3 ms·
> Why do people assume that you have to think you'll be a billionaire to be against something that would affect billionaires negatively? Because there is a gro
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
> Why do people assume that you have to think you'll be a billionaire to be against something that would affect billionaires negatively?
Because there is a group who struggles to reconcile what looks like a contradiction - another group who appears to advocate for policies which harm themselves. The quote and its derivatives attempt to explain this apparent contradiction.
- mc32 4y agoNot P, but I agree. One does not have to like a billionaire or even dream about being one to disagree with disproportionate taxation out of other principles or concerns.
- Rapzid 4y agoIt goes the other way around too. There are billionaires in favor of increased taxes on billionaires.
- mc32 4y agoAnd the IRS allows you to contribute as much as you prefer to the treasury. It's voluntary and no one is compelling you. So that group of billionaires who think the government can use their money more efficiently than they can in order to advance American society are absolutely free to do so! Go them! They don't need the government to compel them. They can form their own Philgubernatorial group -set their own donation rules and taxation (donation) bands and percentages and come tax season give it to the feds.
- Rapzid 4y agoHow do you know that don't? Really though, they shouldn't. That's pissing in the ocean on an individual level, and the government doesn't run it's budget off rando Treasury donations. They are not just advocating more taxes on themselves but on the very wealthy in general. A systemic change in taxation. These same people likely also donate a huge amount of money to charities and etc. On an individual basis it's easier to draw a line between funds donated and outcomes. > They don't need the government to compel them. Do they? Do you? Why not just make the government a charity then.
- daenz 4y agoI've never understood this either. It's like they only want it to happen if its forced on everyone, which is the opposite of the social altruism that they are claiming to advocate for.
- Rapzid 4y agoI mean, that's the great thing about the rule of law right? That we agree to do stuff together that we might not individually? > It's like they only want it to happen if its forced on everyone Well if we take a law to mean "forced on everyone" that's really the definition of "it to happen".
- mysterydip 4y agoThe answer is that such policies are more nuanced than just help or harm. Some people weigh effects differently than other people, leading them to believe that for their specific situation, one outweighs the other.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoCompletely agree. There are also people who would give everything and anything to be ideologically consistent - worse off on every metric, but right with themselves and the way they see the world. It can be very difficult to relate to them due to that very experiential chasm.
- wordnerd2022 4y agoI think it’s pretty paternalistic to think that you’re a better judge of what is good or bad for someone than that person themselves. There are plenty of people who are anti union because they’ve rationally concluded they would be worse off.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI'm genuinely curious to read what your edit would have been so that it didn't appear that I was putting myself into one of these groups.
- wordnerd2022 4y agoSorry, I probably shouldn’t have used “you.” I meant generally… “people who make this argument”