2 ms·
Yes. The big problem is that you can't have a uniform distribution on the natural numbers. (And by extension, you can't have a uniform distribution on the rou
by eru 4y ago
Yes.
The big problem is that you can't have a uniform distribution on the natural numbers.
(And by extension, you can't have a uniform distribution on the rounded-to-integer version of a distribution on the real numbers.)
- xigoi 4y agoWho said there is a uniform distribution on the natural numbers?
- dllthomas 4y agoI think the assumption that "for all x, p(x) = p(2x)" implies a uniform distribution on the natural numbers. Imagine we have a distribution that satisfies that assumption, and then someone tells you they've sampled from that distribution and found that the result is of the form (say) 7*2^k, for some k > 0. That conditional distribution for k would seem to have to be uniform, right?
- dllthomas 4y agoWe're not dealing with the natural numbers, right? Otherwise, you obviously want to open the envelope and always switch when you see an odd number. Of course, the lack of a uniform distribution on the reals or rationals presents the same problem.
- eru 4y ago> We're not dealing with the natural numbers, right? Well, you can either assume that the envelope's numbers are specified only up to pennies. Or you can just round and say you don't care about sub-pennies. Or you can go with your suggestion, and look at the lack of a uniform distribution over the reals / rationals.