5 ms·
10 days ago I had a 3 day power outage, and lost all the food in my fridge. Generators are a giant PITA. You need to use and maintain them regularly or they'r
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
10 days ago I had a 3 day power outage, and lost all the food in my fridge.
Generators are a giant PITA. You need to use and maintain them regularly or they're going to be broken and filled with stale gas when you need them. For something you only use once a decade or so, that's a big ask. Better to have something you use daily, like your truck, so you know it works.
A half charged vehicle is no problem during a grid failure. That's 150 miles. An EV gets better mileage in a traffic jam than it does at highway speeds, so it's a true 150 no matter road conditions. Also remember that you don't have to find a fast charger -- EV's can be trickle charged off a normal 115V outlet, and that's usually easier to find than gasoline during a crisis. All the gasoline stations around me last week either had multi-hour lineups or were out of gas.
- brianwawok 4y agoI own EVs, though Tesla doesn't do this (they want you to do a powerwall instead, which starts at 10-20k). Instead, I have a whole house natural gas generator. No gas to go stale. It powers my entire house. And it costs similar to this. Maintence: Every 2-3 years, it needs an "oil/filter" change. I have never had one before this house, but wow it is nice. We seem to be on some flakey power lines, we have lost power ~8 times in the previous year, ranging in duration from 1 hour to 2 days.
- giantg2 4y ago"Maintence: Every 2-3 years, it needs an "oil/filter" change." This seems suspect to me. The ones I've seen call for it once a year or every 24 hours of run time.
- AshleyGrant 4y agoEvery 24 hours of runtime would be insanely wasteful. A quick Google for a Generac manual shows they recommend annually or every 125 hours, whichever comes first. They do recommend an oil change after 30 hours to replace the break-in oil. The Onan/Cummins LP generator in my RV requires an oil change every 150 hours or annually, whichever comes first with the first oil change after 50 hours.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 4y agoAh, I probably forgot the 1 in front. But the annual thing still stands. Every 2-3 years is not something I've seen recommended.
- runnerup 4y agoI believe the reason for that is no engine oil manufacturer warranties their product longer than one year. However, engine oil these days is very high quality and should last longer than a year. 0: https://youtu.be/T-yt5a1cWd4 https://youtu.be/T-yt5a1cWd4
- briffle 4y agoMy parents have one of these. They work great, but have a few limitations: * the oil typically needs changed every 100 hours of operation. That was fine, until an ice storm knocked out power for 11 days to my parents house. * if you live in an earthquake zone, most likely after a major quake the gas lines will be down.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Kon-Peki 4y agoAre you basing your "every 2-3 years" on something the salesman said? You are using your backup generator a lot, you need to seek out the maintenance schedule for your model and ensure you are following it! In my area, Generac [1] and Kohler [2] are what everyone uses for their homes. The maintenance schedules are much higher than every 2-3 years. Good luck :) [1] https://www.generac.com/service-support/faqs/maintenance-kit-faqs/what-maintenance-do-i-need-to-do-and-how-often https://www.generac.com/service-support/faqs/maintenance-kit... [2] (Page 60) https://resources.kohler.com/power/kohler/residential/pdf/tp7092.pdf https://resources.kohler.com/power/kohler/residential/pdf/tp...
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoBased on my experience running all manner of clapped out junk with engines 2-3yr for an engine that sees dozens of operating hours per year and runs on propane/natgas seems fine. You're not pampering it by any means but you're not neglecting it either. Engines running on gaseous fuels tend to have really clean oil. I'd be more concerned about things nesting in it than anything else.
- brianwawok 4y agoI’m basing that on the manual that came with my generator, but I’m glad you as a hacker news stranger knows more than the actual person who read the manual.
- gigantaure 4y agoi'm not a fan of those "true milage no matter what conditions" a half charged EV up north during winter would cut that 150 miles to 75 miles (at around minus 10 celsius which is common in Canada). i wouldn't dare to go very far with that.
- fluctor 4y agoIt all depends on your use case. It can get below zero F here (northern Minnesota) for weeks at a time, but I don't regularly drive more than 10 miles round trip. As a second/town vehicle, a cheaper EV sounds great for conditions I can't use the e-assist cargo bike.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIn my experience, at -20C you lose about 10 miles of range to get the car up to temperature, plus about 20% of range to keep the car at temperature.
- _ea1k 4y ago> and that's usually easier to find than gasoline during a crisis. All the gasoline stations around me last week either had multi-hour lineups or were out of gas. I'm shocked at how many people overlook this. I've had the same experience, as our "crisis" situations tend to be combined with widespread gas shortages. EVs are surprisingly convenient during most of those. It wouldn't be fun to depend on a supercharger or other DCFC during that time, though... but maybe not significantly worse than gas even then. I've been in those gas lines.
- theshrike79 4y agoJust look at the situation in Ukraine. There are cities where pretty much all gas stations are literal holes in the ground from being blown up. On the other hand most apartments do have electricity and the only vehicles on the road are military or EVs.
- sokoloff 4y agoIf your power outages are "once a decade or so", "do nothing" seems like a reasonable (likely optimal) point on the response curve if you're not dependent on electricity for literal survival. This is our strategy in Cambridge, MA with some overhead supply lines, but it’s very rare to have an outage over an hour [the last one I recall was about 10.5 years ago]. We bought a few extra flashlights after that one.
- gwbas1c 4y ago> You need to use and maintain them regularly or they're going to be broken and filled with stale gas when you need them. My trick is that, instead of buying a gas or battery leaf blower, I just drag my generator out to the street and plug in a leaf blower to clean up my grass clippings. I do it often enough that I know my generator still works.
- unregistereddev 4y ago> An EV gets better mileage in a traffic jam than it does at highway speeds, so it's a true 150 no matter road conditions. You don't live in snow country. While winter reduces ICE vehicles' range as well (this isn't meant as a slam against EV's), you may lose 40% of your EV's range just due to cold weather. A multi-day power outage could easily drain what remains. Also, ice storms cause a lot of power outages. This isn't a hypothetical for large parts of the country; power outages are more frequent in the winter. Personally, my response is a variation on "do nothing". I have propane around for cooking and heating water, and I have a clean-burning kerosene heater to help keep the house warm-ish if we can't run the furnace for an extended period of time.
- jstream67 4y agoworth noting that the electric F-150 does not use a heat pump yet for some reason so cold weather performance will probably be poor. I'm not sure why anyone is making EVs without heat pumps - that is something Tesla pioneered years ago - and seems to be the obvious route to take for heating.
- gamblor956 4y agoWorth noting that the electric F-150 was designed and built in Michigan, where they have brutal winters, and are presumably aware of the effects of cold on EV systems, having tested these vehicles in the cold.
- elif 4y agowith 1 powerwall and 4kw solar, i could get through 3 days just by turning off the AC and the hot tub. i'm sure it was way more expensive than a generator, but a generator doesnt generate daily profit for the next 20 years either... PS i've also done 3 day camping trips in my EV so if i needed AC i could have it any time.