5 ms·

the problem of choosing a good leader hasn't been solved by humans yet.

by nazgulnarsil 18y ago

goodkarma 18y ago
For example: George W. Bush
- msg 18y ago
  GW picked a great leader: Dick Cheney
  - chaostheory 18y ago
    depends on perspective. dick has been great for GW's self interest, I'm not so sure about how great he's been for the country though
    - msg 18y ago
      Sorry. The snark I feel is never the snark you read. I made a pretty borderline comment anyway. Must remember </sarcasm> tag
- goodkarma 18y ago
  LOL, funny I lost karma for saying that.. :)
marvin 18y ago
This is a gross simplification. Good leaders do exist. The real problems are politics and corruption, which happen to run rampant in...well, politics and public companies. These areas are where the "problem of choosing a good leader" is most pressing. It would work out nicely if every leader thought leading was so fun that he'd do it for free. Berkshire Hathaway chooses its managers in this way. The people they hire seem to enjoy building something rugged. Unfortunately, many leadership positions just aren't fun enough for this to be a viable option. And it's not even just a question of choosing the right man for the job. Public companies are notorious for their ruthless owners (the market), which often require different things than what would be necessary for long-term growth and stability. Even if all shareholders were interested in the distant future, the market is nothing if not a committtee. Necessary decisions are sometimes unpopular. No one who masters his craft (in this case domain-specific leadership) wants to be bogged down with politics, but this is exactly what public companies offer. Hence, these positions attract the wrong type of people - those who are attracted to money or power. The 'right man for the job' is probably enjoying a tenth of the salary leading some small company somewhere, because leading a large market-exposed company just isn't worth it. It's not just a question of choosing the right guy and writing him a big check; he might not want the job.

the problem of choosing a good leader hasn't been solved by humans yet.

goodkarma 18y ago

For example: George W. Bush

msg 18y ago
GW picked a great leader: Dick Cheney
- chaostheory 18y ago
  depends on perspective. dick has been great for GW's self interest, I'm not so sure about how great he's been for the country though
  - msg 18y ago
    Sorry. The snark I feel is never the snark you read. I made a pretty borderline comment anyway. Must remember </sarcasm> tag
goodkarma 18y ago
LOL, funny I lost karma for saying that.. :)

marvin 18y ago

This is a gross simplification. Good leaders do exist. The real problems are politics and corruption, which happen to run rampant in...well, politics and public companies. These areas are where the "problem of choosing a good leader" is most pressing. It would work out nicely if every leader thought leading was so fun that he'd do it for free. Berkshire Hathaway chooses its managers in this way. The people they hire seem to enjoy building something rugged. Unfortunately, many leadership positions just aren't fun enough for this to be a viable option. And it's not even just a question of choosing the right man for the job. Public companies are notorious for their ruthless owners (the market), which often require different things than what would be necessary for long-term growth and stability. Even if all shareholders were interested in the distant future, the market is nothing if not a committtee. Necessary decisions are sometimes unpopular. No one who masters his craft (in this case domain-specific leadership) wants to be bogged down with politics, but this is exactly what public companies offer. Hence, these positions attract the wrong type of people - those who are attracted to money or power. The 'right man for the job' is probably enjoying a tenth of the salary leading some small company somewhere, because leading a large market-exposed company just isn't worth it. It's not just a question of choosing the right guy and writing him a big check; he might not want the job.