3 ms·
Elon clearly has a Hobbesian conceptualization of power. Key phrases in his memo precipitate gracefully from the very same naturall power, instrumentall power,
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
Elon clearly has a Hobbesian conceptualization of power. Key phrases in his memo precipitate gracefully from the very same naturall power, instrumentall power, relative power, and ceding power that Hobbes lays out in Leviathan. Let me demonstrate.
> Tesla has and will create and actually manufacture the most exciting and meaningful products of any company on Earth.
Here Elon describes the consequences for working from the office. It is the use of power as the ability to secure well-being or personal advantage 'to obtain some future apparent Good'. It's to affect a change in the world - the ability to manufacture exciting and meaningful products.
> If you don't show up, we will assume you have resigned.
Elon directly connects presence with power in this statement. Resignation is the ultimate absence of the power to affect change within Telsa in the same way that not showing up is. Conversely, Tesla's power is the aggregation of the presence of its workforce. Instrumentall power is definitionally the aggregation of power and they buying of compliance. Tesla's buying of compliance are the wages paid in exchange for labor.
> There are of course companies that don't require this, but when was the last time they shipped a great new product? It's been a while.
In this passage, Elon establishes a conceptualization of relative power. He strikes a comparison between companies that require presence and those that don't. Those that do have the power to ship 'great new product's, and those that don't, don't.
> The more senior you are, the more visible must be your presence.
This equation constructs an equivalence between power and presence. It is under-girded by the assumption that a manager's power is the aggregation of power (compliance) ceded by their direct reports. Those with more aggregate power must show more presence. "That's why I lived at the factory so much," is evidence that Elon sees himself as having the most presence and therefore the most power.
I've demonstrated how Elon has a Hobbesian account of power directly tied to Hobbes' ideas of naturall power, instrumentall power, relative power, and ceding power. Elon sees himself as the culmination of this power and consequently he see's Tesla as his Leviathan.