4 ms·
Study suggests that most of our evolutionary trees could be wrong
- ggm 4y ago"For over a hundred years, we've been classifying organisms according to how they look and are put together anatomically, but molecular data often tells us a rather different story." This is a really odd comment. Dinosoars, there is a strong dependence on holotypes physical features but for any organism we have organic remains, we've been doing dna for a long time, over 40 years. With increasing accuracy. Revision of family trees informed by cladistics dates to the 1990s. So 30 years. What am I missing? Is it just that this research reaches back further and is more widescale? The relationship of currawongs, Australian magpies and butcherbirds to corvids (for instance) is DNA based, and informs the branching, the convergence of socialised behaviour, intelligence is interesting, nobody would call a butcher bird anatomically similar to a currawong or Australian magpie, but genetically that is the closer relatiinship than the morphologically similar corvid family. Currawongs and magpies look far more crow like than butcherbird like. Butcher birds look far more like kookaburras and kingfishers in some ways. But their close relative is the magpie and we know this by DNA.
- bediger4000 4y agoBiologists/phylogenists have always known this - even when working with morphological features, there's missing data, judgement calls, etc etc. Lots of room for mistakes. When modern phylogenies get calculated, it's almost always done on a statistical basis. And there's always a note about uncertainty in the text of the papers.