3 ms·
Note: they are charging him with wire fraud and money laundering. The DOJ is not attempting any insider trading specific charge or aiming to define the NFT ass
by yieldcrv 4y ago
Note: they are charging him with wire fraud and money laundering.
The DOJ is not attempting any insider trading specific charge or aiming to define the NFT assets traded. But like insider trading, the wire fraud charge is contingent on the existence of the confidentially agreement with his employer.
- dubswithus 4y agoWill the buyers of the NFT's be able to sue this guy?
- colechristensen 4y agoSeems like they would have a decent case.
- chrisco255 4y agoInsider trading is not contingent on a confidentiality agreement with an employer. It's an actual law on the books: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/insider_trading https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/insider_trading
- yieldcrv 4y agoIt is contingent on having a fiduciary duty with the issuing organization, just like your own source says. For non-directors, this duty comes in the form of confidentiality agreements that are part of standard employment contracts (but can take any form, and the wording must be evaluated by the prosecutors independent of the action they wish to prosecute). Note, that it also relies on the thing being traded being a security. Which the DOJ here decided to avoid trying to figure out, by specifically not leveraging the insider trading fraud statutes. And therefore they stick with the super broad wire fraud statute, the fraud part being extended to the breach of fiduciary duty. They otherwise wouldn't have a tool to prosecute this action that.
- chrisco255 4y agoSeems like a stretch from the DOJ. I wonder if plaintiff settles or goes forward with the trial.
- yieldcrv 4y agoabsolutely agreed, it is quite a stretch but its not how I would have led with the conversation because people want this guy to have consequences.
- twox2 4y agoIMO, I think the way he was publicly lambasted and fired was punishment enough. Not to mention that shortly after, people were calling for him to return to OpenSea, because they were struggling without him for a hot minute. I agree what he did was stupid and wrong, but I think he's the wrong person for the DOJ to throw the book at. They are only targeting him, because this was low hanging fruit due to the public outcry around this incident.
- alphabetting 4y agoDisagree with most of this. It couldn't be more clearly textbook insider trading. He wouldn't have bought the NFTs and then immediately sold them for 5x profits if he didn't know OpenSea would be featuring them. >I think he's the wrong person for the DOJ to throw the book at Who cares if other people have done worse? When you break the law you should face consequences.
- yieldcrv 4y agoour realization is that we don't really have laws to cover this. insider trading is exclusively a securities law violation, which requires securities to have been traded. the NFTs in question are not securities and the actions around them are not being prosecuted as such. the remaining laws the prosecutors came up with are such a stretch that it seems like a waste of public resources, although "wire fraud" is sufficiently broad enough it may still be either kind of weak, or, not the expansion we want. Case in point, "wire fraud" is typically a tacked on charge, in addition to another charge. and "money laundering" is also a tacked on charge, that requires an illicit origin, not just the action of obfuscation or movement of money. So they have to tie a couple things together solely because "we don't like what happened", but it may be the wrong authority to deal consequence. It has nothing to do with a public understanding or a legal understanding of insider trading, because that's not what he was charged with, despite his trades being the catalyst for this indictment. semantics, but relevant semantics. you can insider trade everything except securities. you can have a market advantage on spot commodities, real estate, trading cards, you name it. but yes its typically a form of fraud when you can be proven to have created more demand than was really there + trading on that + when your employer has entrusted you not to do that. there are many circumstances where this would all be a non-case.
- olalonde 4y agoWhat is the alleged fraud then? It seems pretty clear that this is what he is accused of: > From at least in or about June 2021 to at least in or about September 2021, CHASTAIN used OpenSea’s confidential business information about what NFTs were going to be featured on its homepage to secretly purchase dozens of NFTs shortly before they were featured. After those NFTs were featured on OpenSea, CHASTAIN sold them at profits of two- to five-times his initial purchase price. To conceal the fraud, CHASTAIN conducted these purchases and sales using anonymous digital currency wallets and anonymous accounts on OpenSea.
- adrr 4y agoNot sure what the fraud here is. Who is the victim? The person who he bought it from? Let's say the company did the purchasing and reaped the benefits of being feature on their homepage. Would that be still be crime? It is the same act with different entities. These aren't securities so insider trading doesn't apply.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThe fraud, I believe, is that he chose what would be featured, and that he was entrusted not to do this specific thing in his employment agreement. The case seems to revolve around that, to open to door to federal prosecution of otherwise benign (but annoying) actions.