7 ms·
I agree with you about the persistence problem; the government acts like a rotten two-year-old that keeps trying until it gets its way. Like a two-year-old, it
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
I agree with you about the persistence problem; the government acts like a rotten two-year-old that keeps trying until it gets its way. Like a two-year-old, it learns what it can get away with and tries harder each time. Unlike a two-year-old, it doesn't grow up and learn what not to do.
We shouldn't need a constitutional amendment here; the constitution is a whitelist of things the federal government may do, not a blacklist of things it may not do. While the constitution does sadly include the notion of copyright, it does not include anything allowing regulatory authority over the Internet.
- zacharycohn 15y agoTo be fair, the repetition is how the system SHOULD work. Do you think the first attempt at passing a women's suffrage bill passed?
- anigbrowl 15y agoI agree with you about the persistence problem; the government acts like a rotten two-year-old that keeps trying until it gets its way. That's because the House elections run on a two-year cycle, and this is the part of the cycle at which people are paying the least attention. While the constitution does sadly include the notion of copyright, it does not include anything allowing regulatory authority over the Internet. /facepalm It doesn't say anything about aeroplanes either, but you'd be mad if they started falling out of the sky onto your house so you put with the FAA. Dark hints about constitutional permissions are a signal of irrelevance, because if it was as obvious as all that the issue would get in front of the Supreme Court much faster. You have to take the history of constitutional jurisprudence into account, because courts do. This is the sort of problem best fought at the ballot box, which means holding your nose and opening your wallet.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoI wouldn't necessarily argue that the federal government should not have any new powers, but rather than they should not simply assume them in contravention of the constitution. If the federal government wishes to expand its purview, it should have to get a constitutional amendment passed. Yes, that requires quite a lot of work and requires more consensus than political decisions normally require; good, that's a feature. (Personally, I think we'd almost certainly be a lot better off if all bills required margins much greater than 50%; then, only universally accepted policies would gain acceptance.) Hence my argument that we should not need a constitutional amendment to say that the federal government may not do something, unless the constitution currently says it may.
- anigbrowl 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCulloch_v._Maryland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCulloch_v._Maryland is 'the' case which explains the existence of the Federal government's implied powers as well as the enumerated ones. For good or ill, the Supreme Court's interpretation of the constitution is the law whenever there's a disagreement, and the decisions of the Marshall court in particular are very important (not least because Marshall was in office for so long so early in the USA's history). It's pointless to have arguments about the constitution without reference to past controversies - I've highlighted the relevant section here, but this whole page is effectively the 'rest' of the Constitution that lawyers are paid to think about: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_landmark_court_decisions_in_the_United_States#Landmark_decisions_in_U.S._federalism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_landmark_court_decision... There's a short and very readable book by Prof. Laurence Tribe called 'The Invisible Constitution' that examines the competing approaches to constitutional interpretation and implementation. Now in California, we do have a very comprehensive state constitution of the kind you're talking about - any significant expansion of state power or rules has to trace its way back to some specific constitutional provision. It's not my idea of an improvement: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/const-toc.html http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/const-toc.html
- rayiner 15y agoPeople act like there is no downside on hamstringing the federal governments ability to govern. Over-restriction of what the federal government could do is precisely what led to the creation of the Constitution.
- westicle 15y agoDepends what country you live in. In my country the Constitution was enacted for the very purpose of restricting what areas of law the federal government is allowed to weigh in on. Plenary power is retained by the states.
- anigbrowl 15y agoNo, it was amended for that purpose. The Bill of Rights was added to the Constitution afterwards, not at the time of enactment. Plenary power is retained by the states in some areas - the ones where it has not already been delegated to Congress. Art. 1 s.8 certainly does give Congress the plenary power over interstate commerce, copyright, and a number of other things...not least 'post roads,' which are arguably equivalent to 'communications infrastructure.' There are limits on Federalism, but it is far from the unconstitutional imposition you seem to think it is.
- jbooth 15y agoHang on one second, who in the hell is "the government" in this situation? The politicians supporting this bill, mostly republicans, work the phrase "I'm anti-government" into every single public speech they give. Those are the only supporters on the public payroll, the rest are all corporate entities and lobbyists, as well as the Chamber of Commerce, natch. Those are your pro-government marxist ideologues in this story. I really think the phrase "the government" or even worse, capital-G "Government", should be banned from any discussion of policy, it turns everyone involved into an idiot. Government and industry both have lots of moving parts. Lastly, I agree that our existing constitution should prevent this sort of law. I'm not optimistic about the current "small-government" supreme court agreeing with me.
- jwhitlark 15y agoThe sponsors of this bill break down as 16 Democrats to 11 Republicans. How does that work out to "mostly republicans"? It appears that this has support from both parties, and I think casting it as a party issue will weaken opposition.
- jbooth 15y agoOk, it's bipartisan, but the only meaningful opposition has come from democrats, and the entire political spectrum of "anti government" has lined up behind it. I'm just saying breaking everything down to "government" is a ridiculous tagline that obfuscates more than it helps. I mean, even if this is approved, it's basically the government doing extremely cheap contract work for the companies who'd benefit. I have a problem with it being done, period, if the ISPs formed a cartel with the MPAA to do this without the government it'd be just as bad.
- CWuestefeld 15y agothe only meaningful opposition has come from democrats, and the entire political spectrum of "anti government" has lined up behind it Which Libertarian think-tank was it that was supporting the bill? Really, jbooth, your partisanship isn't helping anything.
- lukifer 15y ago> the government acts like a rotten two-year-old that keeps trying until it gets its way Point of clarification: the government itself has no inherent interest here, and is acting mostly on behalf of influential Big Content lobbyists. Like so many other first-world systemic problems, this is yet another government-industrial complex. > the constitution is a whitelist of things the federal government may do Yes, this is how it should work, but it hasn't worked this way for a long time; scope creep has taken on a life of its own. Without implying a simple, "magic bullet" solution, We The People should acknowledge just how broken our electoral system is, and that it is the central impediment towards regaining anything resembling a constitutionally constrained democratic republic.
- repsilat 15y ago> Yes, this is how it should work, but it hasn't worked this way for a long time; More concretely, this bill would be allowed up by the prevailing (contorted) interpretations of the copyright clause and the interstate commerce clause.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoThe copyright clause does not provide authority to regulate the operation of the Internet. And yes, the commerce clause gets contorted into an all-encompassing regulatory justification, but that doesn't make it right.