3 ms·
Honestly I think email needs to be rethought from the ground up, just a whole new protocol with a killer app to get it going. Some of the most salient uses/qua
by dwallin 4y ago
Honestly I think email needs to be rethought from the ground up, just a whole new protocol with a killer app to get it going.
Some of the most salient uses/qualities of email:
- Asynchronous communication
- Decentralized / Federated
- Identity
Issues:
- Spam
- Lack of room for the format to expand
- Identification verification is hard
My ideal replacement for email would look something like a decentralized/federated identity protocol with default whitelist for contact upon which you build out data formats for sharing.
One key spam reduction technique in a federated system is to realize that most legitimate interactions are with people and services you are already in contact with so it’s better to make initial connections harder to improve the quality of daily use.
Another tool that works decently in a decentralized system is introductions/vouching. Eg. you can ask mutual contacts to connect you or at larger scale you can entrust third party services to “vouch” for a user, similar to how certs work. If a vouching service does a poor job of vetting who it lets through than users will stop trusting it.
- Avamander 4y ago> Honestly I think email needs to be rethought from the ground up, just a whole new protocol with a killer app to get it going. That's why it hasn't and won't happen any time soon. > My ideal replacement for email would look something like a decentralized/federated identity protocol with default whitelist for contact upon which you build out data formats for sharing. Nobody stops you from implementing sender whitelists with email. > Another tool that works decently in a decentralized system is introductions/vouching. This idea boils down to PKI but that's far from perfect due to humans, not tech. We could already absolutely significantly increase mail trustworthiness if we'd use S/MIME en-masse. If postmasters aren't improving mail integrity, end-users could. A few EU countries have deployed certificates to people, but it hasn't reached critical mass to act as an indicator yet.