4 ms·
> Girard argues that we don’t develop our own desires but want what others seem to want. Garbage. I might feel bad that I haven't read Girard, except that the
by AlbertCory 4y ago
> Girard argues that we don’t develop our own desires but want what others seem to want.
Garbage. I might feel bad that I haven't read Girard, except that the author admits he hasn't either.
> Think about it: rituals before, during, and after the game; group singing; deep emotional involvement; the use of symbols to show that you are part of a certain group. These are all religious aspects. Every club has legendary players; heroic figures, shaped by immortal memories, admired by everyone at the club.
Sorry, Niklas. I've been to Wrigley Field when the Cubs win and everyone sings "Go, Cubs, Go." It's different in America, and by the way, you're welcome to wear the visiting team's baseball cap to a game, too. We know it's just a game.
In the video [1], Girard says:
I think desire usually is born out of the contemplation of someone else who is desiring and who designates to you the object he is desiring as desirable.
Sorry, this is barely even a half-truth. Middle schoolers are walking down the street not looking where they're going because they're staring at their smartphones, and that's where they get desire. If they grow up, they learn to think for themselves.
More from the video:
Peter Robinson [narrator]: Serpent, Eve and apple.
Rene Girard: Serpent in the mimetic theory of desire is a symbol, an image, of the mediator. In other words, the one who directs the subject towards the bad desire. There are churches who know what they are talking about much better than most people think. Know that example is the key to bad as well as good behavior, and this is nothing but what I call mimetic desire.
... and this is why people like to make fun of French intellectuals.
- Mulpze15 4y ago>It's different in America Yes. Not sure how it makes his argument weaker. There is a weak sense of community in US sports fans, where it is well understood that sports teams are first and foremost a commercial enterprise. It is perceived differently in Europe where fans are attached to the team fo r other reasons and want to limit the commercial impact in the sport, probably for some of the reasons explained by the author.
- Niklas96 4y ago> Girard argues that we don’t develop our own desires but want what others seem to want. What's your point here? > Think about it: rituals before, during, and after the game; group singing; deep emotional involvement; the use of symbols to show that you are part of a certain group. These are all religious aspects. Every club has legendary players; heroic figures, shaped by immortal memories, admired by everyone at the club. Sorry, Niklas. I've been to Wrigley Field when the Cubs win and everyone sings "Go, Cubs, Go." It's different in America, and by the way, you're welcome to wear the visiting team's baseball cap to a game, too. We know it's just a game. I see your point. I think you have to take into account what football means for people and that is very different in Europe compared to America. In America, I would argue, it's much more about entertainment. The development in Europe is similar but it didn't use to be that way. Back in the days, these were local clubs, founded by local people who only lived for these clubs. Wright Thompson's piece explains that much better than I could: https://www.espn.com/espn/insider/insider/story/_/id/32218044/super-league-rage-ronaldo-mania-fight-soul-manchester-united https://www.espn.com/espn/insider/insider/story/_/id/3221804... > Sorry, this is barely even a half-truth. Middle schoolers are walking down the street not looking where they're going because they're staring at their smartphones, and that's where they get desire. If they grow up, they learn to think for themselves. That's very true. They stare at their smartphones, see other people and get their desires. It might be true that their beliefs system changes when they grow up and that they think for themselves more often. The tendency to desire what other people want, however, doesn't necessarily change. The desires might differ, maybe also the extent, but I don't believe that the mechanism itself evaporates.
- AlbertCory 4y agoThere's a whole universe of scholarship on the reasons people want stuff. If you think about it, anyone trying to sell you stuff is dying to figure that out. "Because other people want it" is, no doubt, ONE of those reasons. But the only one? Please. As for ManU not being the People's Team anymore: the explanation for that has more to do with money and the structure of professional sports than anything else. I watch the Cubs and don't know half those players, either, and it's not because of globalization. Maybe Mike Trout will play his whole career with the Angels, but most players move around. I'd be remiss if I didn't mention that I have a patent [1] on using "endorsements" to sell stuff! So obviously I'm not denying that there's some role for influencers. [1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US20150363809A1/en?inventor=Purvy&oq=Purvy https://patents.google.com/patent/US20150363809A1/en?invento...
