10 ms·
Ceiling Air Purifier
- dylan604 4y agoWhat happens when someone flips the switch and reverse the rotation of the fan?
- SamBam 4y agoOoh, it sucks the air through backward, dislodging the particles, and showering the person below with dust.
- leobg 4y agoIsn’t the dust just going to rain down on you as soon as you turn the fan off?
- jefftk 4y agoMostly no: it's tiny particles that get embedded in the filter. One way to see this empirically is that pm2.5 levels don't go up again after turning off the fan
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoVery cool. Now what can we do about the eyesore factor? Does this affect the fans cooling performance? The air blows more straight down than diffuse I am assuming due to the shroud?
- sandbx 4y agoit could be pretty if you light it well
- phabricator 4y agoI'm not sure mood lighting is going to do much for the duct tape on the ceiling (or what your ceiling will look like when you take it off)
- lkbm 4y agoIf you push air down, it's going to displace the air below it off to the sides, so I don't think it'll make a big difference. My main concern would be that the filters limit flow, and thus it might be more likely to pull air up, causing a tight vertical loop (air goes down, turns outwards, and then back up while still inside the filter ring). I don't really have a solid mental model of how air flow works, though. Some experimenting with the shape (and some colored smoke, perhaps) could be interesting. What if the filters tilted inwards to be slightly narrower than the fan's reach? Or if they were shorter than the ceiling-to-fan distance and just inside? Or does it help to put them further out? (Seems unlikely, but would be a good thing to test.)
- s5300 4y agoA bit of wood stained black or vintage brown-ish + octagonal metal grid sheeting would look pretty nice. Search term may be “metal lattice sheet” Wood for the frame, metal grid sheet to cover the filters & still allow good airflow
- bombcar 4y agoIf you have a whole-home furnace you can often make it run the fan even if cool/heat is off - and install a high power filter and change it regularly and it’ll filter the air reasonably well. The ecobee has a “minimum fan time per hour” setting - it can also help to balance the air temperature.
- discreditable 4y agoI've had HVAC techs tell me not to use those thick filters unless your system is designed for it. They make the fan work harder to pull less air. This reduces how much air it can move.
- SigmundA 4y agoA good system like an AprilAire [1] will have a 4" thick filter vs the standard 1" thick filters. This allows much more filter area than a standard filter allowing proper airflow even with a finer more restrictive filter medium. You can't just swap filters, the 4" thick one usually go in right before HVAC air handler intake rather than at returns. I have had an AprilAire installed for over 10 years in my HVAC when it was replaced last time, recommended by HVAC installer, its has worked very well and I do have my blower fan cycle constantly regardless of need for heat/cool to turn over and filter air. 1. https://www.aprilaire.com/whole-house-products/air-purifiers/air-filter-buying-guide https://www.aprilaire.com/whole-house-products/air-purifiers...
- bombcar 4y agoYou can have them do a test and adjust the system depending on the filter that's installed to make sure it's moving enough air (though that is mainly important when heating to prevent the heating element from overheating).
- dr_orpheus 4y agoIt is also important in the cooling cycle for two reasons. 1. If there is not enough air moving over the air-conditioner coils there is the possibility that they will ice over. This has a cascading effect where there is less transfer through the coils and more ice builds up until the whole thing is a block of ice. This most often happens though when people buy condensers that are too big for their system (the thinking being the bigger the better the more cooling, but it is a balance within some tolerance) but can also be done on the other side by reducing airflow too much. 2. Less airflow can also mean too much condensation in the air which can end up sitting in the ductwork and causing it to rust out. This happened to my parents when they installed extra filters in their HVAC system. I guess this is similar cause as #1, just different potential effects.
- sha256sum 4y agoGreat idea. What's worked for me is simply taking a 20"x20"x1" filter and sliding it into the back cover of a standard $25 Lasko box fan. Cheap, easy option for air filtration in the home.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoThat’s a great idea. What kind of filter do you use?
- newsclues 4y agoStandard furnace filters, pick the level of filtration you desire/can afford.
