4 ms·
The mistake they made is that they used a much broader category in the clarifier for the definition of fish than they may have intended to. "Invertebrate" is a
by shadowgovt 4y ago
The mistake they made is that they used a much broader category in the clarifier for the definition of fish than they may have intended to. "Invertebrate" is a massive section of the animal kingdom. Poor choice of words if they only meant the wet ones.
- gpm 4y agoI'm not convinced it was an accident. They took an existing statute, decided they wanted to extend it, and did it in the lazy way of adding "invertebrates" to "fish" instead of replacing the word "fish" all over the place.
- happyopossum 4y agoDo you know in fact that the legislature changed the definition after the fact? It seems to me more like crappy law-making than expedient changes.
- gpm 4y agoYes, the ruling mentions it (with dates).
- rob74 4y agoThe "bug" is (or rather, isn't) in this phrase: "[n]o person shall import into this state, or take, possess, or sell within this state, any bird, mammal, fish, amphibia or reptile, or any part or product thereof, that the commission determines to be an endangered animal or rare animal, except as otherwise provided in this chapter." I guess there must be a very good reason why they didn't want to add "invertebrate" (or, to be safe, "other animal") to this list and instead chose to repeatedly expand the definition of "fish". Ok, "fish" included crustaceans, and those are related to insects, so if you squint hard enough...
- tptacek 4y agoYou don't have to wonder about this. The court tracked down the context behind the definition, and it was written specifically to include terrestrial invertebrates (including the Lange metalmark butterfly and the Trinity bristle snail). The only reason this seems complicated is because the headline of this post has asked us to find it complicated. The real story is quite boring.
- tptacek 4y agoSeems like a problem for the legislature to clear up, not the courts! The law itself is quite clear as it stands.
- shadowgovt 4y agoAmong the reasons we have courts is to clear up ambiguous law; this question of the definition of the word falls squarely on the shoulders of the judiciary, and there is no procedure for referring a question like this to the legislature (and at the rate legislators operate, imagine if we had such a procedure... People's court cases would be jammed in limbo for even longer waiting for the legislature to stop pocket vetoing their question). Adding a system for that would not be impossible but would have to be done carefully. Instead, we have the system as it currently operates... The law says what it says, the courts declare interpretations if people disagree, and the legislature may, but is not obligated to, act to pass law with further clarification if they have concern with the court's interpretation.
- tptacek 4y agoThis law is not remotely ambiguous. You don't have to read tea leaves to figure out what a fish is. A bumble bee is a fish; it says so right in the text of the law, unmistakeably.
- MAGZine 4y agoThe legislation is clear. If the legislation is incorrect, it should be amended. The court did its job.
- tptacek 4y agoWe agree.
- babypuncher 4y agoOnly if the intent of the law is ambiguous enough that the courts find themselves unable to parse it. This language is certainly a bit odd, but it was plenty easy for the courts to suss out what was meant here. If the legislature disagrees with the court's conclusion, then they are free to amend the legislation in question.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The mistake they made is that they used a much broader category in the clarifier for the definition of fish than they may have intended to. "Invertebrate" is a massive section of the animal kingdom. Poor choice of words if they only meant the wet ones. The court examined historical evidence specifically to evaluate the argument that the law was intended to apply only to “wet ones” and rejected that argument.