6 ms·
My house is valuable to me even if there isn't a collective belief in it. Most financial assets are backed to some extent by real assets. I'm happy enough to p
by tim333 4y ago
My house is valuable to me even if there isn't a collective belief in it. Most financial assets are backed to some extent by real assets.
I'm happy enough to put value in USD or imaginary-coin if I can swap my holdings in them for a nice house/car/jet. You don't really need "economic, military and even cultural might" - just for the currency to be accepted somewhere where you can buy real assets and for the supply to be limited so it doesn't inflate to nothingness.
- baq 4y agothe point is your belief is not relevant, it's the belief of the counterpart to any transaction that may involve your house ("the market").
- afiori 4y ago> if I can swap my holdings in them The reason people are willing to give away their house/car/jet in exchange for crumpled is the existence of the market protected by that "economic, military and even cultural might". Trust here is not in that the some big guns are protecting your cash, it is rather about you trusting that the next day/month/decade people will want that cash about the same as today.
- coldtea 4y ago>My house is valuable to me even if there isn't a collective belief in it. That's because it also has use value (and land use value), etc. Crypto coins don't have any. >Most financial assets are backed to some extent by real assets. Negligibly so in modern economy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- silon42 4y agoHouse is only valuable as long as the US military has enough $ to defend from Russia/China (taken to extreme, but not if you were in Ukraine).
- tlb 4y agoThe collective belief that you own your home is a crucial part of its value. If you come home and find a bunch of people partying in your kitchen, you can tell them to leave, or call the police and they'll drag them out. That's all due to the collective belief that you own your house. Without that collective belief, owning anything is a huge effort to defend it against whoever else it might appeal to.
- mettamage 4y agoYep, ultimately it's all belief. The fact that we have countries is a collective belief as well. It's feels very similar to a game. A serious one at that, with real consequences. It does not have a clear winning and/or losing condition though.
- abakker 4y agoIt is a game! Hence “game theory” and other reductive, useful abstraction used to describe and model the real world.
- jqpabc123 4y agoThis "collective belief" is somewhat more than mere "belief". It has been translated into laws and social contracts backed by established enforcement that is sufficiently effective and has been demonstrated to the satisfaction and judgment of most people. It's true that in the event of nuclear war, this could all evaporate --- but this probabilty is low enough for most people to reasonably ignore. Labeling this a "belief" is thus somewhat disingenous in the fact that it is reason rooted in logic and judgment and probability.
- mrpopo 4y ago> It has been translated into laws and social contracts backed by established enforcement So, the "long dick" of the US government that grand-parent was talking about. Society creates value.
- 4y ago
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>My house is valuable to me even if there isn't a collective belief in it. If people suddenly stopped believing that living in your location makes sense, the value would drop very much. See ghost towns.
- tonyarkles 4y agoTo a certain degree yeah, but that has an interesting balance of, not being a finance guy, intrinsic vs extrinsic value? A great example is my rural property; my wife paid $1 for the land 20 years ago, and I paid $300 for the 40 year old mobile home we put on it. On the market, it probably wouldn’t be worth a whole lot, but to us it is an absolutely wonderful place that we treasure very much. It’s exceptionally unlikely that anyone would ever offer us a price that would convince us to sell. No one really wants to live in the area we live in! (Although Starlink has had a disproportionate effect on that, now that we’ve got wonderful internet out there) A different belief shifting, though, would change the equation dramatically: either a shift towards less exclusive property ownership (e.g. theoretically requiring any non-primary residence to be rentable or something crazy like that) or dramatically higher tax burden for non-primary residences. If the annual upkeep costs were to increase, the external value wouldn’t change much (it’s already pretty close to zero), but the intrinsic value for us would drop dramatically and we might consider dumping it.
- gitfan86 4y agoI would happily use Tether, Shib, beanie babies, USD as medium of exchange if I trusted that the exchange took place in a timeline I wanted. I'm not comfortable holding tether for more than a few minutes, and I'm not comfortable holding USD for more than a few years. The problem is getting stuck holding the asset for a long period of time. USD will lose 80% of it's value over the next 50 years. Tether likely will lose 100% in that time frame.
- NikolaNovak 4y ago>>My house is valuable to me even if there isn't a collective belief in it. Right. I believe the point of the post you replied to is that while it may be "valuable to you", it also may or may not "have value" (which I interpret as being exchangeable / interesting to other parties), which requires common belief/faith that it has value (basically a circular definition). I could be misinterpreting one or both :)
- usrn 4y agoYou probably don't own it outright and without the collective belief in its value the mortgage would be under water.
- floodle 4y agoYou're confusing having value to others with having value to yourself. I can be happy with a nice rock I found on the beach if I really love it and it's important to me. However, what we are taking about here is are assets which have a wider value on an open market.
- tim333 4y agoYeah but if it has value to me it probably does to others. These kind of things, good houses, land, gold etc. have a good record of retaining some sort of value over long periods of time.
- ajross 4y ago> My house is valuable to me even if there isn't a collective belief in it. It surely is, but this is just a semantic play on the word "value". You mean something like "personally important" in that sentence, the comment you were replying to was using it under its well-established economic definition. In fact, your house is *not* valuable (in the economic sense) if there isn't a collective belief in it's equivalent in currency. Rather: it is exactly as valuable as the market is willing to pay, which is just a statement of the definition of "market value". That's what "collective belief" means in this context.