- bombcar 4y agoI've had surprisingly good luck in my area finding brand-new furnace filters at Goodwill for quite cheap. HEPA, too. If you're making your own setup the size doesn't matter as much so that can be a good way to go.
- azth 4y agoI use a furnace filter (3M brand 2200 (merv 13) or even 2800 (merv 14)), and I tape smaller merv 13 filters on the outbound vents in the bedrooms. Those latter ones clearly need changing every couple of months as they become quite dark. So clearly the furnace filter is not sufficient, at least in my case.
- tiahura 4y agohttps://www.uofmhealth.org/media/19281 https://www.uofmhealth.org/media/19281
- totetsu 4y agoSome really good discussion of this has happened on HN last time California was on fire.
- 4y ago
- jaggederest 4y agoVery cool, if I was going to build something like this de novo I would start with a squirrel cage fan. When you oversize them and run them at low RPM they can produce a startling amount of airflow with virtually no sound at all. You could also bump it up to a MERV 16 with enough intake filter area.
- UI_at_80x24 4y agoI too am a fan of the squirrel cage fan, and have collected a lot over the years. One excellent location to source them for 'reuse' are photocopiers. Old analog copiers can have as many as 4 fans while newer digital ones seem to have 2-3 depending on size/capacity. Mostly DC too, but I have also come across some big A/C fans. They almost always are designed for higher voltages (i.e. 20+VDC) so when combined with a common 12VDC power source it's already been stepped down. (source: used to work for a photocopier company, and when people bought newer units, we would pickup the old units and usually junk them.)
- Kadin 4y agoOld furnaces nearly always have big-ish squirrel cage blowers in them, and many are replaced before the fan motors fail for various reasons. In my area they are a reasonably frequent sight by the side of the road on bulk garbage day. If you get there before the scrap metal guys do, you could easily nab a blower. They're typically 120V single-speed devices, although some newer ones may have variable-speed fans. Not 100% sure how most of them vary the speed; my bet is that they just have some capacitors switched inline with the fan motor to add reactance to the circuit and slow it down. (That would probably be how I would slow down a single-speed one to make it quieter, at any rate.) There are a lot of projects online that you can find, showing how to build fairly big workshop air cleaners with a furnace blower and some cheap plywood/MDF/whatever. Basically you just build a 5-sided box around the blower with a hole for the outgoing air, and then mount a furnace filter on the open face of the box.
- tallanvor 4y agoThere doesn't seem to be good control tests to say what difference the filters really make - seems one was added in in the comments, but it's missing important details (is the control with everything off? What happens if the fan is running on medium or high, etc.? And, of course, it's not really practical in that most people really don't want to be sticking stuff on their ceiling, but it could be an interesting experiment with more details provided.
- sdflhasjd 4y agoIt's not clear how this performs over having no fans and filters at all.
- flybrand 4y agoAgreed - and another wish list item would be a basic room air purifier “RAP” off the shelf, sitting in the corner. OP will also want to track performance over time. How long does it take the filters to load.
- jefftk 4y agoThe first chart in the post compares performance against a RAP (Coway AP-1512HH Mighty, the Wirecutter's top pick): https://www.jefftk.com/mighty-vs-ceiling-decay-big.png https://www.jefftk.com/mighty-vs-ceiling-decay-big.png
- jefftk 4y ago> How long does it take the filters to load This is basically the same question as "how long does a filter cube last". See https://www.texairfilters.com/testing-the-efficiency-of-merv-13-corsi-rosenthal-boxes-in-use/ https://www.texairfilters.com/testing-the-efficiency-of-merv... where they found performance was still good at 6m, though decreasing at 10m.
- SamBam 4y agoI was thinking the same thing. He has graphs for how quickly the pm2.5 levels reduce compared with a commercial machine, but not compared with running the fan alone, without filters. I believe that it is quite possible the majority of the air is not going through the filters. It seems that much of the air might spill out down the insides of the filters, rather than being forced through. In that case, the graph could be equally explained by the fan causing outside air to be sucked in.
