4 ms·
The problem is the courts letting banks/lenders get away with such complex legal agreements. We're straightforwardly bumping against computational complexity, b
by mindslight 4y ago
The problem is the courts letting banks/lenders get away with such complex legal agreements. We're straightforwardly bumping against computational complexity, but the legal system continues to ignore this. A reasonable alternative decision would be that a 90 page document is simply not understandable by the common person ("equal protection under the law"), and therefore is not part of / evidence of a binding contract.
The disclosure laws actually help the banks here, by putting the most important terms front and center where it can be argued that the borrower did understand those even if they couldn't understand the rest of the document. In fact many legal documents are structured in such a way, putting the big picture at the top and then defining/clarifying things later.
As far as your general point, what helps is printed materials by the state that lay out general legal advice. For example, take a look at the wonderful California Tenants Guide.
Another thing that would help would be a public standardization of common consumer contracts. There is no need for every lease/employment contract to have its own custom verbiage that a tenant/employee is purportedly responsible for understanding. There should be at most a handful of standard contracts for common relationships, drafted and published by the government. There are already some of these things published by industry groups like landlord's associations, although they can be a bit biased towards their members. Not using a standard contract or lengthy typeset additions should be judged as an a priori attempt to mislead that no amount of initialing will undo.
Furthermore, putting terms in a contract that are blatantly contrary to prevailing law should itself be illegal with its own penalties apart from enforcement of the contract.
Of course the paperwork pushing lobby isn't a fan of such reforms, and will lobby against them by framing such things as "big government" even though they're better described as mitigations of "big government". There is lots of money to be made by perpetuating government dysfunction and then providing a half-solution. See also: Intuit vs tax filing reform.
- toolz 4y ago> take a look at the wonderful California Tenants Guide. I've never once heard people from California praising their state for making renting better. I've heard the exact opposite many times over. Everything has tradeoffs. Every complexity the state forces into a transaction enables an exploitative company to leverage loopholes to their advantage. Only near perfect systems can reap the benefits of authoritative protections without inadvertently propping up exploiters who thrive on working around the complexity. Something a smaller, (likely more honest) company can't afford to do. There's a reason so many gigantic companies lobby for more regulation in their industry and I sincerely doubt that reason is to protect the consumer.
- mindslight 4y agoYou're rejecting the idea that we can analyze a specific action/edict of government to see if it makes things worse or better. Such a paradigm guarantees that things can only get worse, as the only successful changes will be ones that enrich some well funded interest (ie corruption / regulatory capture). > Every complexity the state forces into a transaction I do not see how publishing a guide of public legal advice is adding complexity, regulatory or otherwise, for either party. If you would like to make a specific argument of how it is, please do so. > I've never once heard people from California praising their state for making renting better. I've heard the exact opposite many times over. There are incentives to spread the negative/political messages, whereas the gains from repeating helpful individual-empowering advice are diffuse.
- travem 4y ago> I've never once heard people from California praising their state for making renting better Let me fix that for you. As a renter in California I had a Landlord who tried to hold on to the bulk of my security deposit (a few thousand dollars) for repainting walls, additional cleaning, etc. The clear guidance in this tenants guide gave me confidence in dealing with the Landlord, clearly articulating my stance, and getting the vast majority of my deposit back. Other Landlords I had were very reasonable and refunded my full deposit without issue (I always left property in a good state) but when I had one that tried to play hardball the guide plus a couple of well written letters with appropriate references to the guide helped me sort out the issue relatively easily. Making it clear what my rights were and setting clear expectations on tenants and landlords relative responsibilities was a clear benefit to me.
- lthornberry 4y agoI’ve rented in CA as well as other states. CA rental protections were great for getting my landlord to back down from withholding my security deposit for illegal reasons.
- lthornberry 4y agoThere are good points here, but the equal protection clause has nothing to do with this issue. There are standards in contract law that apply (and are state-specific). Those could be statutorily changed.
- saghm 4y ago> Furthermore, putting terms in a contract that are blatantly contrary to prevailing law should itself be illegal with its own penalties apart from enforcement of the contract. I can't help but scoff every time I read in a rental contract that even if some part of the contract is nullified due to not being legal, the rest of it still applies. It always makes me wonder which part of it they thought might not be enforceable, although likely they probably all include since it costs them nothing to do so.
- nybble41 4y agoA slightly more charitable interpretation would be that they are trying to use a standard contract with terms which are both reasonable and enforceable in most contexts, while allowing for the fact that the rules about precisely what is or is not legal in a contract can vary from one jurisdiction to another and may be subject to a certain amount of interpretation. Also, something which was legal at the time the contract was signed might be changed to be illegal later. Either way, they don't want the entire contract to be nullified on the basis of one invalid term. IMHO it mostly works out in your favor. If any of your obligations toward them are deemed unenforceable they are still bound to uphold the rest of the contract. The reverse could also apply, of course, but as the smaller and "less sophisticated" party to the contract your obligations are more likely to be nullified by local consumer protection rules than theirs.
- saghm 4y agoNormally I might agree with you, but after dealing with this landlord for six months...I don't think that a charitable interpretation is warranted. I won't bother going into details, but there have been no violations on my part, and I can't say the same for them.