3 ms·
First, I'd remove the email from the editorial team at the bottom. It feels like doxing. I understand that anyone that is not a moron can find those emails, but
by gus_massa 4y ago
First, I'd remove the email from the editorial team at the bottom. It feels like doxing. I understand that anyone that is not a moron can find those emails, but for that reason I think it's not necessary. Moreover, making morons fail to get the email is a feature.
I tried to read the "Smoking Gun". It's a links to a viewer, so it's not necessary to download the file.
The first section 2 about not publishing a clear script of how the author published the data is so common (at least in other areas) that I'd not bother mentioning it. It would be nice to have that information available (at least in other areas), but the hard true is that in each paper (at least in other areas) you must cross your fingers and try to guess what the author actually did.
Section 3 and 4 are about discrepancies with other source. Most errors look small and are probably not relevant. I'm not surprised. It's not ideal, but I've probably seen worse cases (at least in other areas). Try to focus in big error with big effect. This sound interesting:
> Peculiarly, the mere change in registration cutoff date tripled the effect magnitude for White voters living
within 100 meters of demolition projects, from slightly below -0.05 (decline in turnout by 5%) to around -0.15
(decline in turnout by 15%).
I don't understand the section 6 about other works by the same author. It's common to republish the papers as book chapters or vice versa.
Perhaps there is a smoking gun there, but it's surrounded by a lot of small complains that are (sadly) usual and no one will be concerned by them. Try to find the most clear and most big problem, and isolate it.