- jstream67 4y agoNeat idea however air filter changes would be extremely expensive as its about 5x the air filters of a conventional purifier - which already seem to cost around 50-100 dollars to replace.
- eli 4y agoBut they’d last 5x as long to move the same amount of overall air, right?
- jefftk 4y agoThe filters are MERV-14, not HEPA, so they're much cheaper ("materials for one fan are nine MERV-14 filters for $110"). See https://www.jefftk.com/p/merv-filters-for-covid https://www.jefftk.com/p/merv-filters-for-covid for why MERV-14.
- Havoc 4y agoI like the lateral thinking. I'm currently using a pretty ghetto version as well - air filter is pointed at a open desktop case. I suspect the ideal version is an adaptation of the US central HVAC model. i.e. Push clean air into the various rooms. ...but hard to retrofit.
- polskibus 4y agoHow do you measure PM 2.5 at home? Whats the best and cost efficient way to do it?
- nerdbaggy 4y agoIt’s not the cheapest but this is what I use https://www.airthings.com/view-plus https://www.airthings.com/view-plus
- ryankrage77 4y agoI use a Nova SDS011 sensor connected a raspberry pi, then feed the data into HomeAssistant with a python script and MQTT.
- joelnc52 4y agoWe run one of these (https://www.adafruit.com/product/4632 https://www.adafruit.com/product/4632) off of an Arduino Uno with a small LCD hat (w/ micro SD for logging as well). I think that's the same sensor as in the outdoor units that Purple Air sells. ~$150 for the whole setup, but could definitely run that off a smaller / cheaper board, display only. Going strong for 2+ years at this point.
- mellavora 4y agohttps://www.airgradient.com/diy/ https://www.airgradient.com/diy/ Founder is very supportive, good product, easy to build The sensor will display PM2.5, CO2, Temperature and Humidity on the display and can optionally send the data to any server for data logging (e.g. the AirGradient platform or any other cloud backend). Parts: Wemos D1 Mini USD 2.24 Wemos OLED display USD 2.47 Plantower PMS5003 PM Sensor USD 13.89 Senseair S8 CO2 Sensor USD 28.00 SHT30 or SHT31 Temperature and Humidity Sensor Module USD 2.55
- jefftk 4y agoDetails: https://www.jefftk.com/p/testing-air-purifiers https://www.jefftk.com/p/testing-air-purifiers I'm using a Temtop M2000 because it was the cheapest option I found with per-minute data export: https://temtopus.com/collections/temtop-co2-monitor/products/temtop-m2000-2nd-generation-air-quality-monitor-for-pm2-5-pm10-particles-co2-hcho-temperature-humidity-settable-audio-alarm-data-export-recording-curve-easy-calibration https://temtopus.com/collections/temtop-co2-monitor/products...
- pfisch 4y agoThe cost of filter replacement would be absolutely insane. Also filter replacement would be unpleasant.
- 0daystock 4y agoThat looks extremely cheap and ugly, I would be embarrassed to have company over. I'll stick to my True HEPA Coways, which you can get for roughly the same price as this DIY contraption.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lkbm 4y agoHigh ceilings will help. Next step would be to add paint the joints and latticework (or run some colorful tape), and maybe add some LEDs. Black light tape along the latticework, black light at the top of the room. Other lighting is all dim lighting in the lower half (warm lamps). I dunno. It'll be hard to make this not look weird unless you do something crazy, like a drop ceiling so the fan and filters are inset. If the aesthetics are important, I'd put it on the home office (out of view from Zoom) rather than the living room.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI going for aesthetics I might just put them in the ceiling and have what appears to be low profile vents that one might not even notice. That would keep most of the noise in the ceiling. One could build an enclosure that the HEPA filter unit sits in and routes the intake/output to different ceiling vents. With a little extra effort the filter could be swapped out by removing/lowering the vent intake.
- russnewcomer 4y agoI wonder if there is going to be an issue with the structural integrity of the filters, since they are designed to rest on an object rather than hang? Wouldn't think it would be a big issue, but possibly? If you were wanting to do this long term, feels like a series of light wood frames to support would not be too expensive/difficult to construct or possibly 3d print, and have advantage of reduced adhesive smell.
