8 ms·
> “We also made the decision to not move forward with the proposed talk which — rather than bringing our community together and raising awareness — was creating
by lolinder 4y ago
> “We also made the decision to not move forward with the proposed talk which — rather than bringing our community together and raising awareness — was creating division and rancor,” Newberry wrote.
This doesn't surprise me one bit. Even on HN, every thread on this topic turns into a flame war with a bunch of people crying racism/religionism. How dare we discuss something we don't fully understand? How dare we criticize another culture when we have our own problems? It's the same arguments every time, and then the article ends up flagged to death.
The role of caste within the US is a super important conversation to have, and every resident of the US is entitled to participate, but there are a lot of people with a vested interest in shutting it down and the tools to do so.
- BaseballPhysics 4y ago
- throwaway049 4y agoA weak argument is a weak argument. Or are you saying brahmins and confederates have a lot in common and ought to spend more time together?
- djbusby 4y ago
- acheron 4y agoGood thing they've all been dead for close to a hundred years then.
- monetus 4y agoHaving stayed in Columbia TN for a decent while, I can tell you that the legacy is alive and well. Really, visit if you ever drive by - the confederate headquaters is in an anti-bellum house where they give tours, and they never say anything bad about the social dynamics of the past. It really leaves an elephant in the room, when they are selling battle flags in the gift shop embroidered with things like history not hate.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> the legacy is alive and well I think OP's point is those revering confederates today aren't confederates, they're something else. Sort of like how we term neo-Nazis separately from the historic Nazis.
- monetus 4y agoYou're right, or at least I think so yeah- and that point is definitely precise. From the years I spent in the area and outside of Nashville though, I'm not so sure that the sons and daughters of the confederacy as it is referred to all think of themselves as a part of the union. I'm pretty sure of the opposite for a few people in my mind rn. Don't take absolutes away from what I'm saying, this is just my experience. Aside: The largest minority in Columbia besides black Americans were Indian Americans and immigrants. I didn't have any insight into how they saw the caste system, but living in that city probably gives them a unique viewpoint that might be worth asking about should you have the chance. I wish I had.
- ethbr0 4y agoWhat do you have against confederacies?
- djbusby 4y agoI assumed they meant the Confederate States of America. Which was founded on principles that some humans are less than others. Burn that shit down (again).
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoI'm saying folks who make excuses for historical and present day discrimination clearly have a lot of things in common.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MomoXenosaga 4y ago
- brendoelfrendo 4y agoThat quote from the article gave me pause. It sounds like an admission that they wanted the good PR from having a caste bias speaker, but when having a conversation on a difficult topic actually became difficult, they backed down. Maybe, Google, instead of just giving up you should be asking why a speaker on Dalit rights and inclusion is causing "division and rancor" in your community? Or is that also a difficult conversation you'd rather not have?
- naravara 4y ago> Maybe, Google, instead of just giving up you should be asking why a speaker on Dalit rights and inclusion is causing "division and rancor" in your community? Or is that also a difficult conversation you'd rather not have? The same reason speakers on Palestinian rights often can. While they may be on the right side of the issue, it's also very easy for closed discussion spaces to rapidly devolve into pretty viciously anti-semitic tropes. These discussions need to be done with some strict moderation and sensitivity, usually with actual historians who can properly contextualize the issue. If all you're doing is bringing in "activists" from a specific point of view to talk about it while delegitimizing all other perspectives as inherently beneath consideration it's not gonna go well.
- car_analogy 4y agoDo you demand this strict moderation and sensitivity also when it's white people that are being accused of discrimination?
- throwaway894345 4y agoNot the OP, but I think the same principle applies. Whenever you accuse an entire race of something (as opposed to isolating your criticism to individuals or even systems), you’re engaging in racism, and this is unfortunately common in DEI trainings and among “race activists”. I don’t think strict moderation is necessary in the general case (especially since a lot of the most credentialed people who would moderate are themselves the sort of race activists who agitate)—rather, I think we’ll work through it in time. It is a shame though that we were on this path toward a post-race world and then some of us abruptly reversed course and dragged the whole nation with them, setting us back decades.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zionic 4y ago>The role of caste within the US is a super important conversation to have, and every resident of the US is entitled to participate, but there are a lot of people with a vested interest in shutting it down and the tools to do so. I don't believe HN's current moderation policies/leadership make this the place to have that conversation though. Participate in good faith all you want, you'll still earn a ban/warning for "arguing" if you piss off the right people.
- the_only_law 4y agoLast time I saw a big thread related to the topic there were super deeper threads of people just straight up calling each other slurs. They probably would have been flagged, but the threads were just so deep you wouldn’t see that unless you’re intently following the thread.
