5 ms·
Very true. The old-fashioned telephone handset was a masterpiece of human engineering. I bet with state-of-the-art mic and speakers, it would still be way bette
by AlbertCory 4y ago
Very true. The old-fashioned telephone handset was a masterpiece of human engineering. I bet with state-of-the-art mic and speakers, it would still be way better than a smartphone for actual phone calls.
Of course, I have to admit that my Bluetooth headset is pretty good, and a first-class gaming headset would be even better.
- bombcar 4y agoThe low latency with a completely analog phone call is amazing. We forget it but it was really really low.
- Animats 4y agoWith the 1950s mic and speakers, it was substantially better than a smartphone. The Western Electric model 1500 [1], from 1963, is generally considered the best analog phone [1]. This was rented, not sold, so it is extremely reliable and rugged. Best audio quality was with ISDN phones. Digital end to end, synchronized at the bit level, no noise, no dropouts. [1] http://www.telephonearchive.com/phones/we/we1500.html http://www.telephonearchive.com/phones/we/we1500.html
- Aloha 4y agoI'm not sure why you picked a 1500 as the best sounding, the 500, 1500 and 2500 all used the same network, receiver, and transmitter elements - I've used all three, they perform identically, the 1500 set is actually incredibly rare - touch tone was just not common until the 2500 was out. The best speakerphone ever made (even better than modern ones) is a 4A Speakerphone. Also in my opinion, an AE 80 with a non cohered up carbon mic will outperform a 500/1500/2500 on a short loop (sub 15kf), and can be tuned to outperform on a long. The self compensating network in the WE set is better however. That all said, a modern Northern Telecom or Aastra analog phone will consistently outperform a 500 set, because of the electret mic in them. Carbon mics have benefits as an amplifier, but transistors rendered them obsolete in most cases.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- E39M5S62 4y agoYou know your phones.
- franga2000 4y agoThe mic and speaker in the 90s Iskra payphones are far superior in sound quality to anything you'd find in a cheap phone these days. I hooked one up to Discord last month for an art instalation and could not believe my ears when it sounded way better than the 3 other people in the call using flagship smartphones.
- WalterBright 4y agoOne thing has not improved one iota in the 30 years I've had a cell phone - the voice quality.
- genewitch 4y agoI'm not sure this is true universally. I just spoke to a friend for the first time since I got a phone that does "HD" calling, and although I've been speaking to them for 25 years on the phone, I didn't recognize their voice. I feel like POTS and edge->3g calling made me miss out on a lot of detail and intonation. I'm just glad I get to experience this call quality with non-technically inclined friends before I go completely deaf. I use a lot of voip services and there's something to be said for the phone companies actually making a competitive product, here. I suppose one could argue that "HD calling" is technically just VoIP as well.
- jcrawfordor 4y agoVoIP systems negotiate codec choice on call initiation, generally using a "best common denominator" rule. Even when only companded PCM is available (PCM-a, PCM-µ), 64kbps will be used since it's the universal norm on the TDM (conventional) telephone newtwork. Unfortunately, as a capacity measure GSM specifies very low bitrates for voice connections, as low as 5kbps in the worst case and 10-20kbps typical. This requires the use of high-efficiency vocoders like CELP variants that are sufficient for intelligible speech but, well, only for that purpose. "HD voice" is exactly VoIP and with few exceptions is only transported over SIP or a SIP-like protocol using the existing RTP negotiation mechanism, which usually ends up selecting 64kbps companded PCM (same as a landline phone). Increasing use of VoLTE, which is essentially an optimized form of SIP designed to "combine" session control features with LTE for lower overhead, has made this pretty common as HD voice support is standard from VoLTE vendors. There was such a thing as HD Voice over 3G using a similar mechanism that leveraged HSPDA but it was never very common, at least in the US. VoLTE will quickly become the only way to make cellular phone calls in the US which we can expect to make HD Voice pretty universal. Right now it can be spotty when calling between networks, depending on how their peering is set up.
- stavros 4y agoI converted an old rotary phone into a mobile phone (https://www.stavros.io/posts/irotary-saga/ https://www.stavros.io/posts/irotary-saga/), and the quality is much better than a mobile. Even just the sidetone makes it SO much better to talk on. I have no idea why modern mobile phones have no (or very low volume?) sidetone. It makes the UX orders of magnitude better.
- frosted-flakes 4y agoYes, sidetone (hearing your own voice through the handset) makes all the difference! I'm not exactly sure why, but I find it so much easier to talk on the phone when there's a sidetone. In general, for me, talking on the phone is like talking into the void, and sidetone at least gives me the assurance that, yes, it's still working. Like the little inset video feed of yourself when you're on a Skype call.
- stavros 4y agoYeah, exactly. Plus, I've found I'm much louder when there's no sidetone, which is very tiring.
- alamortsubite 4y agoNice work! Maybe I missed this, but have you considered simulating a dial tone?
- stavros 4y agoI haven't, I think it would be a fair bit of work, given that the modem is what outputs the sound.
- alamortsubite 4y agoI haven't worked with the Arduino. Would it be difficult to incorporate an SPDT relay to switch the sound source between it and the modem?