- usefulcat 4y agoAs long as the filters are adequately supported at the edges it shouldn't be a problem. I know because my house has two 12x24 HVAC filters which are only supported at the edges and are almost certainly subject to much higher rates of airflow.
- Kadin 4y agoMost filters (especially the 1" and thicker ones) are surprisingly sturdy across most dimensions except for torsion. Thinking about 3D printing, you could probably print a nice corner bit, that would hold the corner of 3 filters together and square to each other. That would make the whole assembly easier to put together and seal up with tape.
- havblue 4y agoAn ac filter is pretty gray after just a few months. Granted this will take longer to get dirty but I suspect it will look ugly before you know it.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoA good reminder to change it at least. If this were a purchasable product, I envision making the filters replaceable and the frame compatible with some standard furnace filter size, so that you can just run to the store and grab new filters when you can visually see the filter needing replacement. Contrast this with the furnace filter, which needs some other mechanism (often, a schedule) to determine when to change the filter since it's not readily visible on a daily basis.
- sampo 4y agoI read on the internet, that HEPA filters actually just filter better when they start getting clogged. But clogging increases air resistance, so you need higher power level in the fan to get the same throughput. So the economics calculation is, the cost of new filters vs. the cost of electricity of running the fan and eventually the cost of a new fan. And the comfort factor is more noise when the fan is running at higher power level. So running the filters a long time before replacing, might be the cost-saving option.
- DJBunnies 4y agoDid you see the tape?
- post_break 4y agoI mean if it works, but it's also the ugliest thing I've seen. It's up there with those plastic covers for furniture. A standalone air purifier in the corner would be less noticeable and ikea even makes a table with a hidden one: https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/starkvind-table-with-air-purifier-stained-oak-veneer-white-80461974/ https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/starkvind-table-with-air-purifi... Aesthetics matter. Now if you could somehow make the blades the filters, that would be badass.
- flybrand 4y agoI agree - I love the enthusiasm for IAQ, the data is fantastic - but find a conventional white good stand alone room air purifier “RAP” and it will be as effective, better designed, and likely in the same cost range once changeouts are considered.
- s5300 4y agoAesthetics only matter for the extremely insecure. I for one would happily proclaim “my shitty looking box fan contraption that costs $100 outperforms your $700 dyson by a decent margin” Why lick the boots of brand centric corporations. Maybe you’re one of those “lifestyle brand” people… I think that’s code for no originality or personality.
- post_break 4y agoA box fan with a filter looks infinitely better than filters taped to the ceiling... I have a dyson air purifier because the sound profile is different and doesn't keep me up while I sleep. In the room with my 3d printer I have the jankiest air purifier I could find. If you're ok with this contraption taped to your ceiling, while having guests over, more power to you. This of course would be totally fine if you lived in a state dealing with wild fire smoke I will say.
- mreiner 4y agoI like your concept, can imagine it to look quite aesthetic. Consider you need to create a fair pressure gradient between the two sides of the filter and it needs to be higher the more the filter clogs up. AFAIK radial fans are more efficient for that purpose. Downside is the noise. If you are running the ceiling fan anyway just for the turbulence it creates on a hot day, it's probably fine even if just a small percentage of the airflow is pulled through the filters, your data certainly looks promising.
- hinkley 4y agoThat’s why those filters are full of zigzags. The CFM/m² is very small, and so it can capture small particles instead of them zipping through. Also takes longer for them to clog up. Way longer than the oil change place wants you to think. The test of a dirty filter is that it looks dark when backlit, not when it is covered with surface lint. When they show your your filter, take it out of their hands.
