3 ms·
"But if a loophole is needed to protect the bees then it's probably a good idea." Or the legislature could do their jobs and craft appropriate legislation.
by giantg2 4y ago
"But if a loophole is needed to protect the bees then it's probably a good idea."
Or the legislature could do their jobs and craft appropriate legislation.
- fdr 4y agothey did, but in a way rather odd, where they have a remark in the law that "fish" are a shorthand for, among other things, invertebrates. I wonder if such a drafting choice would be made today, in the presence of the modern word processor.
- giantg2 4y agoI believe that was in the context of aquarically associated invertebrates, right?
- tptacek 4y agoThey specifically did not do that. The court tracked down the origin of this change in the definition of the law, and the legislature at the time was acting in part to preserve an endangered terrestrial snail. If they'd meant "aquatic invertebrates", that's what they'd have said.
- giantg2 4y agoThey already stated that the snail was a mollusk. It still seems you're ignoring the context of the fact that they added invertebrates under the fish heading, while they added other classes (plants) under their own headings. That context seems to indicate aquatic relation. Perhaps it was just them being lazy, but it would have been more proper to have it as it's own classification as was done for plants. This whole thing would have been unnecessary if they were good at being lazy and said they had the power to regulate species without making all these classifications.
- tptacek 4y agoThis snail is a terrestrial mollusk, so that doesn't help you. But even if it did: the legislature was also trying to protect 3 different butterflies along with the snail. I don't think there's a way to weasel out of this.
- vkou 4y agoIf they don't like this ruling, the legislators are free to draft legislature to clarify and correct it. As you describe, they can do their jobs. If they don't, we have to assume that they are fine with this interpretation. It's a common misconception among American technologists that law is some kind of code that you can deterministically, and unambiguously execute on a VM, and come up with the same result every single time. If that's the sort of thing you're looking for, you could try moving to a Civil Law country. You have a lot of options in this case - most of the world runs on Civil Law. In the boundless wisdom of the founding father, America forked its legal system from the United Kingdom, and is therefore a Common Law nation, where courts can routinely interpret legislature as they see fit, and set binding precedent when they do so.
- giantg2 4y ago"If they don't, we have to assume that they are fine with this interpretation." That method of operation leaves it open to future disputes. It's better to have a well defined law that doesn't rely on interpretation as those interpretations change over time. Not to mention, this interpretation should never have occurred to begin with. It's a concept in law that you cannot ignore or contradict the wording of a law to pursue its spirit. This clearly defines "fish" in such a way that it is inconsistent with the text. That one also must use the definitions defined in the law, defined in similar laws, or defined in the dictionary. Which this meets none of those. "It's a common misconception among American technologists that law is some kind of code that you can deterministically, and unambiguously execute on a VM, and come up with the same result every single time." That is the goal - that the law is defined in a way to produce consistent results and is applied equally. That's why we have rules of procedure, follow precedent, etc.
- vkou 4y ago> That method of operation leaves it open to future disputes. That method of operation is precisely how the legislature and the judiciary in this country works. Based on a decision made ~250 years ago. When a law is open-ended, the judiciary clarifies it. If the legislature doesn't like this clarification, it passes a new law. If the legislature includes a contradiction to the clarification in the new law, the courts take this into account as a strong indicator of how the law should be interpreted in the future. > It's better to have a well defined law that doesn't rely on interpretation as those interpretations change over time. If you believe this strongly enough, you should consider moving to a Civil Law nation, where the process I described does not happen. This is a Common Law nation, that is built on this process. > That is the goal - that the law is defined in a way to produce consistent results and is applied equally. This goal, like a spherical cow, is impossible to meet. In practice, ambiguities and uncertainties always exist, and every country's political system has a process for resolving it. This country's process is a push-and-pull between the judiciary and the legislature.