4 ms·
I sat on a jury for a violent crime and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the jurors. I expected a much less savvy and less logical group of people an
by refurb 4y ago
I sat on a jury for a violent crime and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the jurors. I expected a much less savvy and less logical group of people and found the opposite - they understood the process, how the law is applied, the nuances between different charges and most importantly the presumption of innocence. The lawyers were playing all the games you'd expect, but every juror saw through it 100%.
- usrn 4y agoThe American public is underestimated way to often IMO.
- paulcole 4y ago> I expected a much less savvy and less logical group of people Why did you expect this?
- mschuster91 4y agoGiven a random selection of 12 people on the street, one might reasonably expect that their educational background may be... less than optimal. For Germany for example, a quarter of the population only has the utter basic level of education [1]. [1] https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/197269/umfrage/allgemeiner-bildungsstand-der-bevoelkerung-in-deutschland-nach-dem-alter/ https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/197269/umfrag...
- refurb 4y agoEducation =\= intelligence
- op00to 4y ago#1. The people st jury duty either want to be there or are too stupid to get out of it. #2. I interact with the public from time to time. As a rule people can not understand compound sentences let alone be able to string enough facts together in their head to be effective on a jury.
- refurb 4y agoMy experience with #1 was it actually really hard to get out of jury duty. The lawyers and judge have seen all the tricks. The people who were able to get rejected had to hold pretty extreme opinions and hold to them under a lot of questioning. I saw many people break and admit they could be impartial.
- refurb 4y agoBecause a lot of legal concepts aren’t that intuitive. And people are often emotional in their decisions particular when it comes to violent crime. And not to say those didn’t exist in my jury experience, but usually some juror stated their opinion and moved the thinking forward.
- dkarl 4y agoI would expect people like the people I went to high school with, since that was a pretty random selection of society. That would not be a group where you could describe an abstract concept like the criteria for applying a law and expect them to get it the first time. More likely you'd explain it many times from many different angles over a couple of weeks and then give them a test and they still wouldn't get any part of it entirely correct. And that's on average; you also have the low end of the range, people who managed to put the right words in the right boxes to pass world history but came away not sure if there's an ocean between France and Germany or not. And then at the very bottom there were the ones who couldn't pass high school classes at all....
- op00to 4y agoI sat on a jury for a personal injury case, and I was surprised at how absolutely stupid, and unable to absorb basic concepts about the case my fellow jurors were. They wanted to give a huge settlement to “stick it to the man” whether there was a reason to or not. I’m pretty anti-corporation but there was no evidence to support the claim!
- 1shooner 4y agoI had the opposite experience: There were itemized compensatory claims that hadn't even been specifically contested by the defense (e.g. preliminary medical assessment for injury), but they still gave nothing. They really seemed to just want to get out of there by lunch (they also made me foreman because I was the only one wearing a tie).
- sparselogic 4y agoSimilar experience here. If I'm ever on trial, I'd be happy for the people I sat with to be my jury.