- blagie 4y agoI think people are missing the point. YES this is bad engineering for a finished product: - The fan is not designed for high static pressure. It won't do well pulling air through filters. - It's ugly. It will get uglier as filters get dirty. - It's expensive to replace filters. - Etc. But it's not a finished, industrial project. It's a prototype. Those sorts of issues are universal for prototypes. They're easy to address: - Switch to a rotor design with higher static pressure - Provide prefilters. Ideally, there's a nice cover, followed by a washable pre-filter, followed by a carbon filter, followed by the fancy high-filtration filter. With an appropriate frame, it could be beautiful -- nicer than a normal fan. The filters could actually reduce noise. The frame could guide air (much as in a Vornado), increasing airflow. Good job OP. It's a clever idea and a good design. It's a proof-of-concept implementation, but that's the point of a proof-of-concept. (Unless you like the DIY aesthetic, which some do)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- turtlebits 4y agoThis is just an air filter with more filters, the installation location is part of the prototype, which is not practical at all.
- hinkley 4y agoOne way to reduce static pressure is to increase the number of filters. I saw one design last year, during the fires, that was a cube. Lasco fan on one side, and five filters tied into a box shape. A couple problems. One, space - this thing was bigger than a dorm fridge. Two, availability - no way you were finding five filters during a wildfire. Three, etiquette - if you found five filters that meant two other people weren’t getting any at all. Four, diminishing returns. Two filters reduce the pressure by half. Another only reduces it by a third, and so on.
- jefftk 4y ago> Two, availability - no way you were finding five filters during a wildfire. Three, etiquette - if you found five filters that meant two other people weren’t getting any at all. Filters last a long time unopened: buy them in advance and store them until you need them, rotating stock.
- maxk42 4y agoIs nobody going to mention what a pain in the ass it would be to change all those filters regularly? I love in a somewhat dry and dusty area and need to change my filters (near the ground) every two to three months. I'd hate to have to climb up a ladder to change eight to nine filters that often.
- jefftk 4y agoUnless your ceiling is very high you probably wouldn't need a ladder to change the filters on a productized version of this. Reach up, twist something to unlock, old filter slides out, slide in new filter, twist to lock. Repeat for each filter going around. Ten minutes every six months?
- mxfh 4y agoNot to forget, you'll have a looming black octagon after 6 weeks or so already depending on your environment. At least a reminder, that the filters are doing something useful.
- jefftk 4y agoI've been running a filter cube in my office 8hr/day since November. It's a bit grey, but far from black.
- Brajeshwar 4y agoCan we also please add a wi-fi access point to the ceiling fans? I always thought that would be awesome.
- _ea1k 4y agoThat's kind of brilliant, tbh. The biggest downside that I can think of is that they tend to be electrically noisy and fairly space constrained. It'd have to be really small, but probably possible.
- hinkley 4y agoMight be easier to do on a fan with a light fixture. The part that sticks down below the fan is a lot of dead space, and farther from the motor.
- ark03 4y agoMy intuition says most airflow comes from the center(and drops linearly towards the tip of the blade and picks up at the blade) i.e. there's no need to build a filter the size of the fan; you can cover "most" of the airflow by using something similar but extends 50-60% of blade length(pure guess) and the whole arrangement can be above the rotating plane (so easier build?)