- zionic 4y ago>Last time I saw a big thread related to the topic there were super deeper threads of people just straight up calling each other slurs. I hope you didn't take my comment is advocating for that. I can't really comment on a thread I didn't see. >They probably would have been flagged, but the threads were just so deep you wouldn’t see that unless you’re intently following the thread. Sounds like pointless name calling. That said, my original point that HN is not a good place to have these discussions stands. Unfortunately this community is for sterilized technical discussion, anything with spice or flavor isn't permitted.
- the_only_law 4y ago> That said, my original point that HN is not a good place to have these discussions stands. Sorry, I must have missed the not, I thought you were saying this is a good place.
- otterley 4y agoI disagree. It is permitted, but it’s important to tread carefully and have a nuanced discussion that is respectful of other points of view.
- 29athrowaway 4y ago> How dare we criticize another culture when we have our own problems? Because there are now 4.6 million Indian Americans and they are one of the fastest growing ethnic groups in the US. So it's our own problem now too.
- H8crilA 4y agoIt was a rhetorical question.
- leoc 4y agoIt seems the grandparent agrees with you on that, and not with the opinion which it summarised in that sentence.
- lr4444lr 4y agoI think he's being rhetorically sarcastic there.
- PheonixPharts 4y agoI was going to comment the same thing but then realized the parent comment is listing the tactics people use to shut down the conversation, not their own personal opinions. The point being made is that people who don't want this conversation in public (i.e. people in favor of and/or who benefit from the caste system) will flood the comments with this type of rhetoric which instantly turns the conversation into to a flame war rather than a helpful discourse on how to improve things. The fact that you and I both instinctively fell for this reaction is evidence that parent is quite correct in the effectiveness of this tactic.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> will flood the comments with this type of rhetoric which instantly turns the conversation into to a flame war rather than a helpful discourse on how to improve things Which is how they got Google to cancel the talk.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> every thread on this topic turns into a flame war with a bunch of people crying racism/religionism Is there a term for shutting down a discussion by turning the belligerence to eleven? Such that people outside the discussion tune out not the views of those being belligerent, but the discussion itself?
- HideousKojima 4y ago"Heckler's Veto" is kind of close, though I'm not sure it perfectly fits the phenomenon you're talking about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler%27s_veto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler%27s_veto
- UmYeahNo 4y ago>Is there a term for shutting down a discussion by turning the belligerence to eleven? "Trolled into oblivion", perhaps?
- fundad 4y agoDominance
- wolverine876 4y agoTrolling, or a specific case of it? I think of trolling as disruption, and it is commonly used to shut down discussions and attack good faith community (i.e., where people disagree, listen, tolerate, and support each other's right to hold and express differing opinions). This is one application of it.
- BitwiseFool 4y ago>"Is there a term for shutting down a discussion by turning the belligerence to eleven?" We really need one, because it's a known phenomenon without a known label. If we can't assign a word or phrase to it, we'll struggle to communicate the concept to others when we see it happening. That, in turn, makes calling this behavior out monumentally more difficult and far less likely to succeed in pressuring people to stop. Imagine if we didn't have the term "ad hominem" and how much more difficult it would be to confront someone making such underhanded attacks in arguments. It would be a lot more difficult to discredit the person, despite recognizing what they are doing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- truthwhisperer 4y ago
- wolverine876 4y ago> every thread on this topic turns into a flame war with a bunch of people crying racism/religionism Isn't that the first step in the flame war, attacking, dismissing, and blaming one side (and before they even say something)? How will someone with a good faith interest in discussing concerns about racism or religionism act, seeing this comment - they will feel shut down, and like they won't be heard and will be attacked. There's already no room for those discussions. There is a lack of trust - a situation that is the goal of people trying to disrupt open societies and the trolls that help them. Whatever we say or do, the primary goal needs to be to build trust. People who are alarmed act badly - that's why trolls try to alarm people (even if they aren't quite conscious of how it works). Even when people are acting badly, if you can build their trust then very often the situation will improve. It would be extremely valuable to society to find a way to conduct constructive conversations; I think we are improving, but not nearly quickly enough.
- ReactiveJelly 4y ago> It would be extremely valuable to society to find a way to conduct constructive conversations It's tough. I mean this sincerely - It requires heavy moderation. The government can uphold a free speech ideal, but the good conversations happen in bubbles where someone can't create a burner account and start talking shit as loud as anyone else. Some years ago, Christopher Hitchens gave a talk about free speech. It's very compelling. Nobody yelled "FIRST!" over him, cause it wasn't an Internet comment thread. Maybe we should distinguish between free speech and "free-for-all" speech. I'll listen to Hitchens saying we have the Right To Read about Holocaust deniers, but I don't want any given thread to be over-run by the same Holocaust deniers.