5 ms·
The size and longevity of these enormous endowments is a problem, but it is quite naive to think that you could create a top tier university with an arbitrarily
by colechristensen 4y ago
The size and longevity of these enormous endowments is a problem, but it is quite naive to think that you could create a top tier university with an arbitrarily large amount of money. There is quite a lot more to the quality of an institution than the ability to build facilities, pay salaries, and buy equipment.
- ajross 4y ago> The size and longevity of these enormous endowments is a problem Is it? The largest university endowment in the world is $50B. That's wouldn't even crack the top 100 US companies by market cap. If it's a problem, it's certainly not a big one.
- clairity 4y agocomparing endowment to market cap is misunderstanding basic finance and accounting. endowments are more directly (but not perfectly) comparable to (long-term) assets on the balance sheet. those are typically a small fraction of the market cap of a company. apple, for instance, has a $2.4T market cap, but it's non-current assets are $216B (of which $128B are investment assets).
- ajross 4y agoHow so? Universities don't use their endowments like companies use assets either. Assets are returned as dividends or reinvested. University endowments are for income. If anything they under perform the returns that the broader market would use to assign a market cap. A public company with a total revenue /budget of Harvard's would have a market cap rather less than the endowment size. I'm still not understanding what the problem with these endowments is, except that they represent money in the hands of people you personally dislike.
- clairity 4y ago> "Assets are returned as dividends or reinvested." see, you did it again. assets are almost never "returned" anywhere. that's typically profits. you don't need an mba, but to have any credibility, you need to at least use these words reasonably. in a capital structure, endowments are most similar to (long-term) assets, not revenue, income, or market cap (which is a valuation). i'll leave it as an exercise to work out why.
- ajross 4y agoGood grief, you know perfectly well I meant liquid assets, c.f. the number you cited for Apple. I'm not talking about factories and capital goods, and you know that. The term as you used it is ambiguous[1], but I engaged in exactly the frame you used on the assumption that you'd interpret it in good faith. This kind of nitpickery isn't winning, it's just deflection. So deflect away. But you know perfectly well that Harvard University isn't 1/4 the size of Apple Computer. [1] c.f. your own qualification when you had to say "(long term) assets"! Needless to say that Apple number you quoted wasn't an accounting of any kind of long term investment. It was cash!
- clairity 4y agoyou keep making the same mistake. it's really easy to look up the balance sheet of apple online, and then look up the line item terms on investopedia (hint: "non-current assets"). luckily it's a random internet board and not a work meeting or something.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoCreating a top tier school would be hard with a large pile of money, but would be a lot easier if you started with a large pile of money and Harvard. This is an argument against the article. But the article's plan could be used as a threat. Use it or lose it, expand your enrollment substantially or we'll tax your endorsement away.
- hooloovoo_zoo 4y agoCreating a top tier university with a big pile of money would be trivial. Match every grant dollar for dollar, provide lab space and free tuition for 30 years and you’d have the most productive faculty and the best students overnight. It would just cost 10s of billions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- davidgay 4y ago... and in fact: www.epfl.ch (my undergraduate) "The QS World University Rankings ranks EPFL 14th in the world across all fields in their 2020/2021 ranking" (from wikipedia) It is indeed ~free ($1600/year) for Swiss residents at least, and gets most of its funding from the Swiss government. I would take issue with the "overnight" bit though - the ranking above was not its ranking 30 years ago when I was there (and the EPFL took its current form in 1969). It also took a concerted effort to hire the right faculty, probably recruit the right graduate students, etc, etc.
- 908B64B197 4y agoWhat's interesting is that, from my experience, they are one of the few schools that don't recruit from the same "pool" of talent as everyone else. If you want to do engineering in French, it's either score a spot at EPFL, or go to Polytechnique in Paris (very small) or all the way to Polytechnique in Montreal (8 hours flight time?).
- 4y ago
- derbOac 4y agoThis is the internet, so I'm willing to let people wildly speculate in interesting ways. Having said that, I don't know this is as impractical as some seem to think (or at least in the ways some are thinking -- there might be lawsuits about taxation but in terms of establishing a school, less so). All you have to do is admit students with appealing enough characteristics (GPAs, GREs, whatever you can quantify) and you'll immediately establish a reputation out of the gate. Then you build out your faculty by giving out insane incentives to start, from undervalued individuals in the right places. There's enough oversupply in academics to fulfill this need. I might be skeptical too except I've seen this work at the high school and college level. Brand new high schools established that immediately have super high test scores; it establishes a brand immediately. At least one university I know of had a windfall and was smart enough to vacuum up undervalued properties and start pulling in whole colleges and departments spontaneously by making remarkable offers to the right people. Their only problem was that they weren't a new university, so they had a sort of existing old reputation to overcome.
- boeingUH60 4y agoKing Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) in Saudi Arabia started in 2009 with a $10 billion endowment [1]. As far as I can tell, they’re still not noteworthy on the global stage. 1- https://www.science.org/content/article/can-saudi-arabia-build-mit-10-billion-says-yes-desert-school-opens https://www.science.org/content/article/can-saudi-arabia-bui...
- l33t2328 4y agoThat’s not that much to start a school from scratch. You need dozens of buildings and a huge amount of equipment to be competitive, and that’s without mentioning the fact that many academics don’t want to work in Saudi Arabia.
- bruceb 4y agoBecause very few young people would list Saudi Arabia as place to visit, even for free. Starting with a $10b endowmwnt in North America, Europe, or East Asia would probably create a noteworthy university inside 15 years.
- djbebs 4y agoMillions of people go to Saudi Arabia yearly...
- hhjinks 4y ago60% of college students are women. Do you think most women would want to study abroad in Saudi Arabia? Teach? Do research? Seems like you'll have a hard time becoming a notable university when you've alienated the most numerous category of academics.
- sammalloy 4y agoDo you mean for religious pilgrimage to Mecca? That’s different from what the OP is talking about.
- eunos 4y agoIt's a very specific university that focus on STEM. So it lacks certain renown unless you worked intensively with their researchers.