3 ms·
> That method of operation leaves it open to future disputes. That method of operation is precisely how the legislature and the judiciary in this country works
by vkou 4y ago
> That method of operation leaves it open to future disputes.
That method of operation is precisely how the legislature and the judiciary in this country works. Based on a decision made ~250 years ago.
When a law is open-ended, the judiciary clarifies it. If the legislature doesn't like this clarification, it passes a new law. If the legislature includes a contradiction to the clarification in the new law, the courts take this into account as a strong indicator of how the law should be interpreted in the future.
> It's better to have a well defined law that doesn't rely on interpretation as those interpretations change over time.
If you believe this strongly enough, you should consider moving to a Civil Law nation, where the process I described does not happen. This is a Common Law nation, that is built on this process.
> That is the goal - that the law is defined in a way to produce consistent results and is applied equally.
This goal, like a spherical cow, is impossible to meet. In practice, ambiguities and uncertainties always exist, and every country's political system has a process for resolving it. This country's process is a push-and-pull between the judiciary and the legislature.