6 ms·
News flash: big company only does things in its interest. When Apple was trying to escape from its near death experience (imac era) they were super enthusiasti
by gumby 4y ago
News flash: big company only does things in its interest.
When Apple was trying to escape from its near death experience (imac era) they were super enthusiastic about open standards (JPEG, MP3, iCal, et al.). When I say "super enthusiastic" I mean to the point of Jobs touting that on stage.
Of course they also paid adobe and Microsoft for access to some of their very popular formats. They paid for USB and made one of the first, and as is usual for them, most strict and compliant, implementations. They were probably the first consumer 802.11 companies. As much as possible they wanted to talk to as many things as possible.
As they clawed their way back those standards were still OK (and still are -- Apple is actually pretty good at supporting open standards, better than most in my experience) but they didn't care as much about going off in their own direction again, and making those their defaults.
- pjmlp 4y agoOne big example was OpenGL adoption, nowadays the FOSS folks get salty with Metal, yet the pre-Jobs revival Apple was doubling down in QuickDraw 3D and QuickDraw VRML, they couldn't care less about OpenGL.
- mmphosis 4y ago> When Apple was trying to escape from its near death experience (imac era) The "imac era" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac_G3#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac_G3#History Steve Jobs reduced the company's large product lines immediately upon becoming Apple's interim CEO in 1997 ... The company announced the iMac on May 6, 1998
- eyelidlessness 4y agoThe “era” definitely began then but definitely didn’t have much impact other than cultural until a few years later. Really it should be called the iPod era, but even that lagged a while as Apple gave up on mainstreaming FireWire.
- gumby 4y agoThe iMac really did keep apple from falling down the well and dying. They were busy throwing whatever they could into the fight, and (to mix metaphors) tossing overboard anything that didn’t help. This was the era of iTunes, iDVD and iEverythingElse. The iPod was at first something to plug into that nascent iEcosystem. It began a period of growth.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoExactly my point. The iMac was a product for years before any of these other efforts. It did help, but it took all of these other products (most importantly the iPod, and eventually iTunes along with it) to really make it more than a flash in the pan. By the time it was effective, the iMac had been repositioned from an entry level computer to a status symbol (as displayed in many product placement ads), and eventually the non-workstation pro Mac. It’s iconic mainly because it was a pivotal historical point for Apple, not because it actually achieved that pivot.
- Jasper_ 4y agoExactly. Underdog companies always try and differentiate themselves with standards and openness and talk about how friendly they are compared to the big giants, and then close themselves off once they become #1. I have personally seen this happen so many times. And it's happening right now with AMD as they're slowly overtaking Intel. And expect to see Intel scramble soon about how they're all geeks at heart and love open-source and standards.
- bitwize 4y agoIt's the tech corporate version if "When you are stronger than me, I plead for freedom because it is according to your principles. When I am stronger than you, I take away your freedom because that is according to my principles."
- eyelidlessness 4y agoThey may have paid a few lip services to openness, but very seldom (apart from their legal obligations) openness of source. They did very broadly embrace interoperability when it suited them, and it’s increasingly suited them except in a few key competitive areas. And they’ve quietly relented in areas where they were overly aggressive resisting for very little business purpose (eg AV codecs). I’d be surprised if, in a perfect universe of their imagining, Apple wouldn’t fully embrace open source… because they don’t see much value in software other than integration. Their resistance to standards and openness now is almost entirely about protecting trade secrets. Which definitely has flaws! But it’s a substantial difference from Apple in the early 2000s where they couldn’t coherently tell a story about what was public or why.
- olliej 4y agoCan you define "very seldom (apart from their legal obligations) openness of source"? There are major OSS projects that were started by Apple, and plenty that weren't started by, but definitely get the bulk of their engineering from Apple, in public repositories.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoApart from Swift I can’t think of an example of this. But I do think Swift is a great example of how Apple would embrace OSS if they had the right incentives.
- shp0ngle 4y agoJoel had an article on his "blog" - way back in 2002 - about something like this. https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ Back then, it was not really much about Apple, but about Microsoft and Sun. But you get the picture.
- qubex 4y ago> they were super enthusiastic about open standards (JPEG, MP3, iCal, et al) Let’s not forget that Jobs promised iChat would be opened for third parties to interoperate with, and never did.
- exikyut 4y agoOh, like FaceTime! D:
- nreilly 4y agoiChat supported jabber
- lproven 4y agoiChat originally used the AIM ("Oscar") protocol. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OSCAR_protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OSCAR_protocol Later it added XMPP and Yahoo IM support. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messages_(Apple)#macOS_version https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messages_(Apple)#macOS_version I am not some Apple-booster here. I use Franz, myself. But it was open. I don't have anything newer than 10.14 here so I can't talk about later versions.
- olliej 4y agoNo, the iMac era was not relevant to the business failure of Apple. The issue was that they were built on PPC, and IBM, et al, were utterly failing to provide hardware that was in any way competitive from a price perspective, and for the last few years of that architecture they weren't even providing performance competitive hardware at any price. As far as hardware goes, Apple could reasonably charge a premium for a lot of Mac hardware: They were known for high end LCD, Speakers, they were ahead on USB, DVD, Firewire (...). But people don't care about the architecture of the CPU, they care about the speed it can do something, and PPC CPUs cost more than Intel or AMD by a vary large margin (I've always assumed whole-number factor?), and towards the end of the era PPC was also slower than the competitor. I'm not a business person, and obviously know nothing about Apple's financial or business plans, but I can't imagine that having to pay a huge premium for the most expensive part of a Mac (and having that also be both slower and hotter than the competition) was probably chewing out a huge amount of any profit margin than was manageable. Paying licensing fees for popular formats is an obvious thing for a personal computer company to do - that Ubuntu, or some of the other "end user" distro, never did just seems petulant.
- 7speter 4y agoWere IBM cpus really magnitudes more expensive than Intel/AMD cpus or were they just packaged in macs that had their own premium tacked on (in part because of the integration of cutting edge standards like usb and wifi when wintel vendors were years behind admittedly)? I was reminiscing the other day about the common early aughts meme of pc builders on forums always talking about how they could build a pc that was twice as powerful as a mac for nearly half the cost :), but if anything the price of the ibm power cpus were an abstract mystery because consumers only ever saw them in macs (until the xbox360 anyways)
- olliej 4y agoThat’s actually a really interesting question. As I think about it, all I can produce is “everyone knows they were more expensive”, which is questionable in terms of veracity :D I’ll see if I can find some actual figures
- lproven 4y ago> Of course they also paid adobe and Microsoft for access to some of their very popular formats. [[citation needed]]