3 ms·
> By itself it is nearly worthless (my not-so-humble opinion) for anyone but the most technologically incompetent thermostat users out there Last year, I was l
by egypturnash 15y ago
> By itself it is nearly worthless (my not-so-humble opinion) for anyone but the most technologically incompetent thermostat users out there
Last year, I was living in a house with several people much, much fatter than myself. The living room was upstairs, where the heat collected. My studio was downstairs, partially buried in the ground, which sucked all the heat away. There were heated arguments over the thermostat settings.
Eventually these arguments resulted in a housemate trying to solve the problem by installing a "fancy" new thermostat downstairs - it was a programmable monstrosity with a completely unintuitive LCD display. To this day I am never sure if I ever actually managed to change the temperature it was trying to maintain, or merely dinked around with specifying a temperature that would have taken effect IF I'd put it into the program.
There was probably a manual but I really wanted to talk with the housemates as little as possible to find out where the hell it ended up being stored. I have written fricking 6805 assembly code, I am not technologically incompetent by any means, but I sure as hell couldn't be bothered to try to deduce this thing's operations from first principles.
(Arguably this means the thing did exactly what they hoped it would - make me quit bitching and put on a couple sweaters instead of maintaining a shirtsleeve environment comfortable for a skinny chick in a house largely full of 300lb folks. But I digress.)
> A real thermal management system for the home does not start with a high-design thermostat on the wall. You need multiple types of sensors in every room and multiple outdoor points.
Well, let's see: a Nest has an activity sensor, temprature, humidity, and an Internet connection, which means it can find out what the weather's like outside. Plant one of these in every room and you've got something starting to happen, if you're using local heaters rather than a central system. Admittedly you won't be doing this yet until they get the price down.
> As far as control, a very simple embedded PC board running embedded Linux would be the "lazy" way to build it. It would actually be overkill, but there's an argument to be made for the COGS aspect of it.
Care to lay wagers on what's inside the Nest? I'm betting it's exactly that. You may be willing to spend the time and money to get the thing going and write software for it. But there are a lot of people out there who are not. This is a really attractively simple version of that.
You're describing a level of commitment akin to "I compile my Linux kernels from scratch", this is for the "I open my Mac and it just works" crowd.
- algoshift 15y agoLet's see, for $250 you can spend $10 per room in sensors. Let's say you have 10 rooms. The remaining $150 can easily cover the cost of a fairly intelligent controller. That would be a better system with potential for far more intelligence, particularly if coupled with a simple zone system modification to the AC ducting (valves that can route air where it is needed and prevent it form going where it is not). Something like that would have a far greater effect on the cost and efficiency of controlling an environment than a single expensive thermostat in one room. That's what bugs me about these kinds of products. They never address the real problem. They are only there to find a niche that you can sell a gadget into with some pretext that may or may not exist, like the idea that thermostats are hard to program. OK then, try this one, it's cheaper: http://www.smarthome.com/30429/Venstar-T5800-ColorTouch-Full-Color-Touch-Screen-Thermostat/p.aspx http://www.smarthome.com/30429/Venstar-T5800-ColorTouch-Full... The thermostat is not the problem. Homes (and buildings in general) are wasting energy because we are still approaching thermal management they way it was done 50 years ago. Here in the US it is not uncommon to cover the top of a commercial building with black tar (for waterproofing purposes). And then you wonder why it cost so much money to keep that building cool. These outdated ideas and methods need to change. That's the problem.
- egypturnash 15y agoLike I said above, you're interested in this at "I compile my own kernels from scratch" levels of commitment. The Nest is for "I open my Mac and it just works" levels of commitment. You are quite correct in that the Nest is far from being a perfect solution. But you keep on neglecting to figure in the cost of all the time you spend learning about this stuff, installing it, and frobbing it. How many hours have you sunk into improving your home? What's your hourly rate when you're working? If you LIKE doing it then it's easy to discount that. I'd like to improve my home's energy consumption too, but I'm not interested in spending days and days thinking hard about it, installing ugly boxes on the wall (the Nest looks a hell of a lot better than that box to my eyes, and this does matter to me because I'm an artist), and getting armpit-deep in ducting. Spending a little more money and not having to sweat all the details sounds like a great compromise to me; I might not get the gains you would, but having a smart system I can control from the Internet is still going to make some improvements! Also, reading the Nest's pages, I got the impression that what they REALLY want it to be is one Nest in every room - the things will network with each other. They're just starting, small production runs are pricey. I would bet that they are eagerly awaiting the day when they can sell 3-packs or even 10-packs for what one costs now.