3 ms·
"All my projects have been terminated after Google falsely flagged FairEmail as spyware without a reasonable opportunity to appeal." Would anyone classify Goog
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
"All my projects have been terminated after Google falsely flagged FairEmail as spyware without a reasonable opportunity to appeal."
Would anyone classify Google's projects as "spyware". It is, after all, their "business model" to conduct surveillance. Whereas I doubt this author is making Google-sized profits, or even a modest livelihood, from his PlayStore apps, even if the apps were "spyware". Google is the undisputed king of spyware unless the user believes that her interests are always 100% aligned with Google's interests and nothing Google does can ever harm them. In order to hold such beliefs one would also have to ignore the millions in fines Google continues to pay for privacy incursions.
I have been using one of this author's other programs, NetGuard, from FDroid, in lockdown mode, for computer running non-rooted Android. I have not seen anything like it, i.e., a user-controlled application firewall as a standalone app, for iOS. I am not aware of any competing apps for Android either. It appears to be a one-of-a-kind app, AFAICT. If someone knows of better option for selectively blocking traffic from apps, let's hear about it and the reasons why it is better.
The assumption that Google is more trustworthy than any single app author is questionionable. It is that dogma upon which the "app store" concept depends.
For example, can Google really compete with this author with respect to protection from spyware. Let's consider some facts.
The author offers user-controlled protection from spying in NetGuard. Google offers Google-controlled protection from spying in the form of app store vetting. The former is open source, users can compile it themselves, and it does not report back to a mothership. The later is not something any user compiles themselves, it not controlled by the user, it is controlled by Google, it does report back a mothership, and the motherwhip's "business model" depends on that surveillance. The later, namely Android, Google apps and Google "services", are, by definition, spyware. Google collects data about pocket computer owners and uses it in undisclosed ways.
There is simply no way for a pocket computer user to know the many things that Google does with the data it collects from spying. The only instances where she may learn about what Google does with her data are when facts are disclosed in response to discovery requests in litigation and those facts are made public. Even if she becomes aware of such facts, there is generally no way for her to limit what Google does with her data according to her own preferences. NetGuard allows users to selectively block or allow traffic to selected domains on a per app basis.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoNot to mention all the legal proceedings brought against Google for privacy related matters that Google has settled despite having the resources to go to trial and have the issues finally decided in Google's favour. Surely Google has has done nothing wrong, and the trial courts would agree, so why does Google choose to settle out of court every time.