the energy charging those cars would come from carbon-free sources, which would reduce almost to zero the greenhouse gas emissions per mile. But a joint study by Electric Power Research Institute and the Natural Resources Defense Council found that even if a plug-in vehicle got all its electricity from coal-fired plants (the U.S. electricity grid is about 50 percent coal), it would still emit only two-thirds of the greenhouse gases released by a conventional car. Over the next thirty years, the study concluded, widespread adoption of V2G could eliminate 450 million tons of carbon dioxide annually, the equivalent of retiring a third of the current fleet." From Earth: The Sequel (p. 226)
- mindslight 18y ago> there is enough excess nighttime generating capacity nationwide to charge 84 percent ... This only means no new power plants. The current ones would have to step up production at night. > it would still emit only two-thirds of the greenhouse gases released by a conventional car 2/3 isn't significantly different than 1 as far as I'm concerned. Especially when were talking about what goes into making the batteries. Without clean grid electricity, electric cars are merely a feel-good way of outsourcing the problem.
- swombat 18y agoAs Al Gore put it in his movie, all those things add up... 1/3 here, 25% there, 15% over there, another 1/3 of what's left from here, etc... 1/3 is quite a lot in that respect.
- mindslight 18y agoOnly if these percentages are in series. Since we're talking about the same power plants, it seems that 1/3 is all we get. Checking the study in question (first hit for 'study "Electric Power Research Institute" "Natural Resources Defense Council"'), it seems they did _not_ take into account the production and maintenance costs of each type of vehicle. I'm skeptical of technologies that promise incremental conservation through massive consumption of other resources (battery material).
- Alex3917 18y ago"Only if these percentages are in series. Since we're talking about the same power plants, it seems that 1/3 is all we get." To quote E:TS again: "Without any major breakthroughs, vehicles that are little different from today's could use one-third the energy per mile, says John DeCicco, Environmental Defense Fund's specialist in automotive strategies. That alone would radically reduce greenhouse gas emissions. If those cars ran on a biofuel made from renewable feedstocks with one-fourth the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions of today's gasoline (Amyris's biogasoline, for instance, or Verenium's cellulosic ethanol), then the emissions per mile would be one-twelfth what they are today, a reduction of 92 percent. It was the feasibility of such options that, in September 2007, caused Vermont U.S. District Judge William K. Sessions to reject manufacturers' challenges and rule that they could meet California's new standards, requiring carbon dioxide emissions in new cars to be cut about 22 percent in the first phase (2009 through 2012) and 30 percent in the mid-term phase (2013 to 2016). Given the expected doubling by midcentury of vehicle miles traveled in the United States, however, California and the rest of the country will have to go much further--reducing automobile emissions about 80 percent." (p. 229) The book lists a whole boatload of other ways to save massive amounts of energy with today's technology, many of which are listed in my notes of chapter 9: http://alexkrupp.com/earth.html http://alexkrupp.com/earth.html The sections on weather prediction, clean cement, carpeting, and fans are insanely cool.
- mindslight 18y agoYeah, exactly. I was picking on electric cars because they only address a subproblem; other technologies are certainly more promising. ... "Another innovation came in the carpet pattern itself. The company's top-selling pattern, called Entropy, mimics the disorder of a forest floor with its strewn leaves, pebbles, and twigs. That randomness means that the pattern needn't match up from tile to tile, but can be laid out in any direction, eliminating the huge amounts of scrap normally generated at installation. It means few tiles are rejected at the factor: imperfections get lost in the wandering variations of color. It also means the carpet lasts a long time, because worn or stained tiles can be swapped out without replacing the rest." (p. 215) Sounds like a good book.
- Alex3917 18y ago"This only means no new power plants. The current ones would have to step up production at night." I realize that. However, also realize that wind power is running at peak production during the night, which is when people would be charging their cars. Also realize the 2/3 number was for if 100% of the power was coming from coal, which it obviously wouldn't be.
- SwellJoe 18y agoalso realize that wind power is running at peak production during the night How much power in the US is generated by wind?
- Alex3917 18y agoAccording to Wikipedia, it will be 1.5% by the end of 2008: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_the_United_States However, it accounts for about a third of all new electricity production. You have to remember that a cap-and-trade bill is going to be what makes both V2G and renewable energy profitable, so if it becomes profitable to build V2G cars then it will also be profitable to increase wind capacity. I forgot that solar thermal is also an excellent candidate for creating electricity at night, since you can store excess hot water very efficiently during the day and then use a small amount of natural gas to make sure it's at the optimally efficient temperature to spin the turbines.
- DabAsteroid 18y ago[Windpower] accounts for about a third of all new electricity production. No. Here is the Wikipedia quote: "Wind power accounted for 35% of all new U.S. electric generating capacity in 2007." (Emphasis mine.) Capacity is not production. Capacity-factor helps us understand how much production we can expect from a given capacity. Here are the capacity-factors of two recently-installed wind turbines: http://www.hullwind.org http://www.hullwind.org Sept 25, 2008 Hull 1 Hull 2 660 KW 1.8 MW Total Generation - kWhs 10,262,150 8,127,391 Days Commissioned 2464 877 Hours generating 39,050 14,050 Capacity Factor 26.3% 21.5% Hull 1 is a turbine that was built to replace an older one that -- as frequently happens to wind turbines, but has never happened to a nuclear power reactor -- had been destroyed in a storm. (http://www.hullwind.org/history.php http://www.hullwind.org/history.php) Being destroyed in a storm further hurts lifetime capacity-factor.
- lliiffee 18y agoIt's 2/3, but it can come from coal. There are very significant political/economic advantages to that. A simultaneous 1/3 environmental advantage is icing on the cake.
- DaniFong 18y agoUtilities only burn coal when they have to. It's a soot laden nightmare.