3 ms·
I read not too long ago about things I didn't learn in school: - Most cities in Japan had already been extensively fire-bombed - The Japanese High Command wer
by actionfromafar 4y ago
I read not too long ago about things I didn't learn in school:
- Most cities in Japan had already been extensively fire-bombed
- The Japanese High Command were not shocked that atomic bombs could exist or that yet another city was obliterated
- The Japanese - Soviet war was also not going well for Japan. They would much rather surrender to the Americans than the Russians.
You are framing it as if a land invasion was inevitably the only other option. That's also impossible to surmise.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoThe Americans were basing their decisions on a land invasion, and they were intending, evidently, to continue lots of firebombing prior to doing a full scale invasion. That is known. Something that is evidently not known here is the meaning of surmise, which my dictionary tells me is "suppose that something is true without having evidence to confirm it." so, I think what people are trying to say is it's impossible to know for certain. And yes, it is impossible to know for certain if a land invasion would have happened, but it does seem like a pretty good chance of it given the planning for one.