- Kon-Peki 4y agoI’m actually really curious to know when ManU was really thought of as the people’s team. I always thought that Man City was the team for the working class and city dwellers, whereas ManU was the management-class and suburban team.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 4y ago> everyone sings "Go, Cubs, Go." Why are chants so incredibly lame and unimaginative in US sports? Not sure this is supporting the argument that you think you're making. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_chant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_chant
- twayt 4y ago> Girard argues that we don’t develop our own desires but want what others seem to want I don't think that this is precisely what he argues. There is an obvious circularity of logic if you believe this. If everyone only wants what someone else wants, then how does the original desire even come about? I think what Girard is actually saying is that there is a certain kind of desire, mimetic desire (wanting something precisely because it is coveted by others), that is a strong and dominant force in our society and those that have come prior to us.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoThere is mimetic desire. It exists. It happens. Where Girard falls down is that this is not the only way we develop desires. Girard has his system, and wants to make everything fit in it. But his system doesn't actually cover everything, and so he has to amputate everything that doesn't fit. That's... not a good system, and not a good way to do philosophy.
- twayt 4y agoDo you have a source where Girard claims that mimetic desire is the only way we develop desires? The closest quote I could find from him is that "All desire is a desire for being". But I'm genuinely curious if you know of a quote where he claims that mimetic desire is the only kind of desire that exists.
- AlbertCory 4y agoHow about the one I already cited, where he's being interviewed and says: I think desire usually is born out of the contemplation of someone else who is desiring and who designates to you the object he is desiring as desirable. "usually" is not the same as "always", admittedly. But it's fair to say it means "more than 50% of the time, maybe much more."
- twayt 4y agoI would probably agree with Girard that "usually" is accurate if you consider the aggregate of human behavior
- egypturnash 4y agoby the way, you're welcome to wear the visiting team's baseball cap to a game, too. We know it's just a game. I have absolutely no interest in sports but I feel like an important life skill is paying just enough attention to which sports teams are super important to the city you live in and making sure not to wander anywhere near the stadium's neighborhood wearing their traditional rival's colors, especially when said rival is playing. I did not wanna be anywhere near Fenway when I lived in Boston and the Sox were doing their thing. Do not risk accidentally attracting the ire of a bunch of drunk fans all wound up for the game, or by its outcome. Shit gets weird when the city's Important Team makes it to the playoffs, too. I live in New Orleans and I always try to avoid big groups of people clearly wearing team colors for something like the Sugar Bowlbwhen I'm in the tourist zone. They are on vacation in Sin City and they are super hyped because their team's near the top and probably nothing is gonna happen but I sure don't wanna get unlucky.
- AlbertCory 4y agoIt IS unlucky, whereas in the UK, you'd be lucky to escape major hostilities. I was at Dodgers Stadium to see the Cubs in 2015. There were 1000s of Cubs hats there, and this happened to be the day Jake Arrieta threw his no-hitter against the Dodgers. Everyone was standing in the 9th, even the Dodgers fans.
- netfortius 4y agoTerrible comparison between a sport like football (not the American one!) and baseball. I lived in Chicago for 35+ years, and been to Cubs and White Sox games quite a few times (mostly because corporate world likes to do events at such games), and that was in large majority about "socializing around" a game, vs anything like attending a football event, e.g. a game of ManU, Liverpool, Milan, Bayern or PSG. I recall the first few times, when I actually attempted to understand baseball, asking people in the stand to just give me the chance to watch, vs. them walking around with hotdogs and beer, standing up and turning around to converse with their buddies by or behind me, giving me no chance to truly watch the game. And I always got the canned response "who comes to a baseball game to watch the game all the time?". I don't think a baseball "fan" will ever understand what it is to grow up with and be a football one. ... and this is partially (i.e. besides the profits making engine) why some Americans hope to get, by buying European football clubs. But they can't get the fan spirit. It just doesn't work.