2 ms·
The GP is not contesting this, they just think that the whole discarding/revealing of the goats is an unnecessarily complicated explanation for why this works.
by tsimionescu 4y ago
The GP is not contesting this, they just think that the whole discarding/revealing of the goats is an unnecessarily complicated explanation for why this works.
The way they put it, the strategy becomes obvious if you instead reformulate the problem like so: there are three doors with three different prizes. You get to pick one door, but are then given a choice: stick with your original choice, or choose to get the best prize from the other two doors.
The solution (switch!) is more obvious in the second formulation. I have no idea if it's easier to convince someone else of the reasoning in the first formulation, or to convince them that the second formulation is equivalent to the original.