3 ms·
Proudhon (IMO) is not nearly as compelling as either Rawls or Nozick, although he is popular among the younger generation of 'professional-class' capitalists.
by whimsicalism 4y ago
Proudhon (IMO) is not nearly as compelling as either Rawls or Nozick, although he is popular among the younger generation of 'professional-class' capitalists.
- guerrilla 4y agoHave you read "What is property?" or Nozick? > although he is popular among the younger generation of 'professional-class' capitalists. This seems like an attempted ad hominem but makes me suspect you might not know who Proudhon is.
- whimsicalism 4y agoI've actually read both, although it's been a while since "What is property?". I have not read any other Proudhon. > makes me suspect you might not know who Proudhon is. No, I know exactly who he is. Left libertarianism is ironically very popular among rich millenials & Gen Z, probably because it allows them to be cynical about all institutions when in reality governmental, collective action is the only realistic counter to capitalism.
- guerrilla 4y ago> No, I know exactly who he is. Left libertarianism is ironically very popular among rich millenials & Gen Z, probably because it allows them to be cynical about all institutions when in reality governmental, collective action is the only realistic counter to capitalism. What you said originally is that Proudhon is popular among a subclass of capitalists, which is a contradiction, being that he was an anti-capitalist. Now you're saying libertarian socialism is popular among a subset of rich people, which also seems pretty suspect at this point in time. Then you're giving an explanation of why this is the case but that also seems implausible and you give no argument or evidence for it (and honestly it just sounds like dismissive hand-waving)... Then you say collective action, exactly what Proudhon (and almost all libertarian socialists, including mutualists) argued for, is the alternative, which is also a contradiction: It can't be the alternative if it was part of the original position. What you're saying isn't making any sense to me...
- whimsicalism 4y ago> which is a contradiction Being a capitalist who thinks they believe in anti-capitalism may be hypocritical but it is not a logical impossibility. > libertarian socialism is popular among a subset of rich people, which also seems pretty suspect at this point in time What do you think is the median income of someone who knows who Proudhon even is? I will confess that I am absolutely speaking from anecdata, not from some income survey of Proudhon supporters, but anybody I have ever discussed him with has been quite well off. Even most libertarian socialists seem to have been aware of this themselves. Straying from Proudhon, consider this essay (Appeal to the Young) [0] by Peter Kropotkin. Look at the audience he is writing to - it is precisely young, rich professionals! > collective action, exactly what Proudhon (and almost all libertarian socialists, including mutualists) argued for, is the alternative, which is also a contradiction That's fair enough, I should have been clearer - I was referring to hierarchical, centralized action as in the form of the state. The "governmental" was modifying the "collective," the comma was not operating as an "or" there. [0]: http://dwardmac.pitzer.edu/Anarchist_Archives/kropotkin/appealtoyoung.html http://dwardmac.pitzer.edu/Anarchist_Archives/kropotkin/appe...
- guerrilla 4y ago> Being a capitalist who thinks they believe in anti-capitalism may be hypocritical but it is not a logical impossibility. I don't think it's hypocritical to not want to live in the system you have to live in. > Even most libertarian socialists seem to have been aware of this themselves. Straying from Proudhon, consider this essay (Appeal to the Young) [0] by Peter Kropotkin. Look at the audience he is writing to - it is precisely young, rich professionals! Kropotkin wasn't talking to Gen Z and millennials, which was your claim. I mean I wish what you were saying were true, but I don't think you're going to find any polls that come even close to supporting popularity among those demographics right now. Maybe in the future. > I was referring to hierarchical, centralized action as in the form of the state. So, the opposite of collective action, just dominance by one group over the rest like we already have.
- whimsicalism 4y ago
- nicoburns 4y ago> governmental, collective action is the only realistic counter to capitalism I feel like it's not either-or, and that we ought to acknowledge that there's a very real information gathering / decision making problem that is in some cases but not others very neatly solved by markets. I don't see why market based systems that don't lead to systematic wealth accumulation are seen as unrealistic.
- guerrilla 4y agoExactly. It's the positive feedback loops we need to get rid of.
- whimsicalism 4y agoMarkets may be valuable, but not as a counter to capitalism. Personally, I'm very sympathetic to a market-based, strong state approach (maybe what might be derided as the "Dengist" approach) > why market based systems that don't lead to systematic wealth accumulation are seen as unrealistic. You still have to resolve Nozick's wilt chamberlain problem and it's not always unclear how that works. If it isn't possible to accumulate wealth in your market, what is the incentive for participants? Personally, I think inherited wealth is a big, big problem, but also one that can hopefully be eliminated without too much of an impact on the functioning of markets.... while people do accumulate wealth in order to pass on to their children, I am not sure the primary reason people accumulate millions of dollars is just to pass it on to their kids.
- guerrilla 4y ago> If it isn't possible to accumulate wealth in your market, what is the incentive for participants? Obviously the answer is to produce things that they and others want. That's a sufficient incentive proven by everyone that does subsistence farming or has a hobby... We don't need profit and capital accumulation to survive and do cool shit.