- aarongray 4y agoI love the enthusiasm and DIY ingenuity here. That said, the post is tagged with COVID-19. The COVID virus particles are .1 to .5 microns in size, and these MERV-14 filters, while certainly better than nothing, are not going to capture a significant amount of these virus particles. A better approach is to not filter the particles, but actually rip them apart at a molecular level. This has the added benefit of destroying all sorts of other contaminents that even high grade HEPA filters will miss, such as mold mycotoxins. A system like the Molekule is a good example of this approach. https://molekule.com/technology https://molekule.com/technology
- picture 4y agoIs this legit? Their website feels kinda sketchy to me, with the huge and somewhat tacky CG pictures, sweeping claims, apparent SEM photography that just looks too good to be true (could there really be zero residue? and the background never change, presumably over time span of at least minutes!) This really reminds me of vaporware like WaterSeer, or one of the recent "turn kitchen garbage into dry dust" appliances that I've seen ads for
- gonehome 4y agoYour intuition is correct - it’s bullshit. — In the summer of 2019, we purchased a Molekule Air (the flagship model) and tested it. We bought an Air Mini that fall and tested it in February 2020. At the time we tested the Molekule Air, the company claimed that its “scientifically-proven nanotechnology outperforms HEPA filters in every category of pollutant.” Our tests proved otherwise. And by mid-2020, that language had been withdrawn, after many of the company’s claims were ruled against in a case before the National Advertising Division and upheld in a later appeal before the National Advertising Review Board. The Molekule Air turned in the worst performance on particulates of any purifier, of any size, of any price, that we have tested in the eight years that we have been producing this guide. The Air Mini outperformed it, but that’s not saying much: It still produced the second-worst performance we’ve ever seen. Guide author Tim Heffernan asked Molekule CEO Dilip Goswami why the language was removed. He answered, “The point about ‘in all categories’ is that we see a device that outperforms across all of the categories. Right? So we’re not trying to say that individually, on any particular metric, we would be number one. Right? What we’re saying is, when you look across all the categories, we outperform HEPA. Right? And that’s what we’re attempting to convey with that. And so—it’s fair to say that we needed to re-examine some of the language to make sure that it’s saying what we’re intending to say.” https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-air-purifier/#molekule-air-and-air-mini-the-worst-air-purifiers-weve-ever-tested https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-air-purifier...
- mrfusion 4y agoOff topic but why did tic toc start showing me diy air filter videos right after I read this article? Is there some kind of tracking?
- atmartins 4y agoYes. And it's on your home IP address. I see things based on what others in my household have done with Tok Tok
- harvie 4y agoUse static electricity to attract the dust from air, completely quiet.
- coding123 4y agoJeff, is this for covid or more for prepping for the CA fire season?
- jefftk 4y agoPrimarily thinking about covid, but would work for either
- WesleyJohnson 4y agoMatthias Wandel's secondary YouTube channel has a lot of recent videos about retail air purifiers compared to homemade ones using box fans. I'm not up to snuff on the science of it all, but he does a lot of cool comparisons on the effectiveness of each. Worth a look if you're interested in this sort of thing. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3_AWXcf2K3l9ILVuQe-XwQ/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3_AWXcf2K3l9ILVuQe-XwQ/vid...
- jjeaff 4y agoI like his channel. He is one of the few people you will see out there with almost an entire shop full of very useful, but completely diy woodworking tools.
- steve76 4y ago
- seanp2k2 4y agoCool idea but very low "wife approval factor". Just do the box fan + MERV 13 air filter if you want something decent for <$50.
- mgraczyk 4y ago"people often select purifiers based on their maximum flow" I don't know if that's really true. Looking at the top 20 or so Air Purifiers on Amazon, almost none of them mention the CADR or flow in the title, and very few of the reviews mention it. Most talk about sound, "HEPA", "ozone-free" etc. My guess would be that people care much more about physical appearance than maximum flow. I would personally not tape an octagon of dirty air filters to my ceiling because that would be look ridiculous and probably not filter as well as my beautiful, silent $200 Winix box.
- strunz 4y agoMost mention the room size or square footage they cover though, which is a simplified way to say the same thing
- ChuckMcM 4y agoNice work! I built a "Corsi cube" using 4x 20" filters and a 20" box fan. Some simple extrusions for the filter corners would be a win (and probably a good basis for a DIY kit). Since the Corsi cube can be hung from the ceiling (it looks weird being a cube hanging up there) but it is ungainly. This is a much more elegant solution.
- ChoGGi 4y agoKind of ugly looking... And that paint is probably coming off when the tape comes down I had a new furnace/AC installed last year with a 4" filter. $50 CAD for a carbon filter and leaving just the fan on made a vast reduction in smoke smell during a wildfire or two from BC.
- simne 4y agoGreat idea! I thinking about make something similar (with one very big prop) for computer cooling system, and also it could be beneficial to make computer case with purifier filter, why not.
- fomine3 4y agoIt depends on the purpose, but air purifier should be at the floor because dusts finally fall at the bottom, isn't it?